Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

In-laws - What would you do?

31 replies

MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 13:52

I’m currently going out of my mind trying to figure out what I should do regarding my MIL and SIL, or if I even should do anything at all.

I cheated on DH almost a month ago - I’m not proud of it at all. I feel fucking awful and utterly disgusted with myself, never in my life have I thought more lowly of who I am and what I’ve done - but thankfully, DH wants to give us another go and he believes he’ll be able to get over it with time. I couldn’t be happier that he’s found it within himself to forgive me and I’m counting each and every one of my lucky stars right now.

The issue at the moment though, is his family. DH is currently living with his sister as we’ve decided to ‘hit a reset’ button on our relationship and start dating one another again, taking things slowly, rather than move back in together straight away and pretend like nothing happened.

The day after he moved in with his sister, I received a very long, ranty message from SIL. She didn’t hold back in telling me how vile and disgusting she thinks I am and that apparently both her and MIL have been telling DH for years that they essentially hate me and haven’t liked me from the get-go. She then proceeded to remove me on Facebook, which was understandable and fair enough.

Upon reading her message and seeing that she’d deleted me, I clicked on my Facebook newsfeed, to see that MIL had written a post saying about how she wanted to ‘smash a certain someone’s head in’ - or something to that effect, and both MIL and SIL were talking to each other on the post, laughing and joking about hurting ‘me’ (they obviously wasn’t naming names) and how SIL would help MIL with the ‘smashing’.
When I read the post and the comments, I then did what I thought was the sensible and right thing to do.. I removed myself from the rest of his families profiles, 1) so they didn’t have to see my posts anymore and further their hurt and anger, and 2) so I didn’t have to see my in-laws publicly slagging me off and trashing mine and DH’s relationship.
A mere ten minutes after I’d deleted MIL, MIL decided to message me. She kept her message short and sweet, and simply said ‘unfriend you have, bothered I am not. YOU’RE A WHORE. I’m not as polite as my daughter’.

The following day, DH came to see me to tell me he wanted to give things another go and said that he’s confident we’ll be able to work through things together. I asked DH if he’d told his family what his decision was, and he said he’d be speaking to them once he went back ‘home’ (to his sisters). The following morning, DH told me that he’d spoken with his sister and she apparently said she wasn’t happy with his decision, but if it’s what he truly wants, then she’ll stick by him and give him her full support. I thought that was nice of her to say, only to then discover later that afternoon, that his sister went on to block me on Facebook and Instagram (previously I was only unfriended), as did MIL. Now, I get that they’re hurting too, and I completely understand that if I hurt their son/brother that will upset and anger them, I can never try and refute that. But, to me, you can’t tell your brother/son that you fully support them, only to then go on and block their partner after saying said sentence. I feel like that’s not supportive to DH at all.

Now, what I’m about to say here is in no way me trying to excuse what I’ve done and the mess that I’ve made - but, DH is no angel himself. He’s put me through a lot while we’ve been together, I won’t go in to the ins and outs of everything he’s done, but I know that what I’ve had to put up with over the past couple of years, would be enough to make the majority of women walk away. However, I never did. I always stuck by him, I always strived to make us work. Even after he did some appalling things, I stayed by his side. So it’s with that in mind that I’m confused as to how his family have thought I’ve been vile for years. Excluding my recent catastrophic fuck up, I’ve been good to DH on the whole, even on the days when I really didn’t have to be. I know why they’re angry at me now, of course I do, but I’ve been going out of my mind these last few weeks trying to figure out exactly what it is I’ve done in the past to make them despise me so much.
DH doesn’t really see eye to eye with SIL and MIL, I’d even go as far to say that he doesn’t like his own mother - he'd rather not see her than spend actual quality time with her. He's essentially told me to ignore their comments and remarks, that he doesn’t give a fuck what they think and he’ll never let their opinion of me get in the way of him and I. But I’m struggling. People’s opinions of myself really get under my skin and make me lose my mind.

My final point, throughout everything DH and I have gone through, my family have never once got involved. They understood it was between DH and I, and even though there were times in the past when both of my parents were absolutely fuming at DH’s behaviour, they never said anything to him. They knew that if he and I decided to work things through, then they’d just look stupid for sticking their oars in and causing more drama in our lives. I think because my family react so differently to his, it’s making me wonder which family handle things correctly? Are mine wrong for not getting involved? Should they step in and say things to DH when we’re going through problems? Or are DH’s family out of line here?

I’ve told DH that it’s unlikely his family and I will ever be able to be in the same room again. I very much they’d want to be, anyway, but knowing they’ve hated me for years despite the fact that up until now, all I’ve done is stuck by their brother/son has left me feeling bereft. I also said to him, that should he ever want me to patch things up with his family, then I of course will do that for him, but he basically said he doesn’t really care whether that happens or not.

What would you do? Attempt to apologise to his family, explain yourself, do the damage control? Or cut your losses and go no contact? I’m so torn with what the right thing to do is, but I desperately want to do whatever is right.

OP posts:
Mintjulia · 24/07/2020 14:00

I'd not try to explain or apologise. What goes on in your marriage is between you and your dh.

They clearly have their opinions but I wouldn't worry about them at the moment. They sound pretty horrible anyway, and if they have always felt that way, you haven't lost much.

I'd concentrate on rebuilding your relationship with your husband, that has to be your priority. Leave the family for later.

AnneLovesGilbert · 24/07/2020 14:07

Don’t apologise to them, let them stew.

Are you sure this warrants patching up? He’s behaved terribly towards you, you’ve now cheated on him, you sound like you’d be better off apart. Find someone who doesn’t treat you badly, who you don’t want to cheat on and whose family aren’t violent and abusive.

bigchris · 24/07/2020 14:13

This sounds an awful situation

I think if you truly love each other and think the marriage is worth saving I'd have him living with you not his sister who , although he says he wont listen, will be saying vile things

Do you have children ?

What will happen at Christmas and birthdays

Is he ready to compartmentalise his life for you ?

MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 14:17

I do believe it should, and will be patched up. We both want it to be. Interestingly, over the last few weeks of us 'dating' it's almost felt like the old days, before life got messy and problems caused havoc. We've been through a lot as a couple, and as individuals, but even though it's early days, I can see a change in us, a good change, and we both feel it too.
DH has admitted to a lot of his wrong doings, which is something he's never done. Together we're being more attentive, more considerate, we're talking and being more open, spending 'actual' time together as opposed to just existing in the same home. We're both really trying to put in the effort at the moment, and right now, it's working.

Do you really think his family are abusive? I can't work out whether how they've acted is ok or not really, hence largely why I'm here now!!

We won't be living apart forever, we plan to move back in together in a couple months once the dust has settled and we've put in some work and made decent progress.

OP posts:
HollowTalk · 24/07/2020 14:22

I'm not sure I'd go back to your DH. I would hate to be linked to people like his family.

What were the bad things he did? Who did you sleep with?

MizMoonshine · 24/07/2020 14:22

You need to just take the hits right now.

Discovered my DPs cheating some months ago. My brother pretty much wanted to rip his head off. My family have been more respectful than your H's but they weren't happy with him. And they're not happy with him.

You have to just leave it alone, focus on your relationship, and move forward as a couple. Just the two of you. Have faith that the strength of your relationship will be enough.

YoullFloat · 24/07/2020 14:44

I think you need to just keep quiet for now. Most families would go apeshit if their child had been cheated on.

I don't think their reaction is out of order at all. I doubt they actually intend to smash your head in.

ravenmum · 24/07/2020 14:59

I’ve been going out of my mind these last few weeks trying to figure out exactly what it is I’ve done in the past to make them despise me so much.
Most likely they were just never massively keen on you as a person, and are now just seeing you through the light of the most recent events, and rewriting that minor lack of interest as "I always knew she was a bad'un". And they are simply pissed off and expressing that by saying nasty things. I don't think you need to think about it too deeply.
When they hear about your attempts at reconciliation they will probably be rolling their eyes at having to potentially act nice to you after they have been nasty to you out of an attempt to stick up for your partner. You don't have to see them if you don't want to. Do they tend to hold a grudge generally?

Shizzlestix · 24/07/2020 15:07

Keep your head down, don’t retaliate, but let dh know they’ve sent unfortunate messages. No, it’s not helpful but they’re understandably annoyed. They’ll regret it once you two are back on an even keel. Block them on social media too. I never understand why in laws have to be on each other’s social media.

MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 15:09

I'm sure they wouldn't actually physically hurt me, but to joke about doing so on Facebook for all to see has irked me. Not that I'm in any position to be annoyed with anyone other than myself, I know. DH also hates it when people post their drama online, so I can only imagine how he felt seeing his family slagging me off and airing our problems.

I always got bad vibes from MIL more or less from the day we met. It's like she instantly decided she had an issue with me for some reason, and has just stuck with it. Over the years, I thought SIL and I were getting along somewhat reasonably, and I've asked her in the past if I ever done anything wrong to make MIL have a problem with me, and all she said was 'oh thats just the way she is. She's cold' - turns out both of them have never liked me!

I appreciate I can't wave a magic wand and take everyone's hurt away, but I really want to make amends and show everyone that I'm trying so hard to be a better person, I'm just not sure where patching things up with his family comes in to it.

I suppose it somewhat works in my favour that DH rarely, if ever, sees them all, so should it wind up going down the NC route, things won't actually look that different as we currently see MIL and SIL at best, 2-3 times a year.

I think SIL is generally more able to move past things, but I've little to no hopes with MIL.

OP posts:
MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 15:12

DH is aware of the messages that they've sent, and the post MIL made, and he's not happy about either.

I want to apologise to them both, but I think I may just need to keep out of their way for a while. DH and I have made good progress in a relatively short space of time, so we're both feeling pretty confident that we will get through this, it's a shame his family have said the things they have, but I deserved it and I guess I'll just have to do the damage control if and when the time comes.

OP posts:
Drinkingallthewine · 24/07/2020 15:29

I want to apologise to them both

For what? You didn't cheat on them, you cheated on your DH. Only his opinion matters in this. They seem to me to be liking the drama of it all even at the expense of your DH's feelings - alluding to his personal shit on facebook? That's not supportive or kind to him now is it?
So fuck them. They aren't acting in anyone's interests but their own.

My sister was cheated on. It absolutely tore her life apart. Her partner was part of the family so yes it fucking stung and we were raging at him for hurting her. But we, as a supportive family took our cues from her and what she wanted. When she wanted to try again with him, we supported her in that. And when she finally called it a day we supported her decision.

MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 15:51

Obviously my main focus is my DH, and making it up to him, but I don't know. I feel like I owe his family an apology too. I've clearly hurt them, and for that I should say sorry, shouldn't I? I'm really struggling to know the correct way of handling this.

His mother and sister do thrive on drama and they tend to have a gang mentality, I wish I could say that I was surprised by the Facebook post and their comments/messages, but honestly, I wasn't. I expected nothing less.

I guess they're acting in a way they must think is supportive? Sending messages to me, 'sticking together' as a family and bonding over their hatred for me, we all have different ways of responding to things, I suppose. But they seem blissfully aware that the way they've handled this is the exact opposite of how DH wished they'd gone about things.

OP posts:
averythinline · 24/07/2020 15:53

I think you shoudl take your reset relationship a lot slower.... there have obviulsy been issues on both sides and unless you address the fundamentals they will come back.... have you looked at relationship counselling.....

MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 15:53

Blissfully unaware**!

OP posts:
853690525d · 24/07/2020 16:09

They don't sound like nice people. I don't think you should apologise to them at this point. Perhaps when they see that the relationship if working out and they're stuck with you, it will be worth it to them to accept an apology. At the moment, you don't have to speak to people who are abusive. Who cares if they like you. They sound awful. I'm not sure your DH isn't more like them than you realise, if he's been so dreadful. What on earth are you doing with him.

Happynow001 · 24/07/2020 16:33

@MusicForAForgottenFuture

His mother and sister do thrive on drama and they tend to have a gang mentality, I wish I could say that I was surprised by the Facebook post and their comments/messages, but honestly, I wasn't. I expected nothing less.
These people, SIL but particularly MIL, are bullies. Don't apologise to bullies. Don't give them more space in your head than you absolutely have to. In fact go as low contact as you can (NC if necessary).

I hope it works out for you both - it sounds as though there were problems to be resolved on both sides. 🌹

aSofaNearYou · 24/07/2020 16:42

I think you should follow his lead and both focus on your relationship, have a bit of distance from his family for a while. I can see why they're angry with you but they're not being helpful to your DH by sending these messages knowing he is trying to patch things up. On top of that, if they really have hated you for years without cause then they don't sound like the kind of people you want to have a strong presence in your life regardless of the current situation. It was toxic anyway.

MusicForAForgottenFuture · 24/07/2020 16:52

Thank you @Happynow001 I'm just struggling at the moment with my own opinion of myself - I've never hated myself more than I do right now, throw in their comments too and I start to wonder if I am actually a vile person? Until they sent me those messages, I believed I was a good person that fucked up and did a bad thing, but I can't get their comments out of my head and it's really starting to make me think that perhaps I am vile, and awful and worthy of being hated for so long. Maybe I am a bad person? Whatever their goal was regarding the messages/post, they've certainly succeeded in making me feel worse than I already did!

OP posts:
Upstartcrones · 24/07/2020 17:10

Before everyone throws the ILs under the bus (btw I would never condone the threats of violence that's just bullying imho) but no one knows what their son/brother has said to them to get them frothing at the mouth, neither do you OP. It might all be back on between you but he may not have told you everything that went on and whilst he might be saying that he is not happy with them that might be for your benefit.

Also I wouldn't count on him not seeing them more or them not wanting to be involved more. I suspect he will want to keep the door wide open so he can stay with them again if it all blows up again. To be honest he'd be a fool not to keep that option open given the tough path you both have ahead of you.

Just another perspective.

Happynow001 · 24/07/2020 17:11

@MusicForAForgottenFuture

Not all of us are blessed with such a blameless life like MIL and SIL seem to have been. Have you seen their halos recently? 🙄

You are human and, being so, are fallible. You made a mistake, yes and they have their opinions on it.

But let them take a good look at themselves in the mirror first. The person closest to you in this relationship is willing to start again for BOTH of you, as it sounds like neither of you (Heaven forbid) were perfect. He is the one whose words and actions should have any weight - not those of SIL or MIL.

Also look at your long-term friends. Who are they and are they people of integrity? What, supposing they know your situation, have they said? I've found true friends can be very unvarnished about what they say if you'd screwed up but love you and have your back anyway. Lean on them when you need to. And on your own family.

Anyone of any intelligence who saw those FB postings by those two awful people who are related to your DH, will see them for what they are.

As someone else said, take your DH's lead in this.

Breathe OP. You will get through this. 🌹

Troubledmummy3 · 24/07/2020 17:18

First off I just wanted to say that if the horrible things he did included violence towards you, I would walk away...because that shouldn't be forgiven and if you haven't got kids having them with someone who has ever been violent towards you is a really bad idea...

But if you guys really love each other and want to make it work I think you need to forget about his family and focus on your marriage, on your husband...talk to your family and surround yourself with support and love not negativity. You cannot make everyone like you in life and to be fair I don't think anyone's family would like their relatives' partner after finding out they'd cheated on them...but in time that changes as life moves on. However his family sound vile!! I personally wouldn't want anything to do with them! I think they've done you a favour but that your husband needs to move out of his sisters' place asap as she may try to poison him against you.

You really should think about why you cheated and address any issues that led to it too, to make sure you aren't trying to salvage a relationship that deep down isn't going to work...good luck xx

Tt101 · 24/07/2020 17:27

"Dear MIL/SIL,
I am sorry I cheated on my husband. I am sorry you called me a whore. I am sorry you never liked me. I am sorry that you want to beat me up. I am sorry for the things my husband did that lead to the break down of our relationship.
Obviously as I took a vow to be faithful to you, from now on, you will be the first to know about everything in our relationship. I will do my best to make it up to you..."
Struggling to see how this apology is going to work.

BurtsBeesKnees · 24/07/2020 17:35

Don't apologise op. Do take a step back from his family. I think going forward you'll have to accept that you won't be having any relationship with his family. Unfortunately you've handed them a gift by cheating on your dh. You've given them the ideal opportunity to create drama and publicly humiliate and despise you.

Your relationship with your dh is you and him to repair. Keep them out of it

Tt101 · 24/07/2020 17:37

Yes they can be angry but they have over stepped the mark. Don't apologize to them unless you want more of this kind of treatment from them.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.