Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Why did she say this?

55 replies

Brandbrandbrandy · 23/11/2017 19:16

I’ve been seeing someone for four months and have yet to meet his friends. We’ve been taking things slowly (my choice) because I’d recently come out of a long term relationship and wanted to take time getting to know each other first.

Recently he went a bit distant on me and I didn’t know why. But last night we had a heart to heart and he told me that he had been out with an old (female) friend and started opening up to her about me. However when he showed her a photo, she immediately said “oh no, she’s completely wrong for you”. Confused

He admitted that it got to him and that’s why he pulled away for a couple of weeks.

I’m upset because I’ve never met her and am wondering why she would have been so negative about me.

Why would she have said that?

OP posts:
Koala72 · 26/11/2017 07:27

He sounds unconfident in his own instincts and judgement, and she I would say 99.9% is threatened by how much he clearly does like you and how much you are right for him.

He's been hurt before. He's know this friend a long time and by the sounds of things, they have a friendship where she tells him what to think and do, because probably although they haven't had a relationship because he doesn't fancy her, she kind of fancies him, and feels like she is his closest woman, albeit not lover.

There are women who are like this, and are horribly proprietorial over their imaginary husbands ...

It shows his insecurity, but I think it very much shows also his reliance on her. This, remember, is something that has come about as a result of his 'failure' to be in a happy long term relationship. She has been a bit of a substitute - a surrogate non-wife. That doesn't mean to say it can't all change now. But she knows that if you become his closest counsel, then she will be out the door - and she probably doesn't like that thought. She would then just become the friend she should be, and you would be his number one.

So I think it's as much her as him, and tbh he will only have the chance of falling in love and being with someone properly (e.g., you), if he manages to ignore her.

You have to win his confidence, and although others here will say he isn't worth it if he's so flaky that he just lets her dent his confidence in your mutual attraction, I think it sounds like there is genuine chemistry and compatibility between you too, so it's worth giving him a bit of a chance.

You have to address this with him. Ask him what the hell she knows about you and him - nothing. Only you two really know how you feel. Ask him how long when he first met you before he realised he wanted you. If you're properly in sync then probably less than 13 seconds, if he's honest. Share how you felt about him.

Anyone wanting to be with this guy will have to first wrest him out of his dependance on this female friend. I think it's worth being kind to him and giving him the chance, because she's been someone he's relied on for years. It's not easy to change that overnight.

However, he might not be able to step up. In which case, you'll have to sadly let him go. I'd give him a chance first, though.

Dozer · 26/11/2017 07:33

Going distant because of a friend’s comments about your photo, then telling you this was the reason - red flag.

Avoiding relationships because of one past relationship - red flag

You say you were “taking it slowly” but also “falling in love”: inconsistent.

Anniegetyourgun · 26/11/2017 07:47

I'm so sorry he didn't turn out to be the lovely guy you were starting to fall for. You have done the right thing to end it. There'll be someone else along soon to fill the gap - you only wasted four months (and at that it wasn't all wasted if you were having a good time).

FWIW I have a dear friend who I can quite imagine saying something like this man's friend did and meaning it in all kindness and sincerity (whether she'd be right to think it let alone say it is another question). More fool him if he listens, or actually, in hindsight, maybe she was right...

MarieG10 · 26/11/2017 07:56

45 years old and only one relationship. That would give me alarm bells in itself I’m afraid.

1nina · 26/11/2017 11:39

Although you have posted on here to get advice from others you also have to go with how you feel and not just listen to others (as he did) !

New posts on this thread. Refresh page