Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Would really value your opinion on this letter to my sister?

56 replies

HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 09:21

Dear my lovely little sister

You know I don’t want to hurt you and I don’t really want to rake up the past. Too much has happened, too painful. But, our dad will die and you will probably think that I am a heartless bitch for not being too bothered about it. I can’t bear that you would think that of me, so I want to tell you my story. You can choose whether to read this or not, but at least I will feel as thought I have explained it to you, my sister.

My first memory of you is of the night you were born. I was really young and really scared, mum was in labour, dad no where to be seen. I had to get help. At that moment, I guess I started to look after myself.

Second memory is of a HUGE row, aged 5. You were a baby, not moving around yet. There was shouting and screaming, mum shouted at me to “Grab your sister and get in the car”. I did, I picked you up out of your cot – you were asleep – and packed us a carrier bag of clothes (who knew I could be so resourceful so young?). I wrapped you in a blanket of sorts and went out to the car, sitting in the back, holding you. I waited, I can remember the shouting, I can remember you crying. Mum ran out, dad threw a brick through the windscreen.

That time was pretty horrid for me, school was OK, but something happened that still to this day, upsets me deeply. We had babysitters called J and S, I don’t know whether you remember. The long and short of it is that J raped me. He took me into the bathroom and told me what he was doing was safe, good, make me a grown up. All that grooming stuff. He used a piece of pink toilet tissue to clean himself afterwards. He encouraged his brother S to also use me. S did some more minor abuse, kissing, touching, etc. I was probably 8 or 9. This happened more than once.

They involved others, including Uncle T and our neighbor.

I had a hickey on my neck. Our family friends were there when it was found and I remember mum grabbing me and taking me to them, asking them “Is it what we think?” I didn’t know what it was, I said something about scraping my neck, I genuinely didn’t know what they were even talking about. I don’t think any of them did anything about it.

All of this before I was 11, before I was my DC's age.

So, this terrible stuff plus a childhood filled with dad getting pissed, violent and horrible led me to feel totally worthless. I used to try to look after you a lot.

When I was 16/17 I took a major overdose, more than 100 tablets. I wanted and meant to die. I felt so low, so totally worthless, so deeply isolated and alone. I just wanted all the noise and roar going on in my head to stop. It didn’t. I almost did die, so very close.

I tried to kill myself since, at least once more seriously, resulting in a 3 month stay in a psychiatric unit. It didn’t help much. I don’t think dad came to visit me more than once or twice.

This resulted in me telling mum a very small part of this story and we have only skirted around this. I asked her not to see her brother, she still does. I asked her not to mention him, she said “But you two are close in age.”

So today everywhere I turn there are stories of historic sexual abuse, on every radio station, in every newspaper. I can’t get away from it. I have thought through options and know I won’t do anything about it. I won’t take them to court (even though I know where they are on facebook) because it will destroy me, my career, my stability and my family. I won’t tell mum because it will destroy her, she is still so fragile, which she acknowledges and it will cause untold damage. I won’t put my family, my wonderful DH, and DC’s through any form of pain or damage, just because it might give me some form of justice. I would hurt more from seeing them damaged.

So I can’t forgive either of our parents for not looking after me as a child, for letting this happen to me and for not taking action. Yes, there are probably reasons. But I know for sure, if anyone touched or hurt either of my DC’s, I would do something, I would protect my child, I would keep them safe. I would not let that person walk free.

DH knows all of this and there’s not a single day that I don’t count my blessings to not have died, to have got on with my life and to have kept my children safe. I had a lot of therapy since DH and I met at the beginning and this helped a lot. The thing that has helped most of all is having my own, precious, happy, safe family. My anchor.

The only thing I ask is that you don’t share this with mum. I don’t want to destroy her. I can’t do that. I would rather be silent.

Anyway, that’s it. I am not a heartless bitch. I simply can’t forgive either of them.

Your big sister x

OP posts:
EllaFitzgerald · 07/09/2014 09:40

Flowers to you.

What is your relationship like with your sister now? If you want to keep it private, do you trust her not to tell other family members?

HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 09:57

We have a good relationship, she is a really nice person and as we have got older, we have got closer.

THe only person she would or could tell is mum, but that's unlikely I think given mum's state (she's v sensitive, cries at drop of a hat, bad divorce from dad, that kind of thing).

OP posts:
CogitoErgoSometimes · 07/09/2014 09:59

Is there are reason why you can't say this to her in person? I'm sorry you've had these terrible experiences but I would question the wisdom of asking someone else to take this harrowing information on board and then keep it to themselves. Keeping other people's secrets sounds like it has already ruined big parts of your life. Isn't it time it ended?

CogitoErgoSometimes · 07/09/2014 10:00

Isn't it time the secrecy ended, I mean... not your life, of course. Blush

HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 10:10

Cogito, i understand. Don't worry, a very happy, well adjusted, reasonably sane adult now!

Good call on whether to say in person. I wanted to give her an OUT, an opportunity to not read it.

Maybe you are right. It is probably too much to take on board in writing.

OP posts:
sonjadog · 07/09/2014 10:14

I think also it would be better to tell her in person. Then she can ask questions or respond in whatever way she wants. It is a lot to take in in a letter and then after the letter there will be this ominous pause while you both wait for the other to say something about it. If you have a good relationship, then talk together.

HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 10:19

OK sonja. I want to give her an opportunity to say No, I don't want to know. so I will write her an email saying maybe the first paragraph or so.

OP posts:
F0ssil · 07/09/2014 10:25

Wow. You poor thing.

I would send it but I'd take out the part at the beginning where you TELL her that she might think you're a bitch. You're not a bitch. If she can't listen to you, then that doesn't make you a 'bitch' and you're sort of offering her the opportunity to turn her back on you, and that if she did that, you'd be 'The Bitch'. So I don't want you (fwiw) Brew to put that part in.

I would just send the letter. Your honest account. No assumptions about what you think she will think, of it all, or of you. It should be your account.

Maybe you could hand the letter to her when you are with her. Sit with her while she reads it. That is a way of being present while she reads it, but also being able to put it down on paper in the exact way that you want.

JustTheRightBullets · 07/09/2014 10:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

JustTheRightBullets · 07/09/2014 10:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Branleuse · 07/09/2014 10:30

i think you should send it. it explains a lot. She can read at her own pace and its obviously taken a lot to write.

F0ssil · 07/09/2014 10:32

ps, my mum shuts down any difficult conversation by crying. I don't think it's borne out of fragility.

Meerka · 07/09/2014 10:33

Im so sorry to read of your awful childhood.

Regading a letter, to dump it all on her like this is an awful lot.

In your shoes if you want to give her an out, I would write a much shorter letter saying that you are worried about when mum dies. That you feel you have a much different relationship to her than she, Sister does. When she dies you are going to be feeling differently about her death than she, your sister, is and that there are reasons for that.

Those reasons are strong and very difficult reasons. You would like to offer her a chance to hear them but to warn her they are upsetting. You can get on with the rest of your life well now, but they have affected a great deal up until now and still affect your relationship with yoru parents.

It's kind of pretty heavy hinting that something bad is hovering, but she can shut the door to it if she wants. At the same time, when your mother dies and if you react with near indifference, she will have it in the back of her mind that there might be good reason for it. So she won't think you just heartless.

Beyond that, I think face to face or a letter could work. Just make her aware ahead of time that somethign heavy is coming. It could be shattering otherwise to get it all at once.

Twinklestein · 07/09/2014 10:46

I think it's good to write it down, sometimes traumatic experiences are easier to express on paper than in real life. But I think it would be best first of all to warn her that you would like to share some difficult information with her, so that she's prepared when you send the email, and furthermore to discuss it with her afterwards. She will no doubt want to talk to you about it.

I think it's fine to ask her not to discuss it with your mother, but beyond that I don't think you can really ask her to deal with this on her own, because she will need support herself. It was her childhood too.

HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 11:07

Thanks for all the responses. F0ssil, you might well be right. I think of my mum as an ostrich, bury your head in the sand when it is too difficult or uncomfortable to hear. In her world, it is easier to do nothing and ignore it.

I also like the idea of giving it to her and sitting with her whilst she reads it., maybe.

Meerka, tis not our mother dying, but our father (now divorced). I can't stand him, sis already says she doesn't understand why. I feel it is time to tell the truth.

OP posts:
HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 11:09

And the alternate is to stay quiet and I have considered this. I don't want to ruin my relationship with my sis and know that dad dying and me not being bothered / reacting in a different way may well too much.

I have explained to her that I feel differently and she is OK with that. She respects that I feel differently, just as I respect the fact she feels differently. FYI, he was violent to her too (just maybe not as visible or as much, certainly once as a grown up)

OP posts:
CookieDoughKid · 07/09/2014 13:46

I think you should do what you feel is right.

I wrote an email to my BIL about the sexual abuse of one if my dc. The perpetrator was my husband's youngest brother and he responded quite negatively. In fact, he said it was none of his business.

I hope your sister will respond positively to support you but I think you should prepare yourself regardless.

Do what you feel is right. Don't let anyone bully you otherwise and above all, don't bully yourself to conform with convention.

I have written off my bil. I have zero time and tolerance for family who choose to walk blind on abuse so they can selfishy live the facade

CookieDoughKid · 07/09/2014 13:46

Selfishly live the facade of normality.

Lweji · 07/09/2014 14:00

I do think it is a good idea to tell her that you have a story to tell her about why your relationship with your parents is not good at all. And she could choose to hear it or not, or to ask you about it when she thinks she is ready.
You could also ask her if she wants to read it or for you to tell her, if it's the same for you. But certainly do it in the most comfortable way for you.
You are the one telling the story.

The danger here is that she will continue to treat her parents as she always had and you will be hurt. Or that she won't believe you.
Have you thought about what you will do if that is the case?

JustTheRightBullets · 07/09/2014 14:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 14:38

Cookiedough, sorry to hear that and yet at the same time, I kind of understand. There is a risk that she says none of my business, then I guess I would have to ignore her. I also have no time for anyone who lives the facade of normality.

JusttheRightbullets, good call. It was meant to say I tried, but I was a kid and probably didn't do it very well.

Leweji - if she doesn't believe me, same as cookie really, I would have to go glacially cold on her.

This is why I have been quiet for so long, it is almost easier to be quiet, somewhat distant from my mum, sis etc rather than spill. She was standing by her kitchen counter the other day at a kids party, I put my arm around her and she was genuinely surprised "oh it's you, I am just a bit surprised". I am a really warm and kind person!

OP posts:
HappySmileyPeople · 07/09/2014 14:39

Or maybe f the lot of them, maybe I should be selfish and drop the bombshell.

God it's confusing.

OP posts:
JustTheRightBullets · 07/09/2014 14:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LatteLoverLovesLattes · 07/09/2014 14:54

I am sorry you have been put through so much by the people who should have loved and protected you :(

It's sad that your sister doesn't already know all of this. I think you have a right to tell her and she has a right, a responsibility even, to know.

None of them seem to have been looking out for you, I wouldn't shy away from blowing the whole thing wide open IF it would help you - you don't owe any of them, anything. IF anything it might help other vulnerable people.

I'm glad your DH knows everything and is there for you.

Meerka · 07/09/2014 15:52

happy, there's nothing to loose by approaching your sister with this more gently and giving her warning. There's no fault in her over all this.

Agreed with rightbullets, the damage caused by this stuff staying secret is insidious. Secrecy benefits the abuser far more than it benefits anyone else because it leaves him free to live happily ever after... and maybe carry right on.