I am a 31 year old woman and I have recently split with my boyfriend (he is 28) after I realised that we couldn’t solve the issue he has with being honest. We were together for 3 years and lived together for 2. Our cultural differences also contributed a lot to this (we are from two different countries).
He was the most caring and compassionate boyfriend I ever had. He was my best friend, the first person I always asked for advice and help, and I was the same for him. Always putting my needs first, a great romantic and affectionate lover with a big heart. I have been very spoilt in the last 3 years as he always treated me like a princess. He always been very loving and respectful with me, wanted to marry me soon and have kids in the next couple of years.
However, for some reason, when we moved together after one year of relationship, I started to have a terrible gut feeling and felt that he wasn’t completely honest with me. I started to have anxiety problems and started to go to therapy, thinking that I was crazy and the fault was only mine. I have also started to be more investigative and jealous with him, sometimes for no apparent reason. I have thought that my parents relationship (where my dad has been cheating on my mum for years) really affected my ability to trust men and that I needed to fix that as I had an amazing boyfriend next to me.
However this did not explain why I did not have the same fears with my previous boyfriend whom I lived together for almost 5 years, and with the boyfriend before him. Of course I was moderately jealous (as most of latin passionate people are !) but I never ever had a single trust issue with them.
Over the years, I have realised that my boyfriend has lied to me many many times, mostly little, but MASSIVELY lied about ALL his sexual past.
I have to admit that I am a bit the iper sensitive woman who gets upset easily, but also to add that I mainly became this way after the first year. In the beginning of the relationship especially, I was very relaxed so I don’t understand why he felt the need to lie to that extent.
I could sometimes justify men’s lies if they have a iper sensitive woman as a girlfriend. But what about if the way they lie is actually more worrying that the lie itself? What about if they deny evidences and make many false promises ? And what about if the extent they lie is just quite remarkable?
I give some more specific example on what happened with us:
- On our first dates, I asked him if he ever paid for sex. He denied it saying that he never needed it and find it disgusting. As I am really against prostitution and this is my biggest dealbreaker (but he didn’t know that in the beginning) I have asked this question multiple times to him in the last 3 years(I just felt he wasn’t honest) he always ALWAYS denied and promises 10000 times he did not. 3 years later I found out that he did in the past in several occasions, and seems like he cheated on his ex girlfriend with prostitutes on a trip to Thailand (he told me he left this girlfriend because she cheated on him, “forgetting“ to say that he did it first). He even lied on his previous girlfriend as well, saying he never cheated on anyone. I have found out he also cheated on her many times (he was really young though).
- As I come from a culture where hooking up and having sex around with strangers is very unusual, the first date I have asked him (always in a non judgement way) how his sexual past was, without wanting specific details or numbers. He told me that “he wasn’t a saint but he wasn’t that bad”. Months later he even added that “he was never a one night stand person“, and mostly slept with girls after having dated them. He even been slightly annoyed when I told him the number of my sexual partners, which is relatively low. Few days ago I find out the he had sex with 300/400 girls -all one night stands (he previously told me his number was about 30 in total!). I know this sounds crazy but it is very possible as he worked 6 seasons abroad in a party place, and because I have also worked a season there, I know how the situation is. He also denied having done anything too crazy (sexually) then I discovered he had threesome, orgies, sex in toilets with random strangers etc.
- He came back home multiple occasions lying to me on his occasional cocaine use. I have a past experience with drug use so I have always caught him! Sometimes he even strongly denies the evidences then confessed hours after. I have proved him that I would not get upset if he told me and that I just needed to know the truth in case I’ve asked, but still kept lying.
These are just few examples but there are more. The thing that worries me most is the way he lies, which I find quite manipulative: he promises me (the fake) on his family’s life, he tells me things like “you know I would never do that to you , I can tell you anything as you are my best friend, you can trust me” followed by another lie. Basically he builds massive stories around the lies he tells. He is good at it, but my gut instinct is stronger than his ability to lie.
He got upset because “the past is the past” and I cannot “deal with his past”. What about if I never had the chance to deal with his past as it was hidden from me for 3 years? I am not saying people should be completely honest about their sexual history in the beginning of the relationship, but at least they should give a good accountability on what happened, so that the partner can choose if they even want to deal with it or not and rather date someone else.
I don’t want to judge people, but I think I had the right to choose which kind of man I wanted as my future husband, and I never wanted someone who paid for a prostitute. He knew I felt so strong about it but kept denying. I feel like he forced me to be together 3 years with someone I did not want to be with. He said he did it out of love, but I think that real love should be thinking about the other person’s needs first.
The way I found out all these things is definitely not honourable: I have checked his phone multiple times in the last few months, after I have realised he wasn’t honest with me. I am very embarrassed about that, as I have never ever did it in my previous relationships and I don’t want to be that person. The old messages I found (when he was around 19 to 23) were also very disrespectful towards women, calling them with all possible names and sharing nude pictures of them with all his friends. Some of them were also a bit racist. Do all guys to this between them? I have also been more childish in the past, but my core values have always been the same.
Last month we had a massive argument for the same reason explained above. He promised me he would stop lying and go to therapy, he never did. He knew it was the last chance I would give him. Few days ago ago I discovered more lies and I have broken up with him. We are not talking in 5 days and it never happened before.
However, guilt and sadness are killing me and I don’t know if I did the right choice. I really want to get married and have a family, and I feel I’m getting older and I have just failed in another relationship. I just don’t really want a man like my dad and I don’t want to take the risk! I am also aware that I get upset easily and I haven’t always put him in the position of being honest with me. I am so worried I have made the biggest mistake of my life and lost my soulmate and best friend.
Ps: I am registered on here because we were actually trying to have a baby, you can imagine the stress I’m going trough knowing that all of this is over.
Thank you very much if you would like to take the time to help me.
Lila