Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Stuck in Relationship Limbo: Financial Practicality vs The "What If?"

54 replies

Honest00lad · 05/04/2025 20:57

Ladies of the forum (and blokes lurking in the shadows), I come seeking your collective wisdom while trapped in that classic midlife muddle. Financial climate being what it is, I'm sure I'm not the only one white-knuckling through this particular rollercoaster.

Here's my situation: I'm with someone who knows me better than my own mam (God help her). We've shared everything from brilliant holidays where nothing went wrong except my dancing, to holding each other through life's proper disasters. The photo albums are full, the inside jokes are plentiful. 2 beautiful DD's.

But somewhere between matching pajamas at Christmas and discussing whose turn it is to empty the dishwasher, things changed. The bedroom has become more of a sleep laboratory than anything else. And while I'm staring down the barrel of middle age (when did THAT happen?!), I've got this nagging voice wondering if there's someone out there who'd be a better fit.

Finances make it all the more complicated. I earn a decent wage (nothing to write to Martin Lewis about, but I'm not eating beans on toast every night), but if I left, I'd be financially stretched. Between maintenance payments and suddenly shouldering a mortgage solo, my bank account would be giving me the side-eye. She's spent years being the main parent while I built my career, so her earning potential took the hit. I feel I should at least wait until she's back on her feet career-wise. I'd give her the house without question – help her get the mortgage in her name and all that – but the timing just feels cruel right now.

Then there's that old saying about not knowing what you have until it's gone. I lie awake some nights genuinely terrified that I'd be tossing away something irreplaceable. Our story has all the makings of one of those "50 years together" features in the local paper. But this bloody itch just won't leave me alone. It's like having a pebble in your shoe during a marathon – you can ignore it for a while, but eventually, it's all you can think about. I'd be genuinely heartbroken to let a love story like ours end, but equally scared of staying for the wrong reasons.

I keep telling myself it's not just about fancying someone new (though let's be honest, the ego boost wouldn't hurt). It's about wondering if I'll be 80, looking back, and thinking "should've been braver, you daft old git."

The practical side: I'm basically staying put until maintenance payments end and the kids are grown. But emotionally? I'm all over the shop.

So my questions to you wise women of Britain:

  • Do women go through this too, or is it just us blokes being predictably cliché?
  • Has anyone took the chance and regretted it?
  • Has anyone wished they'd taken the leap when they had the chance?
  • Has anyone weathered this storm and come out the other side with something even more beautiful?

Because right now, it feels like I'm choosing between two different ways to mess up my life, and both options come with a side of regret.

Any wisdom (or mockery – I can take it) appreciated!

OP posts:
Honest00lad · 08/04/2025 17:55

NImumconfused · 06/04/2025 14:34

Staying put until the maintenance ends - well that's lovely, isn't it? So you've used your wife for her child rearing and house keeping services, but you'll generously hang around until you reach the point where you won't need to compensate her for that and then pull the rug out from under her with a limited career history, and much reduced pension.

All because "scratching an itch" is more important than decades of living marriage. She deserves better than you.

@NImumconfused I don't think you've read the whole thread. Not even the OP. Confused not only by name...

OP posts:
Honest00lad · 08/04/2025 18:04

tarheelbaby · 06/04/2025 12:22

Definitely make a huge effort to build your relationship as non-parents: book those weekends, hotel rooms, dinners, walks in the park. Treat her like you want to be around her and you fancy her - flattery might just get you everywhere. Don't worry if your bedroom at home is a sleep lab - take her to some new bedrooms. Invest in your friendship/relationship with her - it will involve some spending but it will be a better use of money that anything else you can buy.

Flirt - all the time - like your sex life depends on it. Give her a little kiss on the cheek and a hug or squeeze her shoulder - don't try for a snog but be physically affectionate. Sit on the sofa and watch something together. Just hold hands or sit close enough to be touching - I craved this but my DH would just start pawing me.

Compliment her - this can be very basic: 'You look nice today' 'I like that top'. Those little interactions are so important. They are the links that keep your physical life going.

If my DH had done those sorts of things, we would have been a lot happier. Most of the time, I felt like a disappointing employee. He wasn't unkind but he wasn't enthusiastic and attentive either. He only touched me when he wanted sex. I was so lonely.

I really appreciate this post and the others and you've made some good points, about putting efforts into relationships.

I don't think I can cure the sex problem. But I'm not too bothered. A lot of people have assumed it's her not wanting it very often, but it's a mutual thing. I want it, obviously not as much as my 20s. It's just quite boring with the same person for almost 20 years. That's not a reflection on the other person or even the relationship, it's just what can happen.

I want to do all those things you mention and do them well. I didn't view myself as fortunate but now I do after reading the posts. I lost sight about what is important and what I have

OP posts:
noidea69 · 08/04/2025 18:08

if you were a woman everyone one would be telling you to go for it and you "owe it to yourself".

As you're a man just be honest and say that you fancy shagging about with a some women in their 20/30s.

Realistically you need to give your head a shake and start treating your wife with a bit of respect.

Honest00lad · 08/04/2025 18:09

noidea69 · 08/04/2025 18:08

if you were a woman everyone one would be telling you to go for it and you "owe it to yourself".

As you're a man just be honest and say that you fancy shagging about with a some women in their 20/30s.

Realistically you need to give your head a shake and start treating your wife with a bit of respect.

It shouldn't make a difference what I am, but yeah you are probably right

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page