Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

My boyfriend and I broke up and I did some stuff with some other guy too soon after and we got back together

50 replies

Yesus339 · 27/01/2021 14:59

All I need is some advice. My boyfriend and I have been dating for 4 years. In 2019 I had an issue with one of my guy friends and I really didn’t know (being quite naive and not really understanding that this happens in relationships as I was only 18 and this was my first relationship). This guy started like me and he told me. I really didn’t know how to react to it and so I thought that maybe I had feelings for him too? I broke up with my boyfriend because I really didn’t want anyone getting hurt. Over time me and this guy kept talking and my ex boyfriend kept trying to get back with me (as I was still completely in love with my boyfriend I was obviously not really telling him to go away), so I had this dilemma that I had to pick between these two guys. I ended up taking way too long and decided upon choosing my ex. A couple of months later I went off to university and within the first week at uni I spent it in hospital because I had a ruptured ectopic pregnancy (it wasn’t panned) I went back university and I had completely missed the social stage as it was a month or so after university had started. I was in a complete mess, both my boyfriend and I hadn’t come to terms with what had really happened. I kept telling people that I had an appendicitis and found it really hard to be able to talk to it with anyone. I signed up for counselling so many times to talk it through but I was too scared to actually face it.

Anyway, I was trying way too hard to get people to like me by drinking large quantities and going out clubbing late. I accidentally at one club borrowed some guys £500 jacket and ended up losing it. I spent the whole evening trying to find it. However I was incredibly pissed (which isn’t an excuse) and ended up going back to his house not really remember much except for me trying to get away from this guy - I have memories of trying to run away from him. Long story short, I spent the evening in his bed but NOTHING happened at all. I woke up in the morning and realised that the guy that was next to me looked like the splitting image of my boyfriend. I also realised that I had texted my boyfriend saying “help me” countless times. I straight away ordered a taxi and left the guys place. I instantly told me boyfriend what had happened and he ended up, understandably, breaking up with me. I was so so upset with him, I thought he’d trust me and understand that I was incredibly in love with him and that we had recently gone through something that adults would’ve found difficult (I was 19 at the time). My friend’s were telling me that I might as well live my life and I really wasn’t expecting for him to take me back. I went clubbing every night after and ended up bumping into the guys 4 nights later. We had a conversation and we decided to get pizza and watch friends at his house, some reason it escalated and we ended up fooling around. We had conversations in the morning and as my dad is an opera singer and I had a free ticket to one of his operas. I offered it to the guy because noone else wanted to go. I left in the morning only to find that my boyfriend had started to message me suggesting that if I was ever in a situation like that again it’s incredibly dangerous and I could’ve been taken advantage of or worse raped. I missed him so so much so I thought that maybe it was my chance to get him back. During all this I did take this guy to opera and I did end up going back to his house again. But later my ex boyfriend was able to give me a second chance. I completely pushed this guy away. I didn’t think that it was a thing and I really wasn’t interested in him. I think maybe it was to do with me just not accepting what had happened with the ectopic and me just wanting someone to be there. In the long run we got back together a couple of weeks later and we’re incredibly happy for year. But I felt incredibly guilty about doing all this stuff with that guy so I thought that being honest to my boyfriend about him would really help improve my relationship and I hated the idea of having a long term relationship (hopefully getting married someday) and my boyfriend not knowing. I also knew that telling him would really risk it all but I would rather be in an honest relationship than our relationship being a lie. His reaction to this was obviously awful, he messaged the guy and asked what had happened and the guy told him everything. He didn’t even tell him the truth he said that we were together for a month (it was about a week or two but we were never a thing or that was never communicated) but he didn’t want to be with me so he ended it which really really was not true. He also told me that when we broke up before he had fooled around with this girl and he told me a few days ago that nothing actually happened and that if he only new that he could do stuff with other people he would’ve. He’s been in such a bad place and I’ve been in utter agony the past few days because I know I’ve caused him pain and I hate that. He’s really the man for me and I can’t think of my future without him. I met up with him (social distanced) and we decided that we’re going to have a 2 month no communication break. He asked me so many times if anything else happened and I kept trying to not tell him because I didn’t want to hurt him and it really wasn’t very helpful when I started getting defensive when he was asking what had happened so I really really messed up with that too. He kept asking and asking and reluctantly told him everything. I’ve come up with some relationship counselling that we can do together after so we can talk through the ectopic and maybe help with our relationship too? Bearing in mind we’ve had a perfect year where we have been together and it hasn’t been rollercoaster-y and the guy from those nights really meant nothing to me. I’ve treated him so well like whenever he’s siad he’s depressed I’d go to his house in London (I live in Oxford) and give him a card, chocolate and flowers. I also booked out a fancy hotel room when we first started our 2nd year at university! My boyfriend now thinks that I cheated on him too and even though the messages from the time were “I don’t want to be involved with you” and “I have nothing left to say” I’m really not the person to cheat and I really didn’t but he has that in his mind now. In really not a horrible person and I always put peoples feeling before mine. I know this is so messed up but he means the world to me and is there anything I can do? Maybe during this break or after to make him understand that everything that happened was just a huge mistake and that I only want to be with him? I really should’ve told him either straight away or should’ve just waited longer before actually doing stuff with the guy. It also really didn’t know what to do because most of the people I know sis that “it’s okay you were broken up” I understand that but if it was the other way round I would feel exactly the same way. How do I prove to him that I our relationship is worth while and that I really do love him. I think one aspect is that I really could’ve chosen the easy way out. The break that originally happened back in April, I chose to go back to my boyfriend after that even if it meant that I had a long time to get his trust back and two after staying in that guys bed, it really took a while to regain his trust again but I would’ve tried for such a long time too. Even now I knew that this would really effect our relationship but I knew that it was the best to tell him even if my timing is a little off. Any other person would’ve just not told him but I did come forward because I knew that was the right thing to do!

OP posts:
DinosaurDiana · 27/01/2021 15:01

You need to put some more paragraphs in before I can attempt to read it !

Silenceisgolden20 · 27/01/2021 15:18

Have you posted about this before?

Pinotwoman82 · 27/01/2021 15:23

This reads very familiar

Wanderlusto · 27/01/2021 15:24

I think I've somewhat got the gist. But it might be helpful as pp said to put in paragraphs. Even just copy your original post and paste it here with some.

OP uni days are tough at the best of times. I remember one specific year of mine being the most ridiculous drama ive ever had in my life. Mostly because of too much drink and poor choices that revolved around boys.

Your bf is right that you put yourself at risk with that guy (probably because he tricked you into feeling guilty about the jacket). You have to be aware that men can be exceedingly dangerous to an intoxicated woman.

I do think you should see someone to chat with about your ectopic pregnancy as it is still playing on your mind. There's usually someone at uni available or they can direct you. Seriously, get this dealt with so you can move forwards.

As for the bf...could you just take the break? Theres a saying 'what's for you wont go by you'. Take the next two months to focus on you. Your feeling and your needs. And by that I dont mean need to be with him. Put him in a bix in your mind and lock it and put away the key and make the conscious choice to just look after yourself, get any help and support you need and learn to like your own company.

And fir what its worth, a relationship where you have to constantly prove your devotion/innocence/loyalty/trust is not healthy, its toxic. And if that is how it is going with him,he is most certainly not the man for you.

Yesus339 · 27/01/2021 15:25

I’ve added it again but with the paragraphs put in, thank you! 😊

OP posts:
Yesus339 · 27/01/2021 15:29

(Here are a paragraphed version 😬) All I need is some advice. My boyfriend and I have been dating for 4 years. In 2019 I had an issue with one of my guy friends and I really didn’t know (being quite naive and not really understanding that this happens in relationships as I was only 18 and this was my first relationship).

This guy started to like me and he told me. I really didn’t know how to react to it and so I thought that maybe I had feelings for him too? I broke up with my boyfriend because I really didn’t want anyone getting hurt.

Over time me and this guy kept talking and my ex boyfriend kept trying to get back with me (as I was still completely in love with my boyfriend I was obviously not really telling him to go away), so I had this dilemma that I had to pick between these two guys. I ended up taking way too long and decided upon choosing my ex.

A couple of months later I went off to university and within the first week at uni I spent it in hospital because I had a ruptured ectopic pregnancy (it wasn’t panned) I went back university and I had completely missed the social stage as it was a month or so after university had started. I was in a complete mess, both my boyfriend and I hadn’t come to terms with what had really happened. I kept telling people that I had an appendicitis and found it really hard to be able to talk to it with anyone. I signed up for counselling so many times to talk it through but I was too scared to actually face it.

Anyway, I was trying way too hard to get people to like me by drinking large quantities and going out clubbing late. I accidentally at one club borrowed some guys £500 jacket and ended up losing it. I spent the whole evening trying to find it. However I was incredibly pissed (which isn’t an excuse) and ended up going back to his house not really remember much except for me trying to get away from this guy - I have memories of trying to run away from him.

Long story short, I spent the evening in his bed but NOTHING happened at all. I woke up in the morning and realised that the guy that was next to me looked like the splitting image of my boyfriend. I also realised that I had texted my boyfriend saying “help me” countless times. I straight away ordered a taxi and left the guys place. I instantly told me boyfriend what had happened and he ended up, understandably, breaking up with me. I was so so upset with him, I thought he’d trust me and understand that I was incredibly in love with him and that we had recently gone through something that adults would’ve found difficult (I was 19 at the time).

My friend’s were telling me that I might as well live my life and I really wasn’t expecting for him to take me back. I went clubbing every night after and ended up bumping into the guys 4 nights later. We had a conversation and we decided to get pizza and watch friends at his house, some reason it escalated and we ended up fooling around. We had conversations in the morning and as my dad is an opera singer and I had a free ticket to one of his operas. I offered it to the guy because noone else wanted to go. I left in the morning only to find that my boyfriend had started to message me suggesting that if I was ever in a situation like that again it’s incredibly dangerous and I could’ve been taken advantage of or worse raped.

I missed him so so much so I thought that maybe it was my chance to get him back. During all this I did take this guy to opera and I did end up going back to his house again. But later my ex boyfriend was able to give me a second chance. I completely pushed this guy away. I didn’t think that it was a thing and I really wasn’t interested in him. I think maybe it was to do with me just not accepting what had happened with the ectopic and me just wanting someone to be there. In the long run we got back together a couple of weeks later and we’re incredibly happy for year. But I felt incredibly guilty about doing all this stuff with that guy so I thought that being honest to my boyfriend about him would really help improve my relationship and I hated the idea of having a long term relationship (hopefully getting married someday) and my boyfriend not knowing. I also knew that telling him would really risk it all but I would rather be in an honest relationship than our relationship being a lie.

His reaction to this was obviously awful, he messaged the guy and asked what had happened and the guy told him everything. He didn’t even tell him the truth he said that we were together for a month (it was about a week or two but we were never a thing or that was never communicated) but he didn’t want to be with me so he ended it which really really was not true. He also told me that when we broke up before he had fooled around with this girl and he told me a few days ago that nothing actually happened and that if he only new that he could do stuff with other people he would’ve. He’s been in such a bad place and I’ve been in utter agony the past few days because I know I’ve caused him pain and I hate that. He’s really the man for me and I can’t think of my future without him. I met up with him (social distanced) and we decided that we’re going to have a 2 month no communication break.

He asked me so many times if anything else happened and I kept trying to not tell him because I didn’t want to hurt him and it really wasn’t very helpful when I started getting defensive when he was asking what had happened so I really really messed up with that too. He kept asking and asking and reluctantly told him everything.

I’ve come up with some relationship counselling that we can do together after so we can talk through the ectopic and maybe help with our relationship too?

Bearing in mind we’ve had a perfect year where we have been together and it hasn’t been rollercoaster-y and the guy from those nights really meant nothing to me. I’ve treated him so well, whenever he’s siad he’s depressed I’d go to his house in London (I live in Oxford) and give him a card, chocolate and flowers. I also booked out a fancy hotel room when we first started our 2nd year at university!

My boyfriend now thinks that I cheated on him too and even though the messages from the time were “I don’t want to be involved with you” and “I have nothing left to say” I’m really not the person to cheat and I really didn’t but he has that in his mind now.

I’m really not a horrible person and I always put peoples feeling before mine. I know this is so messed up but he means the world to me and is there anything I can do? Maybe during this break or after to make him understand that everything that happened was just a huge mistake and that I only want to be with him? I really should’ve told him either straight away or should’ve just waited longer before actually doing stuff with the guy.

I also really didn’t know what to do because most of the people I know sis that “it’s okay you were broken up” I understand that but if it was the other way round I would feel exactly the same way.

How do I prove to him that I our relationship is worth while and that I really do love him. I think one aspect is that I really could’ve chosen the easy way out. The break that originally happened back in April, I chose to go back to my boyfriend after that even if it meant that I had a long time to get his trust back and two after staying in that guys bed, it really took a while to regain his trust again but I would’ve tried for such a long time too. Even now I knew that this would really effect our relationship but I knew that it was the best to tell him even if my timing is a little off. Any other person would’ve just not told him but I did come forward because I knew that was the right thing to do!

OP posts:
LivingMyBestLife2020 · 27/01/2021 15:31

Sorry OP, that’s far too much to read!

LaVitaPuoEsserePiuBella · 27/01/2021 15:33

Totally unreadable.

How old are you?

Respectabitch · 27/01/2021 15:33

Another thread on this? Are you just going to ignore all advice you get and keep posting the same dilemma over and over again?

Look: You broke up. It didn't work out. You are not together any more. It really doesn't matter why, or whether you did anything objectively wrong, which you didn't. It did not work with the two of you, you've messed him about spectacularly in the past, and he doesn't want to be with you any more. This is what happens generally with relationships when you're at uni. You're young and immature and mostly they end up not working. Like this one.

You are telling yourself a story about how much you adore this guy but your behaviour doesn't match it. If he'd always been the one for you you wouldn't have dumped him, then taken ages to decide that maybe you'd go back. You sound less in love with him than desperate not to be alone.

Be alone. Take a complete break from speaking to him and grieve the relationship. Because it's over, and even if he took you back now, you'd break up again.

BornIn78 · 27/01/2021 15:34

You went back to a random guy's flat, stayed the night with him, texted your boyfriend saying “help me” countless times during the night, and then phoned him the next morning going "hey, it's ok, nothing happened" - and you're surprised he split up with you?

JorisBonson · 27/01/2021 15:34

I swear this was taken down a couple of days ago.

Raidblunner · 27/01/2021 15:36

Gave up

Onthedunes · 27/01/2021 15:45

As other posters have said, a little too long to read, but from what I can gather essentially you wish your boyfriend to come back so you can keep using him as a back up regardless of what behaviour you inflict on him.

Yes ?

somethingonthecarpet · 27/01/2021 15:46

You poor thing. This sounds like it has all been very hard, and you are young, which means that you might not have made the best choices.... BUT you just did the best you could at the time, and I really think you can forgive yourself completely because nothing you have done was deliberately cruel or hurtful to anyone at all.

My best advice now is to try and keep away from your boyfriend. Don't keep badgering him. I understand that you desperately want him back and for it to work, but give yourself a little time and distance and maybe it will all work out. I am pretty old now and the best piece of advice I can give you when things like this happen and you feel so worried is 'this too shall pass'. And it does. You just have to teach yourself to wait it out.

Sunshineandflipflops · 27/01/2021 15:54

I lost the will part way through but got enough to know you have a lot of growing up to do and perhaps aren't ready to be in a relationship.

Illy605 · 27/01/2021 16:06

I’m sorry to say it OP, but this will never be a healthy relationship. Your boyfriend will never be able to fully trust you again and you’ll spend every day jumping through hoops to prove yourself to him.

Take these two months to heal yourself. Cut off all contact with your ex and try to stay away from alcohol fuelled nights and other boys. I’m sure by the end of it you’ll realise you are holding onto something you know yourself is toxic and has run its course. Everyone deserves the chance to be in a stable, happy and loving relationship. Don’t hamper your chances of having that.

CharlotteRose90 · 27/01/2021 16:14

It’s hard but look at the facts you’ve cheated on this guy twice and it’s clearly not working. Take this time to work on yourself and stop going back to him. I wouldn’t trust someone that cheated on me and would always have issues. It’s not fair to either of you .

Figgygal · 27/01/2021 16:17

Leave the man alone
Take the next 2 months to work on yourself and moving on not a countdown before you can try to get back with him
I’m sure you’re not a nasty person that’s not what this is about but you are young and need to learn from this

goldielockdown2 · 27/01/2021 16:21

It sounds like love/thrive on drama. Have you addressed this with yourself? Could it be boredom?
You did some normal young person stuff, settled down with your guy and had a great year then decided to spice things up by telling him a load of shit that happened which he really didn't need to know as you were single at the time.
Just be alone for a while and or take up a hobby.

Blueberryflavour · 27/01/2021 16:31

I can’t go all through your post to pick out bits it sounds crazy. Look we were all involved in dramas when we were young and finding our way in life and drinking far too much. Casual boyfriends came and went, sometimes they overlapped a bit, it happens. I’m pretty sure that if I had met some of those men, or one of them in particular, when I was older we might have had a proper grown up long term relationship but I was too young and having fun as were they. Most, but not all, people don’t end up with the person they met when they were your age, at your age you should be dating having fun, this is way too intense just move on. Having dated a lot when younger when I was a bit older I met a nice man and was ready for a deeper connection we were together 3 years then had a couple of other longish term relationships before I met my DH. Don’t rush in to a bad situation or try to force something just to have a boyfriend.

samanthawashington · 27/01/2021 19:14

You are far too immature for any relationship. Get yourself STD checked as something could have happened you don't remember, and lay off the booze and men until you grow up more

whenthestarsgoblue · 27/01/2021 19:20

This isn't ever going to work. Seriously I know you're a young girl, but this is so immature. No amount of relationship counselling is going to solve this. Leave the guy alone.

user194729573 · 27/01/2021 19:22

What happened to your previous identical thread on this subject?

Aquamarine1029 · 27/01/2021 19:23

This again? Did you not get enough advice the first time? It's over, op. Just accept it and move on. Work on your emotional maturity.

GreenlandTheMovie · 27/01/2021 19:28

Standard for first/second year at uni. Perhaps give yourself a break from men and look to resume again by the summer if the feeling is still mutual.

Swipe left for the next trending thread