Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

How do you know when to end a relationship?

62 replies

Northnotts85 · 30/10/2024 16:55

I've been in a relationship with my DP for almost 2 years now and while things started out brilliantly between us, I'm beginning to feel like we have too many differences to make things work.

There have been some minor issues throughout - we live a 90 minute drive apart and he has a teenage boy with some learning difficulties. This has meant that I spend every weekend at his house and he very rarely (3 times so far in 2024) visits my house. I live in a rural area and my DP (understandably) worries that his boy will get bored here - he has an XBox etc at home and that seems to keep him happy. I'd be lying if I said I didn't find the travelling and being away from my home difficult - I'm relatively new to my area (2.5 years here now) and not being here at weekends has made it difficult to form any real friendships. It also means I have to do all my chores and housework in the week after work (and sometimes end up helping him with his at weekends). But although it's occasionally frustrating for me, my DP was upfront about his situation from the off, so any resentment has mostly been swallowed and we make it work.

However, my DP has a very short fuse and over the last year or so has started to get angry, snappy and impatient with me a lot. This can happen when it's something contentious such as me raising an issue within the relationship. But he can also be triggered by the most trivial things: I didn't give him an instant yes or no opinion on an outfit he was thinking of wearing to the pub last weekend and I got my head bitten off. He says it's 'infuriating' when I don't answer a straight question - I'm quite a considered and sometimes indecisive person and am not always quick to provide an answer or an opinion on things because I like to allow myself time to think and respond. His impatience makes me feel quite bad about myself.

I strongly believe that two people can experience the same thing differently and feel opposite emotions in response to the same situation. But I feel that my DP often dismisses my feelings out of hand, is very quick to raise his voice, and tends to invalidate my point of view often. He's told me on more than one occasion that I'm 'being oversensitive'.

To be clear, I'm not afraid of my DP hurting me and there's never been any indication of physical anger. But I've increasingly found that I only have the confidence to challenge things within the relationship after a couple of glasses of wine - which is not a healthy way of dealing with things and leads to arguments and fall outs. Sometimes, because I've had a drink, I get frustrated at the reaction I get and I end up saying horrible things that I regret (which is also completely unacceptable).

I've had several months of therapy to try and improve my methods of communication. But the more therapy I've had, the more I'm coming to realise that his anger and invalidation is a barrier to me tackling my problems. I've tried to discuss this with him on several occasions but I sometimes feel that while I'm prepared to take accountability for my bad communication skills, he isn't. Whenever we have an argument, it's usually me that ends up apologising even if he's yelled at me.

We had a discussion at the beginning of this week where I laid all my cards on the table and he agreed to work on his temper and impatience issues too.

There are also quite a few other problems/things of concern:

Our sex life is pretty much a non-starter as my DP feels weird about being sexually active while the boy is in the neighbouring bedroom.

My DP recently complained during an argument that I don't contribute enough to group conversations when we're out with his friends. (My counter to this would be that he's told me that I'm 'just not very funny' in front of his friends when I've made a joke in the past and often seems to sneer at my contributions generally (he has a very sarcastic sense of humour and would say that this is just him joking around - but hardly a confidence boost or incentive to join in).

He can be quite thoughtless sometimes. To give an example of this, we recently couldn't go to a concert we'd booked tickets for because his childcare fell through at the last minute. I offered to try and sell the tickets on my social media, but he said he would do it himself. He only managed to sell one ticket and kept all the money for himself even though we'd each paid separately for our own tickets. AIBU to think that an offer of splitting the recouped money (and both of us being a little out of pocket rather than him getting his money back and me losing all of mine) would have been the kindest thing to do?

The difficulty is that there are strong feelings there. I do love him and he says he loves me (for all our faults). And my decision whether or not to call it quits is clouded by my having formed a good relationship with his boy. I'm also turning 40 soon and hate the thought of starting back on the dating scene all over again!

Am I just being naïve to think (hope?) that with a bit of work we might be able to turn this around? What has prompted you to finish a relationship in the past?

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 31/10/2024 19:04

Didn't even read it all but get rid of him

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 31/10/2024 19:05

Read 'it's not you' by dr ramani

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 31/10/2024 19:07

I say leave him and I'm your age... there are no benefits to you staying with him (you certainly don't want a child with a man like him) and lots of benefits leaving and being single (or meeting someone else - if you want a nasty user they are ten a penny so don't feel he's irreplaceable, if you want a decent guy you'd have more chance on the apps then holding your breath for him to become nicer)

LBFseBrom · 31/10/2024 19:07

You do not need this man but you know that, The minuses far outweigh the pluses in the relationship.

Break it off, have a new start and aim to meet a man who will put in as much effort as you and has no dependent children. They do exist.

Lamelie · 31/10/2024 19:10

@Northnotts85 @DracunculusVulgaris
Apologies for this teenage suggestion but listen to Taylor Swift, So Long London

You're trying so hard but you shouldn’t.

Flowers
Catoo · 31/10/2024 19:18

He’s horrible.
And, he should have given you all of the ticket money back not half.

Get rid OP.
💐

Hoosemover · 31/10/2024 19:33

i think you need leave this man… you aren’t getting anything from the relationship.

newbeggins · 31/10/2024 19:36

Short tempered people are hard work.

LadeOde · 31/10/2024 19:41

DracunculusVulgaris · 31/10/2024 13:22

Hi @LadeOde, it is I who is the 61 year old - OP said that she is 39

Oh I'm so sorry! that'll teach me not to read so hastily. Well my comments still stand but to you in that case, and @OP at 39 should not tolerate this either. Why would you both at this stage of your lives subject yourselves to self flagellation because that's what this is? Very little joy for some much sadness and hurt in return. You don't have to put up with this and if you're thinking this is the best it gets because of your age, you're wrong.

AcrossthePond55 · 31/10/2024 19:59

@Northnotts85

Just remember that you're never going to meet Mr Right when you're all entangled with Mr Wrong.

Think of a peaceful weekend in your still-new-home. Getting up on Saturday when you want, a leisurely breakfast, perhaps a walk or lunch with your yet-to-be-met friends followed by a quiet evening or even a date with someone who values you as a friend and equal. On Sunday puttering around getting your house in order for the work week so you can really relax after work on Mon-Fri.

Think also of the savings in petrol and expenses incurred in your every weekend 'commute'. You might even save enough during the course of a year to help defray costs on a nice holiday to a place of your choosing.

DexysMidniteRunners · 31/10/2024 20:18

DracunculusVulgaris · 30/10/2024 18:46

My goodness OP! I could have written your post almost word for word, the only difference being that I am male and older than you. Nearly 3 years together, I live rurally, my partner has also only made the effort to visit me twice this year, to give her grandson a holiday in the country, I travel, every Friday, after work, to her city, 75 minutes drive away, and leave early hours of Monday morning and drive straight to my place of work. I, too, walk on eggshells around her, because of her constant irritability, anger, loud, sweary rants, being used as an 'emotional punchbag', farmed out every weekend to help her family and friends with gardening projects (that is my profession ), fearful of how much alcohol she has consumed as it makes her behaviour even worse (and I am teatotal, having been brought up in a household with an alcoholic mum). The constant belittling, humiliating, degrading comments have worn me down and I am a naturally quiet, reserved, introverted personality and rarely speak up! My vocabulary and the way I speak are criticised, my manner of dress is commented on, my eating is 'policed', I am told that I am too quiet around her friends and I am, apparently, secretive - I just don't have much to talk about much of the time as our interests and attitudes to social activities are polar opposite. I have also learned not to feed too much information or fears and insecurities to one who will melt them into bullets to use against me.

Like you, this past weekend, we had a discussion about our future - for the first time ever, on Saturday night, she physically hurt me and then, on Sunday, claimed that it didn't happen, and that if it did it was just in 'fun' and 'playful'. I actually found my voice and found the courage to give her a very stern, measured, calm talking to and put her on notice that if it ever happens again I will be gone for good. I don't think it will actually work, however, and am preparing to stick to my guns and end the relationship. Like you, I have to cram everything into four short evenings a week at home, as I am away in her city for the remainder of the week. In a way I would almost relish being on my own again, having time for my own garden, my bees, chickens and other hobbies!

The similarities are astonishing OP, I feel for you, and although unable to offer you any advice, I can offer solidarity, my best wishes and hope that you are able to make the correct decision for YOU, as I have to do to protect my mental and now physical wellbeing. Good luck OP!

Please just leave. Live your life in peace...alone but not on your own. Too much emphasis on being partnered - you don't have to be

Naunet · 31/10/2024 20:26

I’d say a year in and he knows you’re invested so he feels comfortable and is now showing his real self. He may say he loves you, but it’s worthless if this is how he treats you. Plus, love is frankly not enough anyway, there also needs to be respect, kindness, trust, care and affection.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page