Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Should I keep my options open?

49 replies

BumbleBeeElle · 24/10/2021 00:15

Apologies, this is my first time posting on a forum so bare with me.

I am in a good relationship, however I feel I am in a bit of a limbo. I just don’t know where I stand. Just to give you a back story, I have been in a relationship with my OH for just over 2.5 years. Absolutely adore him and for the first time in life I feel very much loved. I get treated well and taken care off. OH is 39 and has 2 kids, I am 33 no previous marriage or kids. He has been married before but he left within 6 months.
I came along 8 years after the end of his previous marriage. You’d think that by then someone would have made their mind up about what’s next. However I don’t think OH knows what he wants!

There are a few issues here. To start, having any serious conversation with him never ends well, about 6 months ago I tried to have an open discussion with him about where he thinks we are headed, I simply asked if he saw marriage in the future for us, no pressure but just to find out if we are on the same path. Sadly the conversation ended because he said he felt like I was forcing him into marriage…. Ummm okay. At that moment I decided to take a few steps back, I collected a few eggs out of the basket, if you catch my drift. From then on I have been very weary of any serious conversations because I don’t want the tension that comes afterwards, but thoughts of it are constantly floating on my mind. It’s as if there’s questions I can not ask because they are above my pay grade!!

He’s not exactly the easiest person to talk to because you never know which way a conversation can go. Recently I’ve come to notice that at times it’s “I” then other times it’s “we”. It’s as if he forgets that we are a team, it’s we not I.. anyway those little things are nagging at me now more and more.
I have noticed that he has a big problem with trust, he trusts no one in life, myself included. Which is really upsetting to see. Some days I feel there is a future, other days I wonder what the heck I am there for. I feel as though I am just floating along hoping something will happen. Some days are so tough, especially when I see colleagues, friends and old school friends getting engaged etc and I have no clue if that’ll happen for me. Marriage and commitment are important to me. I’ve had 2 previous serious relationships which have both ended badly, 1 cheated and I did not see it coming and the other married someone else behind my back.

When the first lockdown was announced he asked me to come and live with him until everything was okay, which I was happy about, it was great and we definitely kept each other sane. He asked me to stay as he said he loved living with me. However in May he suddenly decided that I should find somewhere else to live, because he will be starting building work in June/July (he is building his own home) and there would be so much noise plus also because he didn’t recall asking me to permanently move in. This took me quite by surprise but I didn’t react, I went and found myself a room to rent in a lovely home. Now, whenever I leave his to come back to mine, only a few miles down the road, he seems sad, he has made comments about how much he hates it when I’m not there.

I definitely think he has issues with people being in his space for too long, it’s a pattern, even with his kids. I am now questioning other things like his refusal to post/ be tagged in photos of us on social media, he says it is because he’s a very private person, then the next time he’ll say because he doesn’t want to upset his kids and ex wife. I do spend time with him and his kids now and then, so it’s not as if there is no clarity about us being in a relationship.

Now to my question, I am not the cheating type nor do I condone it. However I am beginning to wonder if maybe I am better off keeping my options open because I can see myself in this same place in 5 years time. I am not getting any younger and I certainly don’t feel secure.

Apologies for the long post.

OP posts:
FortunesFave · 24/10/2021 05:37

I'm almost 50 and if you were my daughter I'd be telling you to leave.

That's mostly how I think about questions on MN these days...you're only 33. It's young still...you're free as a bird and he's hampering you from moving on to the next stage in your life.

Get rid.

Tell him why too. Don't let him make you feel you can't speak your mind on these things. There's no shame in wanting a family and a marriage

romdowa · 24/10/2021 05:50

It really sounds like this guy is just stringing you along. If you want marraige and kids of your own then I'd be walking away from this situationship if I were you . He will waste your fertile years.

Aquamarine1029 · 24/10/2021 05:54

I strongly advise you to put your trainers on and run for miles. What a headcase that man is. Please stop wasting your time, and at 33 you should be very picky as to who you invest your time in. This man is a road to nowhere.

There are a few issues here. To start, having any serious conversation with him never ends well, about 6 months ago I tried to have an open discussion with him about where he thinks we are headed, I simply asked if he saw marriage in the future for us, no pressure but just to find out if we are on the same path. Sadly the conversation ended because he said he felt like I was forcing him into marriage….

Fuck this guy. He's a walking red flag.

Monty27 · 24/10/2021 06:03

You have already been pussy footing around his wants and needs during the lockdowns now you've moved out at his behest.
I'd say move on as I waited 13 years with someone that never did anything to move the relationship along. Don't do that. Free yourself now. Please don't waste any more time on this person.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 24/10/2021 06:12

He's going to rob you of your fertile years.
He's just a tyrekicker who's happy to be getting his hole.

RantyAunty · 24/10/2021 06:31

Time to get rid.
His actions have made it very clear he sees nothing long term with you but is happy to use you.

parrotonthesofa · 24/10/2021 06:35

You deserve better

Aprilx · 24/10/2021 07:55

The time to call it a day on this was back in May when he asked you to move out. That showed a relationship going backwards not forwards.

You are wasting your time, more importantly you could end up missing key years for starting a family. I think he is trying to keep you hopeful with his pretending he is sad to see you go home. Remember he asked you to move out..

frozendaisy · 24/10/2021 07:59

It's 10 years or so since his marriage broke up and you can't tag him on a SM photo in case you upset his ex?

dotsandco · 24/10/2021 08:15

You need to ask??

Read your post back, as if someone else had written it, and ask yourself what advice you would give!

My mind boggles sometimes at the low expectations some people have 😥

category12 · 24/10/2021 08:20

Stringing you along. Stop wasting your time.

When he asked you to move out again, that should have been it. You should have ended things then.

But it's not too late. Dump him now.

Namechangenumber23 · 24/10/2021 08:33

Yes. In answer to your post title, I would keep your options WIDE open by separating myself completely from him now. Don't allow him to restrict you any further from pursuing what you want in life. The fact he has got you to a point where you avoid talking about things in life that are important to you is enough. That he has denied / backtracked on how he feels about something / what he said would just solidify that choice for me.
You know what you want, where you ideally would like to be in life with him/in general and not only has he shut you down in that, he has got you into a position where he calls all the shots, he moves goalposts and changes them to suit him. At best he is a dick at worst (referencing him denying asking you to stay living with him) he's gas lighting you and neither of those is good.
The social media issue is just plain odd. His reasonings are ridiculous and are likely a convenient excuse/lie. 10 years on and he is concerned about the reaction of someone he split from 10 years ago and children who (presumably after 2.5 years) already know of your existence?
It's possible HE is already keeping his options open.
It's good that you are set up and not living with him now. It will be easier in the practical sense to cut yourself loose. I sense that if you do though he will backtrack and try reeling you back in, make empty promises, things would seem better for a while and find yourself back here no further on or better off in 2/5 years time.
Good luck OP. It's tough but your feeling are valid and you deserve better.

pisces3 · 24/10/2021 08:39

This is coming from someone who's been in your shoes quite recently.
Move on and stop wasting your time and energy on this man .

category12 · 24/10/2021 08:40

It's possible HE is already keeping his options open.

Yes, very possible that he's hiding the relationship on SM so he can appear single to other women.
And having you move out after lockdown - so he can have women back to his place. Convenient to have you there when dating options were limited.

Glitterb · 24/10/2021 08:54

If kids and marriage are key things in your future then you need to consider whether this is the right relationship for you. At 2.5 years in i would like to think he would be capable of having an adult conversation about your future. If one of your friends told you this, what advise would you give them?

I know it’s hard, I’m the same age as you and walked away from a relationship earlier this year for the same reasons, it was ultimately for the best as I can move on and meet someone on the same page.

saleorbouy · 24/10/2021 08:59

From his past history, reactions to conversations and lack of looking towards the future he is not a commitment type of man. He obviously likes his own space and there doesn't seem to be room for you.
If you want commitment move on if you're happy in limbo stay around.

Thisismyusernamefornow · 24/10/2021 09:16

I think you should leave as it doesn't sound like this man can commit to a future with you.

I've recently come out of a 2 year relationship that broke off halfway through when I realised he couldn't give me the type of relationship I wanted. I regret terribly getting back with him as nothing had changed and being in the relationship trying to force the basics (time together, talks about the future, photos together) was exhausting. I am so tired now.

So basically, if it feels wrong, it likely is.

Be strong. Don't waste these important months and years. This chap sounds like he has some serious avoidant attachment issues that you don't need to stick around for.

Limeeye · 24/10/2021 09:33

This man is steering YOUR life here. You will regret it.

Rainbowqueeen · 24/10/2021 09:38

Just end it. You want different things.

Look for someone who wants the same things as you

hg165 · 24/10/2021 09:39

I think it sounds like the type of man he is (from his past) and that he has commitment issues.

So while i wouldn't take it personally, I wouldn't hang around. You deserve better.

I'd also be telling him exactly why I was leaving

Malena77 · 24/10/2021 09:43

I wasted 5 years of my life waiting for someone to finally commit and make the next steps. He promised and ‘really wanted to’ - but never did. On a daily basis I felt loved and looked after, like never before. Turned out it just a stopover relationship for him.
Leave. Don’t waste your time.

samesign · 24/10/2021 09:44

I would definitely move on, he asked to move back out, he had the opportunity to create a future with you living together and he pushed you away. He's not wanting to discuss marriage with you because he doesn't want it. Find someone better.

TheSquashyHatOfMrGnosspelius · 24/10/2021 09:45

Your gut is screaming at you. Listen to it and run the fuck away.

altmember · 24/10/2021 09:46

I think you really need to have a straight and honest conversation with him about whether he wants any more kids. Marriage might happen or not, in any timeframe. But you've obviously got quite a narrow window of opportunity for having children. And if he doesn't want any more himself then you clearly need to set him free and look for someone else who does. I suspect it's the answers that you're weary of, rather than the questions.

FlowerArranger · 24/10/2021 09:47

You say there are a few issues. But they are HUGE issues. Ignore them at your peril.