Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Husband wants a divorce - won't say why

72 replies

abi67 · 21/12/2014 19:07

I'll try keep this short but the upshot is I'm 47 and my husband is 43. We've been married 11 years, no children. About five weeks ago, we had an argument and I could tell he was different from usual. Usually we argue, fix it quickly, cuddle and it's all ok. So I tried to talk to him and he said I've been treating him like shit the last year. I just never realised. I've had a back problem, I've definitely had depression the last few years likely peaking with the death of my mother six years ago (confirmed by a therapist) but generally I didn't see that I was behaving any differently than usual.

But he's my husband, I love him, I understand marriage is work so I listened, took onboard what he said and I guess my behaviour changed pretty quickly. We have a housekeeper (my husband earns good money) but I started to do things like the washing up or whatever. Sharing in the cooking (he's always insisted on cooking before because he enjoys it but he raised it as one of the things that was annoying him). Little things. And they made me feel really good for some reason that I now put down to that I didn't realise even though I had it all - nice house, cleaner, dog walker, first class flights, whatever - that I was really bored and it was making me unhappy and miserable.

I've spent a lot of time on the internet the past few years. I see now that this was neglecting him and it wasn't making me happy anyway. Just bored I guess and I suppose I like to have opinions to share with people. It's all irrelevant really. The upshot is one of the changes I made was to go to a therapist and that's been helpful because it's helped me identify that I've likely brought patterns into the marriage from my childhood. I had a rough childhood and a pretty abusive mother (who was also inconsistent with her affection). That probably resulted in a personality disorder (likely Borderline) but I display little of the usual symptoms associated with it. The most manifest is that I can be pretty nasty in arguments, tend to be introspective and feel little connection to what I feel or value and otherwise occasionally confrontational. The biggest impact it probably has it that it just leaves me feeling depressed and lifeless. I'm seeing a psychiatrist soon to get this diagnosed for sure. The good news is that because I'm older and pretty together otherwise, I've likely managed to self-moderate my behaviour with age. I'm not physically violent and he's always laughed off any confrontations I've had with others (very rare now - maybe one in the last year). I'm not awful - I just lose my temper and will quickly get verbally abusive but there's always a reason and I always calm down. I hate it though and always have and I guess one blessing here is that I finally realise this so I can deal with it. I asked him throughout the marriage if he thought I should see someone and he'd always say it was my decision. I suppose I thought that was good enough and I wouldn't go but I really regret this now because maybe I could have worked on myself sooner and saved this. Even if this is a factor - I don't know.

Anyway, again this is all to give background. He just turned round after a few weeks of everything seeming to be ok and blurted out he wanted a divorce. He won't tell me the specifics and it's driving me crazy. He said he's not been happy for the past year. Understandable. He'd mentioned this a few weeks ago - I listened and took on what he had said and tried my hardest. Then it changed to it was he knew a year ago he didn't love me and then it changed again to it was happening before then. Possibly years. It just "crept up" on him. If I press him any further, he gets defensive and almost like a child. The most I can get out of him is that he doesn't love me. Whatever I say, he replies "I don't love you". It's almost like an attack to try and hurt me. And it really does. The other thing was he "hasn't lived much of a life", that he "doesn't see a future" with me.

So ok, I suppose this happens. People stop loving you. It's so hard to understand. It's just come out the blue too and I asked him why he was cuddling me, talking about the future (we're going to get a car so the weekends are more exciting) right up to the night before he told me, and all he could reply was "I still feel affection for you", and - the worst - "I look back on our marriage fondly". I can't stand it when he says that. We rent where we are at the moment and the lease runs out in March. I said I don't want to make any decisions and just want to process everything. He also says he'd consulted a relationship counsellor but I'm starting to wonder now if he actually has. He didn't seem to like me going to a therapist but then who does. I just can't wrap my head round a relationship counsellor not getting him to try and work with me to save the marriage. I asked him this and he said that he was that determined he didn't love me anymore that she apparently just wanted to help him with his "grief" and "guilt".

I don't understand how you can have grief and guilt about not loving someone any more but then deciding that you're going to divorce them anyway. We also had a substantial sum of money last year that could have at least given me a deposit on a flat or something but that's pretty much gone now because of moving round houses, removal costs, and he started a business as well. That doesn't seem to be going well although he's got one deal on it that will pay off quite big in a few years. I asked him if that would be part of a settlement. I'd just got this news so I guess I blurted it out and he was really nasty. He said he'd just get rid of the company and change the name or something. I don't understand his behaviour. It really isn't like him to be this unkind or shit. It's almost like he hates me. When I've tried to talk to him, I honestly and truly feel like he's saying "I hate you" when he says "I don't love you".

I'm tearing myself up inside. One of the problems with the condition (possible) that I have is that I internalise pain so I will think things like "he never loved me", "I don't really love him", "we were always a mistake". Things like that. I've learned breathing techniques to deal with these though and I've been borderline suicidal at points the past few weeks. That's again another thing. I'm not able to have perspective and I have huge abandonment issues that can cloud my judgement too. Anyway, I'm coping pretty well under the circumstances. I know I've made mistakes. I'm terrified about the future. I have a feeling that he's going to be nasty about a settlement. He's very intelligent and high powered and the way he's spoken to me so far makes me think he just wants me gone and really won't care what happens to me. If I say anything he either says "o here we go with the victim complex again" or "I'll always set you right, don't worry". But how can I trust him now not to shaft me in the future? I'm 47. I could probably work but I'm unlikely to have my own house now or pension or anything. The other weird thing is that once he told me, he acts like I'm supposed to be happy and fine about it. It's totally irrational. I just don't want to talk to him or be anywhere near him because I think he owes me a chance. I really do think that's fair. For better or worse, etc. But he won't even entertain the idea. He's screamed at me that I'm trying to find a "chink in his armour" or sarcasticaly says "oh why? so you can fix it?". I just want to stay away from him. I can't act all friendly with him. He doesn't get it and I can't - it's making me feel sick and anxious if he even talks to me. So patronising and condescending or with this sense of "care" that I know he doesn't mean. Like I'm a patient or his employee or something.

I just can't believe this is my husband. He's always been totally doting and loving and in a way that's been bad for me. I should have worked, I should have had my own career, my own friends. Less dependent on him. We also let our sex life go big time and it's been about four years now. I feel terrible about this but I'd always ask him what to do and he'd say he was fine if we never had sex again. Crazy. I should have pushed but then he's always been kind of non-interested. He has a few performance issues but then I probably do too and just thought maybe one day down the line we'd fix it. What a mistake. But anyway. I see al this now. I can change all these things. I want to and I can and I know that even if he doesn't love me now, he did once. I believe in marriage. The standard it sets. You work through things. I don't know. Anyway, the other thing I realised is that I'm internalising and missed something important possibly. His dad has bouts of major episode depression (kicked off in his 40s iirc) and his aunt has bipolar disorder and part of me is wondering while I'm sitting tearing myself apart if something is happening with him. I noticed it the other night when I was talking to him. He just won't entertain even the slightest discussion and it makes me think that he isn't thinking it through or somehow he thinks I'm the problem and maybe not that he's stressed. He says the "guilt" about not loving me has made him not sleep well and lose a lot of weight (two pants sizes). But these are also indications of depression in my limited knowledge of it. Also, I know you can suddenly start to feel hopeless about the future and start to disconnect from relationships and that you can even develop feeling that you don't have any feelings etc. with it too. The type of depression his dad has is severe and at the chronic end of the spectrum and part of me is really scared something is going on. I asked him to talk to a doctor or therapist just to be sure. Relationship cousellors may not be qualified to pick up underlying issues. Anyway he just sneered when I mentioned it and said "I'll take it under advisement". God, it's so awful seeing him so nasty to me.

I'm not sure. Perhaps I'm still in denial. I just want to cover every angle and possibility and I suppose I wrote all this out and hope someone will read it and tell me what they think. What do I do? I'm pretty sure he doesn't love me any more but I can't see what I've done. I was reading up about midlife crises and I get this because I think I went through one when my mum died but I didn't get help for it. I also thought I didn't love him any more but I fundamentally get love can change or wane but it's always there - you just need to tap it. Anyway, any advice or input? I have very few people I can talk to and no family. Also, I keep reading advice about divorce and people talk about their children and it stabs me in the heart that I never had any with him. I keep thinking if only I had, then I'd at least have a little piece of him to take with me. I don't know. I'm sorry for the length of this. I feel really helpless.

OP posts:
simontowers2 · 21/12/2014 21:33

I agree oswel. I think if there are no kids involved the relationship has to be spectacularly good to work long term. He is only 43. If he is the catch you have suggested he is OP, he could probably set up again with somebody a few years younger who fancies a family. Who knows, he may already have that planned.

Tyzer85 · 21/12/2014 21:46

Vivacia I'm a long time lurker but only a short time poster, nonetheless I have noticed that it is suggested often by other members that the man must have a mistress or something similar even when there's little evidence. Because a man can't possibly ask to separate if there's no other woman. Based on what the OP has posted there could be many reasons for her husband wanting a divorce, instead it's suggested that he's cheating on the OP rather than he wants a divorce for another reason e.g. no sex for four years. Now I'm not saying that there's no other woman but where's the evidence? It seems like projection based on members past experiences from where I am sitting.

Vivacia · 21/12/2014 21:55

It seems like projection based on members past experiences from where I am sitting.

I felt like this too, when I first joined. And then time and time again, the OP returns to tell us about the OW.

Anyway, I agree with what you say about the husband having good reason to divorce the OP without an OW, and don't want to derail this thread with a wider discussion of Relationships Smile

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 21/12/2014 22:00

Tyzer... He may or may not have another woman. We don't know either way. I think his next partner will be younger and able to have children. He will have another relationship at some point, that we do know. Hopefully, OP will also have another relationship that makes her feel happy and settled.

piggychops · 21/12/2014 22:09

The thing I really notice about your posts OP is the number of times the word "I" occurs.
A successful marriage works on compromise a lot of the time, but usually on both sides. If one half gets it all their own way all of the time, the other half will eventually get fed up with it.
What was the situation with your relationship?

SelfLoathing · 21/12/2014 22:39

nonetheless I have noticed that it is suggested often by other members that the man must have a mistress or something similar even when there's little evidence.

Inference.

We know that

  • he has lost a substantial amount of weight.
  • he has not had sex with his wife for 4 years.
  • he now wants a divorce
  • it appears to OP that he is being a bit evasive/cagey about why he wants a divorce.

Nothing to do with projection and obviously no one knows for sure, but I think that an OW is a very real possibility. The weight loss is a big thing. If it were me, I'd do a bit of investigating; he's unlikely to come out and admit it.

hitalownote · 21/12/2014 22:41

OP i understand your reasoning for wanting to know why. But by the sounds of your relationship towards the end I don't think you will get an exact list of whys. I think as others have said he has had a lightbulb moment and feels he doesn't want it to continue. You can look back and say you should have done xyz and if only he had been truthful/honest about how he was feeling in the relationship (which i think he probably coasted for a good while). But your need to know exactly why is futile. He simply does not want this marriage to continue.
I don't believe he has another woman. It's unusual for him to last so many years without sex. But I have known men to do this too. Porn and the likes can be the release. Bracing yourself and wondering if there is another woman and questioning him won't help either. It isn't going to change the fact again he doesn't want this marriage anymore.
WE can speculate all we like. put ideas into your head as to why. But in this situation i just think he has had enough.
Don't beat yourself up now. There is no point. Just think how can YOU get your life together now. Yes financially you didn't have to worry, but nowyou will. I do everyday and do it as a single woman. It's scary and it's exhausting but lots of us do. It sounds mean but you must realise you can't piggyback of anyone elses finances even if married. Not for that length of time, even if he said it was fine. It must have finally hit him that you weren't contributing to the finances or the marriage.
So what do you do now? Let the days roll by and try figure out why he wants it to end? Look for evidence of another woman?
No, you must pull yourself together. Accept you made mistakes and have faults. WE all do. But now it's time to figure out how you can independantly live your life.
Give him space and time to really figure out what he wants. If it's an exciting new world where he can do as he likes then let him. Concentrate on being a better you. Possibly in time who knows if you are independant and happy in yourself, you might fall back in love again. But this won't be today or tmrw. And stop over analysing, he says in plain english i don't love you. You hear I hate you. That's not the case. You'll exhaust yourself overanalysing and wondering. Just tell yourself it's time to pull your life together. You have great insight into your faults, and what you should do.
Do it! Harsh realisation as to how your life wasn't working. But you can make it work and possibly be happier than you ever imagined.

hitalownote · 21/12/2014 22:44

smoking weed and not eating properly or stress can cause weight loss!!

i really don't think it's helpful to speculate why he has come to this conclusion and further upset the OP unnecessarily.

AcrossthePond55 · 22/12/2014 00:26

I think the bottom line is, it doesn't matter why. It just IS. No amount of explanations or reasons is going to change his mind. In younger days I was one of those who thought that if I could only get them to TALK to me I'd figure out that 'one magic thing' to say that would fix everything. Now I realize that doesn't happen.

Rather than focusing on why and how, I suggest you see a solicitor for some good legal advice. You can be pretty sure he already has! Also, some counseling may help you to process things and come to terms with what you can't change.

Is he still living in the same house with you? That's not healthy for either of you. I'd suggest you ask him to leave. I think you both need some breathing room.

however · 22/12/2014 01:24

Perhaps he does have someone else. That must hurt.

That said, I've had experiences with people who "lose their temper, get verbally abusive, and then get over it". My experience is that it's easy to get over it when you're the one hurling the abuse. Not so much if you're copping it.

People fall out of love with people who aren't nice to them. I know you're trying to fix things but sometimes the damage is too extensive.

dirtybadger · 22/12/2014 02:03

You cant force him to explain. Morally perhaps you feel entitled to a "proper" explanation but I'm afraid he's not obliged to give you one. Or to work on the marriage. If he knows its over for him, he knows.
I'm afraid for me your posts read more "how dare he" than "I just want to be with him because I love him so much!"

I didn't think OW. Always possible but I did assume it would have more to do with the verbal abuse and general dwindling relationship.

I'm not sure you will like what he has to say if you press him for why he doesn't "love you" any more. Asking and asking will further reinforce whatever problems he think exist. Frustrate him. If he doesn't even understand himself (one reason we do or dont love someone- nope it doesn't exist, it's complex) he'll have to start over analysing too.

I was in a similiar position to your DH a year or so ago. I threw my long term boyfriend out for a list of reasons (real things- dishonesty, etc). But it was an easy decision because I was really already questioning things. I still sort of cared for him and really didn't want to have to give him 200 reasons. But he pressed and pressed. It made me really angry that he essentially felt I wasn't entitled to end the relationship (which I formed half of). I ended up giving him reasons. Plenty of reasons. Then came more "whys" (I.e. Why dont you find me attractive? Why dont you like it when I do X?). I really doubt he felt better after he forced me into a corner, having to tell him how I felt so brutally. I had so much contempt for him but had really not wanted to be unnecessarily cruel. In the end it became necessary. It was another way of undermining my autonomy. I couldn't end the relationship without his approval!

Get legal advice re divorce and try to accept the relationship is over whether you would wish it to be or otherwise. Unfortunately splits can't always be mutual.

Flambola · 22/12/2014 02:33

You sound like you've been abusive, disinterested and lazy in your relationship with him.

That's probably why he doesn't want to be with you anymore. And the fact that he doesn't love you.

Coyoacan · 22/12/2014 02:45

Op, I am so sorry that this has happened to you, but I do think that when he says that he is no longer in love with you that is sufficient explanation. You may have changed over the last few weeks, if that was the behaviour that killed the love, but, personally, when the love goes, it goes, and it cannot be revived.

The important thing is for you to plan your future life. You are still relatively young, I am in my sixties, and you can do a lot of things. See a solicitor and get the ball moving.

LittleMissDisorganized · 22/12/2014 03:16

I think your few weeks of "real change" has probably come too little, too late for your husband.

So now you need to look to the future. You need a job, somewhere to live, advice on any benefits, and to get straight on with forming a social network. Which of those are you going to start with?

I also suggest you look at the Gateway Women site and forums for a place to deal with your grief and thinking around your childlessness.

Romeorodriguez · 22/12/2014 03:35

This is what struck me from your OP, I should have worked, I should have had my own career, my own friends. Less dependent on him You should never rely on anyone for your own happiness or sense of worth. Why don't you work or have friends?

superstarheartbreaker · 22/12/2014 06:45

Tbh him smoking weed would be a good reason for you to get out op. Horrible drug that messes with people's brains.

Vivacia · 22/12/2014 07:51

In younger days I was one of those who thought that if I could only get them to TALK to me I'd figure out that 'one magic thing'

Heh, yes, I recognise this. I was Viv, The Amazing Man-Fixer.

Enlli · 22/12/2014 10:31

Good helpful post Hitalowrote Smile

Enlli · 22/12/2014 10:32

Hilowrote

Enlli · 22/12/2014 10:33

Sorry.......on phone and it has free will Grin

Buttercupsanddaisys · 22/12/2014 10:37

Sorry, I went out after I posted last night, a winter solstice party , and will be leaving soon to spend xmas elsewhere. Before I go, tho, want to say all the very very best to you as you go through this abi and I hope that you find peace, however it pans out.

Explanation about the 'roaring fourties' comment. No, vivacia I didn't make it up, just that it's been a family shorthand way of describing the sort of behaviour I thought I saw here, so similar to the rel. of mine I mentioned upthread. Thought it was a common phrase but seems not. Actually, as it gives reference to the nautical phenomenon at lat.40 and we're a sailing family,more possible that in the family it dates back to that time my rel took off?

I went out to this party last night, thought I was going to spend xmas alone and fine with that, but had an invite to join a house party in Wales? Just demonstrates that good and unexpected things do happenSmile

Again, all the best to you.

AcrossthePond55 · 22/12/2014 14:15

Ha, viv, I think there are a lot of us 'fixers' out there! And wasn't it great when you had that 'lightbulb' moment and finally realized "F* you, fix yourself!"?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page