Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Lifelong romance and huge mistake. How do I stop thinking about this?

48 replies

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 16:59

Despite being in different relationships, I have had one person I've loved all my life, off and on (now mid 40s), but not always been with. Someone so important to me, but it didn't turn out how it should've. It is really bothering me, and I wonder if anyone can help, or just have useful thoughts.

I met A when I was a teenager, we were both shy and quiet. We became best friends and spent all our time very close, we loved each other but were very pure types. When it came time for me to leave town for university he told me he loved me, but I was so frozen into inaction, I loved him too deeply. We went our separate ways and each had our first partners, who lasted for years.

At age 23 we were both single and bumped into each other at a party in our home town, where he lived and I was back for the weekend. We had a lovely evening and at the end of it he told me he had always loved me, and I said the same back, but I couldn't open up enough to follow it through. We went our separate ways and had long marriages and children with other people. I moved back home and our partners became friendly with each other and we saw each other around, it was normal on the surface.

After my divorce I saw him again, he was just in marriage breakup. He told me he still loved me and to my shame we started a love affair, for a year and a half, he lived in his own place, had a schedule with the kids. I call it a love affair because we never tipped it over into a real thing. He said it was too much of a big deal and he couldn't handle it. Off he went. I started seeing someone, and so on. We fell out over it, I suppose.

However it broke my heart. I think about him every day. Not just as a lover but as my favourite person and best friend. I feel ashamed and unhappy and can't shake it off. We don't speak to each other now, and I don't know if his ex (a very nice lady in my social orbit, who I see with a new man) knows, or not. She is friendly with me when she sees me. I don't know if he tried to go back, or what he is doing. There is a silence between us that I find very hard.

What can I do? It is just that there is such a lot of history and I miss him. The time I did text him, he said he couldn't handle his feelings. He is a hider of a man, has very few friends, is a bit of a recluse.

Does anyone have any advice apart from that I'm silly. He is one of my favourite friends and the rift and destruction is making me feel so very bad. Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
EmbroideredGardener · 07/02/2026 17:07

I don't think you're silly, but I do think you need to move on for your mental health. All the ups and downs of this story sound exhausting. I'm not sure why he keeps saying he can't handle his feelings and yet he manages relationships with others? He sounds a bit pathetic in that regard really (sorry to be harsh)

Could you afford counselling to help you work through it

SoScarletItWas · 07/02/2026 17:14

I don’t think you’re silly, but I do think you’re basing this all on fantasy and imagination. You’ve never experienced the realities of each other, of living together, of how your personalities and values mesh or clash.

You’re missing what you hoped and imagined life would be like. And probably missing a bit of your youth - the bulk of this seems to have happened as teens and early 20s. I don’t blame you for that!

Even during the affair you didn’t live together and see anything other than the ‘best behaviour’ person he wanted you to see.

He sounds avoidant, anyway, and not someone able to commit to his feelings.

If you keep clinging onto these ifs and maybes, you won’t have space to find someone who WILL commit.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:15

I am having weekly counselling. I don’t have any family and so he was like that for me. It is a hard loss. I wish we could go back to before. I am also racked with guilt about did I ruin his marriage (which I knew is irrational, his ex was having an affair). I can’t tell what she knows when I see her.

OP posts:
VanCleefArpels · 07/02/2026 17:15

So you’ve never actually had a kiss even? So your romantic compatibility is entirely in your head? If you were looking at a dating profile and it said “I’m a hider, have few friends and I’m a bit of a recluse” would you think”ooh that’s the chap for me”? Sounds to me that you are in love with an idea not a person. Time to set yourself free.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:16

Oh no, we’ve had a kiss at 23 and then a year and a half of sex from 2023.

OP posts:
VanCleefArpels · 07/02/2026 17:17

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:16

Oh no, we’ve had a kiss at 23 and then a year and a half of sex from 2023.

Ok, fair enough. But still. It’s not happening is it? Never will.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:18

This is what I need to hear @VanCleefArpels!! it is helping me.

OP posts:
TheMorgenmuffel · 07/02/2026 17:19

People who actually want to be together - get together.
This is a fantasy. Neither of you put much effort into making it a reality and I expect thats because on some level you or he or both of you didn't want to ruin the fantasy.

You both had relationships with other people. This mushy mills and boone star crossed lovers stuff is not reality.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:20

I love everyone saying this. Yes, I usually remember that. I’m having a bad patch and the comfort of as you say, the fantasy, has returned.

OP posts:
TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:23

What I also should have said is that unlike other stuff, I can’t tell any of my friends this, so that is why I’ve turned to you to give me the proper glass o wine mates talking to.

OP posts:
OneOfEachPlease · 07/02/2026 17:26

I think there’s a big narrative in films that first love is the most important love and the one you never get over. And it actually makes me very cross! Your other deep relationships have given you much more and were much more meaningful than this fairly fantasy based interaction. He doesn’t actually sound like he’s got very good social skills and that might well be why you’ve had some of these missed opportunities. I really hope this doesn’t come across as harsh! But I’ve been down this particular rabbit hole myself and trying to see things for how they really are helped.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:27

No, he has terrible social skills and also a troubled childhood.

OP posts:
Iwontbethere · 07/02/2026 17:29

Perimenopause and limerance are the cause of this.

Focus on enjoying the bliss of being free of blokes and do things you love.

Thanksforyourlackofthought · 07/02/2026 17:32

It's not a lifelong romance. It's a lifelong fantasy.
If he wanted to be with you, he would. He's had the opportunity.
Move on OP and find someone who is able to give you the relationship you want and deserve.

summitfever · 07/02/2026 17:32

Op this is absolute limerance on your part. He has no intention of being in a relationship with you. He’s managed to get in and out of relationships with other people in that time so he is capable, and you’ve made your feelings clear so he has a clear run if he wanted it. I’m sorry but he doesn’t. Do yourself a favour and erase him from your life. No contact, no reminiscing, focus on yourself. Do you have adhd at all? Sounds more like a hyper fixation Than anything, you need to break the spell, his just out of reach position but with a slither of hope is keeping you stuck. Get in reality and set yourself free. And I bet he isn’t even worth all this, sounds like a bit of a knob. Is he even a good friend? Reality check required here!

Oblivionnnnn · 07/02/2026 17:35

All this ‘I loved him too deeply to open up’ etc is romanticised crap.

When it’s right and true none of that is an option. You make it happen. And trust me, I turned my world upside down for the right person.

He wasn’t your person. He still isn’t your person. It will be so freeing and healthy for you to move on from him.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 17:39

Thanks everyone. I am giggling through my tears now. You’re right.

OP posts:
Jellybunny56 · 07/02/2026 18:03

Oblivionnnnn · 07/02/2026 17:35

All this ‘I loved him too deeply to open up’ etc is romanticised crap.

When it’s right and true none of that is an option. You make it happen. And trust me, I turned my world upside down for the right person.

He wasn’t your person. He still isn’t your person. It will be so freeing and healthy for you to move on from him.

I really agree with this. Some people come into your life and are meant to stay, you KNOW when you find one of those people because nothing feels too much or too little or too difficult, for either of you.

The two of you were not meant to be, not meant to stay, and that’s okay. That's life.

whatwouldlilacerullodo · 07/02/2026 18:22

Looks like he is not willing/ brave enough/ whatever to pursue it, and go for a relationship with you. That's shit, but a relationship needs 2 people and there's nothing you can do.

I went through something similar recently. It doesn't matter how much I wanted to give it a good try, the guy didn't. Maybe he was scared, maybe he didn't like me enough, it doesn't matter. I had to accept it (I tell myself if he didn't want it, then he was not the right person).

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 07/02/2026 18:24

It’s a fantasy. I’d keep it parked as that.

TapsOff · 07/02/2026 18:32

@whatwouldlilacerullodo I’m sorry you understand the feeling. But you’re right.

OP posts:
TikTokker · 07/02/2026 18:36

It’s absolute poppycock. You’ve had plenty of chances for it to work and it didn’t. He’s not your lobster. Move on and don’t give him another thought.

Laiste · 07/02/2026 18:42

You weren't ships that passed in the night - with you wistfully wishing you could have moored up together ...

The ships collided and moored up and it didn't work out.

Cut and dried, simple as that.
You gave it a go and it didn't work. If you gave it another go it still wouldn't.

Dint waste your life pining about this it's daft.
💐

ChaToilLeam · 07/02/2026 18:48

Honestly, if it was going to work, it would have. Time to draw a line and move on.

mcmuffin22 · 07/02/2026 18:50

This may be spectacularly unhelpful but.. I had someone like this. It never quite worked out.

However, 9 months ago I realised how much I still thought about him and messaged (after years) and we are really happily in a relationship now. We have done a LOT of talking and are now finally on the same page. It feels like a really great relationship and we are both very conscious of investing time and talking everything through.