Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Why do you come on MN Relationships and offer advice?

97 replies

InterplanetaryCraft · 12/04/2024 16:48

I’ve wondered about this issue for ages, including in relation to myself. What are people’ personal motivations?

I will add my own motivations a little further down the thread - still thinking about this too – but don’t want to influence other people’s by starting first, if that makes sense.

OP posts:
CleanShirt · 12/04/2024 18:58

I got a lot of help from MN years ago when I was leaving an abusive relationship, and have had mega support when stbxh left me 4 months ago. Feel like I've been through the mill a few times and might have some helpful insights.

Damnyourheadshoulderskneesandtoes · 12/04/2024 18:58

Because I grew up hearing and witnessing domestic violence and alcohol abuse and if my small voice can reduce the chances of even one child growing up like I did, it's worth investing hours of my time telling other women not to accept those things in their home.

EverybodyLTB · 12/04/2024 19:12

For me, as my username probably suggests, it’s a motivation to tell most people to LTB. Not that all men are bastards, of course. It’s just that so so so many women post here with horrendous situations that they don’t deserve and, more importantly IMO, their children don’t deserve. I believe that many women are out there not realising that actually they can very much LTB. Not always easily, but we can work out a way for it to be done and to change the trajectory of their lives.

I’ve had my own very shitty marriage and I now understand that my shitty childhood primed me for a ‘charming’ narcissistic cunt. I have a wide group of friends and most have been in or are in quite horrible relationships. We are all without exception better off as single mums. The only friend of mine still married is horrendously miserable and it breaks my heart.

I always want to (depending on OP, obvs) validate the OP, and call abuse what it is, but oftentimes I want to shake up the OP and push them to find their anger for the sake of their children. Having left my EXH, who I’d allowed to stay way too long ‘for the children’ and lived to regret it, I want to feel like I’m achieving something by telling someone else how foolish this path is. There can be an arrogance on my part, as maybe I deep down believe that what I say will hit the mark? I’m also guilty sometimes of getting upset and frustrated with an OP and being like PRIORITISE YOUR fucking KIDS!!!!

My own childhood just makes me pretty much zero tolerance when it comes to kids suffering. I can’t bear it when someone comes on with a new boyfriend/kids being treated like shit post. It sends me a bit nuts and I’m much less diplomatic on those threads.

I just sort of think, in all, mn is about the joy of sisterhood, in all its highs and lows. I can’t bear to see any woman asking if the abuse they’re suffering is their fault, or if it’s even abuse at all, I feel almost duty bound to tell them there’s a better way. I was out having a lovely long day and night with my real life friends last week, and when I woke up the next morning, a bit tired and nursing a strong coffee, I was straight back on here saying things like ‘you can leave, see a solicitor, think about how this is effecting the children, you don’t deserve this’. I’m a completely lone parent, with multiple kids, stressful job - I feel a bit like I’m authorised to say it’s doable.

It’s just an extension of the care and straightforwardness I try to give friends in my day to day life, and I try not to be outcome oriented in general when it comes to advising anyone. It’s about looking at something from an unbiased (maybe) perspective and giving honesty and fairness, whilst keeping it kind and non judgemental. Whether I always achieve that, IRL or on MN I can’t say….

Highlighta · 12/04/2024 19:17

I don't want other women to go through what I have.

I'm older and wiser now.

I post things here that I would say to my daughter. Just in the hope that even one typed line just may make a difference to someone some day.

asquire · 12/04/2024 19:46

I found the advice here really helpful when I was looking for it, both from others on threads that I posted but also in reading the threads of others in similar situations.

Checking it just became habit, and nowadays I just post when I feel like I can offer insight from something that I've experienced myself.

Gerwurtztraminer · 12/04/2024 19:56

Damnyourheadshoulderskneesandtoes · 12/04/2024 18:58

Because I grew up hearing and witnessing domestic violence and alcohol abuse and if my small voice can reduce the chances of even one child growing up like I did, it's worth investing hours of my time telling other women not to accept those things in their home.

Yes that's a lot of my motivation too. I was that kid too and so many women excuse shit men with 'he's a great Dad' or think the children don't see the abuse. No he's not and yes they do, they really do.

Plus I've had some life experiences and made my mistakes and sometimes feel that's relevant to either share or get a poster to look at something in a different way.

And I guess it's fascinating reading about other people's lives and the dilemmas they face. So not just motivated by some selfless desire to help but also something else I can't fully explain.

ohthejoys21 · 12/04/2024 20:02

I come on if I see someone in a situation I've been in and want to help.

bluejelly · 12/04/2024 20:13

I was in an abusive relationship and Mumsnet helped me realise it and get out.
Now am sorted and with a wonderful DP, and want to pay it forward.

stargirl1701 · 12/04/2024 20:16

Because it is so hard to read the stories of women who are being abused and not being able to recognise the situation they are in. Boiling frogs.

Isometimeswonder · 12/04/2024 20:17

I comment because I want people to know that it's OK to be on your own. I was single for a long time, years and years. I wanted a relationship but wasn't willing to compromise myself.
Married now, but not til late 40s. (He's a good one)
There are worse things to be than alone.

TheFormidableMrsC · 12/04/2024 20:17

Because I had endless support on here during my divorce. It was amazing. So now I will pass on the benefit of my own experiences and I'm useful sometimes with the legal aspects. Why wouldn't you help if you can?

Riceball · 12/04/2024 20:24

Mumsnet relationships board got me out of an abusive relationship 12 years ago. It took reading threads and asking for advice for 2 years before I felt strong enough to do anything. Never looked back.

Endoftheroad12345 · 12/04/2024 20:38

I ended my marriage to my abusive exH in November 2022 and in the aftermath I think I read every single post here on abusive men, ending abusive relationships, how they tend to behave e.g. around finances, children etc - it was chilling how closely he copied the playbook. This board was so, so helpful for me.

Now I have got through it (largely - it takes 2 years to legally divorce where I live 😵‍💫). I am so happy, I am free, I have my kids 90% of the time, I bought out the family home, my career has flourished, I have met a wonderful man, my kids have a happy and calm life, I am in therapy figuring out why the fk I stayed with such an arsehole so long and making sure I never tolerate that behaviour again.

I post to share my experience and to let other women know they can do it too.

GreenhouseGran · 12/04/2024 20:41

I haven't given any advice yet ,I feel I maybe should try after reading this thread.I have learned a lot from Mumsnet relationship pages,this would have helped me so much if there had been Internet in my earlier married years,not too late to help someone though.

wplaf · 12/04/2024 20:44

Because I see people with a lot less life experience than me writing about shitty situations, which they have slipped into - a horrible partner has worn them down bit by bit until they think that the shitty behaviour they are on the receiving end of is normal/expected.

Pashazade · 12/04/2024 20:49

If it isn't something I've had experience of then often just to show compassion by letting them know that someone has heard them, that someone is listening. To offer encouragement when they are wobbling. If for someone we make a collective difference then it's worth my time and effort and I've seen it so many times, it makes me happy to know that a bunch of strangers have helped lift someone out of a bad situation and into a better life. Restores my faith in humanity regularly.

InterplanetaryCraft · 12/04/2024 20:57

I will read and chip in myself at some point on this thread, I’m sorry haven’t been able to yet today.

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 12/04/2024 20:58

I find it cathartic reading advice when people who have been in similar situations to me are being reassured by everyone, I also like to give the reassurance I needed to others for similar reasons

Cathbrownlow · 12/04/2024 20:59

it's been really interesting to read everyone's motivations and I know that mine is the same: difficult childhood and abusive relationships with men. As others have said I really wish mn had been around when I was a younger woman - I felt very trapped and alone when I was in an abusive relationship in the past and I want the posters being abused to know that they are being heard and supported as much as one can through the internet.

xSideshowAuntSallyx · 12/04/2024 21:07

My ex was an abusive twat, who knocked all my self-confidence out of me. I so wish I knew about this place back then.

If even just one person reads my experiences and thinks they're helpful then that's one less person who has to go through what I did.

Although on some I do have an opposing view and it saddens me that many women don't trust they're husbands or other women.

Endoftheroad12345 · 12/04/2024 21:12

Being in an abusive relationship is so lonely. For me, no one knew. I am outwardly very successful, I’m a reasonably high profile lawyer, I’m very well liked and I think reasonably attractive! I have a nice house, we had a nice life, holidays in the Amalfi coast, a beach house - 2 lovely kids, a cat, a dog, a white picket fence 😵‍💫

No one would have realised that it was not uncommon for me to have dealt with a screaming man smashing the house up before I dropped the kids to school, that I I was told how fat and horrible I was more times than I could count, that I was beaten around the head and given a black eye when DS was 1 because I told exH it was his turn to get up to him in the night.

I nailed on a smile and put on an Oscar worthy performance for years. We were together from when I was 20 until when I was 41. I remember posting here about how exH said the abuse was “only a 3, maybe a 4/10, max” 😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫 Even though I always stood up for myself, always argued back, always told him he was abusive a part of me did internalise it, did think that somehow I caused it. Because he only ever behaved like that to me.

Now I know I didn’t cause it, no one “causes” that. He was and is an abusive man who treated me like that because he thought he could get away with it and it suited him
as a way to control me. He was threatened by me and his abuse was a calculated way to diminish me and make me small.

Someone said on here that abuse in a relationship is the fleck of shit in the Michelin starred meal. Even if 99.9% of the meal is perfect, you wouldn’t eat it if you knew someone had flicked dog shit into it. I found that so helpful … instead of justifying staying because of “all the good stuff” it changed my mindset and freed me to leave.

Whattodowithit88 · 12/04/2024 21:16

With age comes experience comes wisdom. Pass it down.

Also I give straight forward (sometimes blunt) advice because I know from experience when your in love you just can not see it, even though it’s very plainly obvious to everyone else. If you don’t voice they won’t question it.

IncompleteSenten · 12/04/2024 21:19

I see commenting on threads being like thinking about hypothetical situations really.

Here is the situation.
If you were in it, what do you think you would do.

I don't know what that makes my motivation.

gamerchick · 12/04/2024 21:21

HotBotHarry · 12/04/2024 16:53

I read relationship threads a lot, comment sometimes. It's because I really wish I had had MN when I was younger and in an abusive relationship.

Yup. Years and experience of total dicks. You don't forget what they say or do, or their motivations.

GotBeatenUp · 12/04/2024 21:26

When I was in a relationship I would read the board without realising I was a frog in boiling water.
When I needed it I found support here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread