Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

My marriage is a sham. I'm new. Would love some advice [long] :-(

86 replies

LouDecember1 · 15/12/2012 22:00

Dear all
I?m new to Mumsnet (pls be nice!) and feel a bit guilty that I?ve joined purely to glean a bit of ?party opinion?. I?m in a very turbulent and difficult marriage that?s teetering on the edge and could do with a bit of unbiased opinion and advice. We relocated a while ago so I currently live away from my network of close friends ? though in any case, I?m hugely private and would probably struggle to share this kind of info anyway (a lot of people assume we have the perfect marriage in fact). This is long (I?ll try and paraphrase etc) and may take a while to read through. So thank you in advance to those who spend time on it.
We?ve been married for 12 years and have four kids. We?re still a reasonably young 30 / 40 smthg, both considered attractive. As with many couples with young kids (ours are still all under 10) life can be a strain both physically and financially (permanently tired for one thing!) but on the whole we are a lot luckier than many.
When the first of our three kids were very small (newborn twins and a one year old ? I kid you not) life was at its lowest ebb for me. I was permanently knackered and (to be honest) hated my body (any twin mummies on here might relate to the ?balloon body? pregnancy ? and how it looks afterwards). I was a size 8 pre-kids and found it hard to adjust to the excess saggy skin on my tummy and the fact that my boobs were flacid and had lost their shape. Add to this the fact that I almost certainly had PND (undiagnosed at the time) and various other (minor but at the time debilitating) health issues, and (mainly) extreme sleep deprivation and I was ? admittedly ? very hormonal and down. My husband had been less sympathetic to me during this second pregnancy. I recall (as a silly example) asking him to rub my back / massage my feet and he point-blank refused. To be fair, he wasn?t an arsehole about it, and was always busy with work etc, but it wasn?t exactly a time of TLC and romance either. Then again, lack of romance has been a bit of a theme. Anyway?
Onto work and I started to notice (post twins) that he was talking a lot about ?the office blonde? (apologies to any blondes out there). This person (slightly younger than me, unmarried, no kids, but with a partner she claimed to adore) was actually a friend of mine (I used to work there too) and so she?d occasionally pop over. When this happened there was a lot of flirtation between her and my husband. As I?ve never particularly been the jealous type and (don?t dislike me for saying this!) also because I?ve generally been considered to be an attractive person (and she?s actually not hugely attractive) I didn?t see this as much of a threat. Even when my husband decided to take her on a night out to see a local band (I was too tired to go ? the babies were still, well, babies?) I was fine with it (in the past I?ve been a bit of a flirt too ? nothing major though ? so just saw all this as a bit of a modern ?male-female? friendship ? with me the modern wife for accepting it. Hmmmm.)
It was around this time though that he also started to make comments to me about her ?great? figure. Bearing in mind I was (and am) desperately shy about my own post-pregnancy figure and I found this very very hard. Especially when he?d suggest I should join her gym and perhaps see which exercises she was doing. Please also bear in mind here that when the twins were 5 weeks old I embarked on the Atkins diet (total ban on carbs) ? it was horrendous. I hated every minute and felt weak and lethargic (and yes I know this won?t have helped my hormones or sleep issues) but I hated myself so much I was desperate to lose the weight. Cut to the chase and within two months I was back to my pre-pregnancy size 8 ? but still with the saggy skin issues. So the fact that my husband was comparing my body to this woman?s felt dreadful as I realised that there was no amount of gym that was going to change my actual shape and skin tone (weight loss, per se, wasn?t the issue).
Despite all of this I was trying hard with our sex life and even started letting him do things such as anal sex. I arranged weekends away / dressed up etc but still I felt ugly and undesired (he?d f*ck me but there was never a sense of tenderness or romance or making love ? maybe other guys are the same??) He ended up wanting sex with the lights off all the time (at home) and claimed it would heighten our senses when we touched each other ? but honestly, my husband has rarely touched me (or kissed me) intimately. In fact, I do have to be in the mood for oral sex (eg I like to be showered) but even so, it?s happened rarely and he?s rarely tried to put me in the mood for this. In fact he never has. And I just assume (to this day) that I?m undesirable.
During this time we argued a lot - and sometimes semi-violently. For full disclosure I will state here that it was usually me blowing my top and I did occasionally push / shove him and slap him around the face, Eastenders style. This is not excusable I know but I was really in a desperate state (no love / affection and realising his on-going flirtations with this other woman). He didn?t ever really reciprocate by hitting back etc ? until one (fateful) night when he really lost it and properly beat me up (black and blue) in front of the kids ? actual punches etc. He was very drunk (not an excuse but it should still be stated). He?s never done this since. And I had never hit / beat him like that so it was a real shock. The kids still remember it (?when daddy pushed you down the stairs? etc).
He also claimed many times to resent the kids and (once) wished our son dead (he had terrible reflux and cried a lot as a baby). I found his rejection of the kids to be a rejection of me.
He started (in these arguments) to say terrible things about my body. Really horrible stuff. And usually it would end with ?no other man would want to sleep with you ? you?re soiled goods? type of thing. I can?t tell you how awful it made me feel. To this day I recall the comments and they make me feel so low.
In the end I booked myself in for cosmetic surgery (tummy and boobs). While the operations worked their magic (another story for another time) I remember feeling hurt that he hadn?t ever tried to talk me out of it by saying that ?he loved me anyway? - or ?are you sure??
Long story short and the flirtation with this woman increased over time. One night he was having sex with me (I was tired and didn?t want it but had relented ? trying to be ?the good wife?) and I asked if he?d mind giving me some foreplay (I?d started to suffer with cystitis as he?d usually just penetrate me and it hurt as usually I was quite ?dry?). His response was to withdraw from me, sit on the end of the bed, say a few disparaging things (I forget what) and then tell me he was in love with this other woman. I was distraught.
In the end we sort of tried to work things out. This was very up and down (big rows / passionate ?make up? sex) until finally I found flirtatious texts that they were sending and he confessed (again) to being in love with her. He told me though (and still swears) that nothing ever actually happened. It was purely flirtation.
Ok?. [deep breath]
I ended up having an actual affair with an old friend (we didn?t sleep together but did pretty much everything else). At the time it felt great ? and I felt desired / loved ? and in fact I nearly left my husband for him (he fell in love with me and wanted us to leave our respective partners and live together. I was starting to fall in love with him). In the end, I couldn?t bear to break up the family and confessed all to my husband. Considering how badly I took his emotional affair, he forgave me for my actual affair really very quickly (I mean, in the course of a few hrs). Looking back this seems odd?? But he is less of a volatile temperament than me? so who knows.
I?m going to skim over a few months here as conscious that this is a very very long post (thank you to those bearing with me). Please also bear in mind that I was no angel during our many many rows (see above re me losing it a bit and shoving him / slapping him ? not all the time ? but the rows were very tempestuous).
We ended up at Relate (which incidentally was shit ? another story) and soon-ish afterwards he lost his job. I was (I think) a huge emotional support and I also ended up finding work to (financially) support all of us.
In the end he got a (great) new job and we relocated. This was to be our ?fresh new start? ? but then he confessed to (mild) office flirtations in his new job (I suspected and cornered him into admitting).
This is such a long post ? sorry.
Since then I?ve tried all sorts of things (arranging weekends away ? that he?s too tired for ? BUT he does work shifts and gets very tired, this is true).
I still receive little to no romance ? and he?s still very selfish in bed (still rarely touches / kisses me intimately ? though he claims to enjoy oral sex ? and very little foreplay).
We?ve been in (couples and individual) therapy for a year now ? but honestly these rows continue. Usually I start them because I hate the lack of romance / affection and I feel totally ignored in the bedroom.

Between the rows he claims to love me and that I?m his soul mate and hates our rows. I receive a lot of promises and emails of intention ? but somehow there?s still a lack of? something.
Am I right to assume that he loves me (I know that he does) but isn?t in love with me / fancies me?
ANY THOUGHTS WELCOME? thank you so much.

OP posts:
Darkesteyes · 15/12/2012 23:37

Sorry OP. that wasnt me having a go at you. I am as shocked and appalled at your therapists attitude as i am at your husbands abuse.

mcmooncup · 15/12/2012 23:39

Transactional Analysis truly is a ludicrous way to try and explain this. She is missing a huge point that you should not have couple counselling when there is abuse. Of any kind. If she has deliberately ignored the very very basic abuse sign, i.e. that he beat the shit out of you, you really should not go back to this counsellor.

AbigailAdams · 15/12/2012 23:41

" If you can't be respectful to each other don't live together" It isn't the OP beating up her husband and chucking him down the stairs.

"Obviously your marriage is not fulfilling you. Emotionally or physically." Well that would be because she is being abused.

This is not a 6 of one, half a dozen of the other situation. Nor is it a clash of personalities. It is a woman in an abusive relationship.

Also second the Lundy Bancroft book, OP. And Bertie speaks wise words about internet (and other) safety.

RogueEmployee · 15/12/2012 23:48

I think once you cross a certain line, you can't uncross it. The physical violence, the hurtful moments, you can't take those back and they leave a blot on the relationship. Once you know someone is capable of thinking about about you / doing that to you then you can never look at them in the same way. You two have been through too much and you relationship is too damaged. I think you would both be better off finding new partners and starting again. All this isn't fair on anyone, your children in particular.

RogueEmployee · 15/12/2012 23:48

Comments not moments.

LouDecember1 · 15/12/2012 23:49

I feel like such an idiot here and for what I'm about to type I think you'll all think I'm in denial... (but)...He really really is a great dad and great around the house and often is so so sorry for ignoring my needs (emotionally not just sexually). He does cry and break down a lot. Whenever he's alone for sustained periods of time for example he seems to spend that time crying / having a mini break-down... he's also tried to read up on his behaviours and is trying to help himself in that respect (learning) - and the beating-up genuinely only happened once (I know that once is probably enough!!!)

Are you all saying (well, most of you) that it's the stuff he's said to me (and the other women stuff) and the fact that I'm ignored in the bedroom, is that still abusive? He doesnt flirt with other women any more (well, at least I dont think he does - I wouldnt know for sure...)

Crikey - feeling Sad and confused ....

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 15/12/2012 23:57

Therapists are not always trained in abuse. They are trained to see problems in everyone, so my guess is she's as much trying to help you "fix" him as she is trying to help you fix yourself. This is a lost cause - you have no hope of fixing him, even if he wants to change, which I don't believe he does, you are far too close.

The violence you mention in the past is very severe and I am concerned for your safety, please don't hold out on plans like supporting yourself via work before you leave, if you feel ready to leave then start making practical arrangements ASAP. With 4 DC I think you'll struggle with childcare costs(?) and you might be better off not working. I stress that this is a temporary, needs must situation and not your own fault. When the DC are older and childcare is not needed for the older ones, you'll be much more able to work and be independent. Until then you could always think about studying or working from home if you wanted to supplement your income or work towards your future.

Please be careful OP. You may want to report your post where you've mentioned his name and get that edited out by MN just in case he searches.

If you're not ready to leave I don't think anything any of us says will help but keep talking it over and thinking it through and processing it, it's the best thing and will get you closer to that strong place you need to be in, for your own and all of the childrens' sakes.

Darkesteyes · 15/12/2012 23:59

Are you all saying (well, most of you) that it's the stuff he's said to me (and the other women stuff) and the fact that I'm ignored in the bedroom, is that still abusive? He doesnt flirt with other women any more (well, at least I dont think he does - I wouldnt know for sure...)

Yes its still abusive. Insulting you and putting you down IS abusive. Entering you when he KNOWS you are not ready and that it will hurt you IS abusive.
And neglect is also abuse.

mcmooncup · 15/12/2012 23:59

It's not a denial I don't think.......it's just you can't see it when you are in it sometimes. AND you need to be educated about what an abusive relationship actually is - it can actually involve NO violence. Sexual (you have ticked this already in what you have posted), emotional (tick), financial (no info)......it is a whole pattern of behaviour.

And abusers aren't twats all the time........they are often charming and charismatic........they have to be..........it's the only way they get away with it all for so long - 12 years in your case. His crying and sorrow is also just part of the cycle........after all he never actually changes does he?

another quick guide here

BertieBotts · 16/12/2012 00:05

Yes it is :( I'm sorry. Abusers are never nasty all of the time. He might genuinely not mean to hurt you or understand why he does this. But that doesn't stop it from being abuse and if he can't help it or isn't willing to stop then he needs to let you go for your own safety.

I also think you're normalising a lot of things which aren't normal - he isn't "inattentive" in the bedroom for example, his attitude that he "doesn't want it on a plate" is extremely damaging and penetrating you with no foreplay when you're not aroused is bordering on rape, quite frankly. And it's likely if you're accepting this kind of treatment (and other things that you've mentioned) as normality then you're probably grateful/happy about some things that he does which are little more than a basic requirement or normal expectation in a healthy, equal relationship.

I'm sorry this is such hard going, it must feel like a ton of bricks to get all these replies at once. You don't have to take it all in at once, take time, post, think, step away for a few days if you need to. I think it's extremely likely that your childhood has damaged your views of what's "normal" in a relationship and what being loved and cherished looks like. I'm so sorry :( I wish I could come and sit down with you and reassure you that however much this feels like everything you know is falling apart, it's going to be okay. You're going to be okay, in the end. We have endless hands to hold here. There's someone to talk to at any hour of the night. You can be safe.

DoubleYew · 16/12/2012 00:10

If he was vile 24/7 you wouldn't be with him at all, would you, trying to make it work? My ex was abusive - emotionally and it started to become physical. It began when we had our child, I thought he was sweet and kind before then. But he was still nice in some ways and had been abused as a child so I tried to make allowances.

Now I'm very pleased that ds is growing up in a calm happy household. You can do that for your children, even if it means being poorer than you are now. He can still be a good dad, just not in your house.

(have to say my relationship couselling was also crap but its free for everyone in this county - I think they try to be so balanced, that everyone has faults, that they can't see the fact that one person is so manipulative)

mcmooncup · 16/12/2012 00:12

I might be reading between the lines here OP, but you have talked about the sex part of your relationship a lot here.........and as Bertie is gently pointing out......there is a VALID reason as to why you are feeling confused about your sex life. You should never have to have sex with someone when you don't want to. And you have been doing this for years. Trust yourself, you are right to be confused about this because he is IN THE WRONG having sex with you when you are not ready and when you don't want to (i.e. you have been coerced into it).

suburbophobe · 16/12/2012 00:21

Trying to read your OP is like trying to wade through treacle.

But how on earth do you have time to have cosmetic surgery and an affair with 4 DCs all under 10, new-born twins and a 1-year-old, an Atkins diet with twins at 5 weeks old, PND....etc.

Confused

I do get it's time to kick him to the curb, as the saying goes. He is violent FFS! Never mind playing other women off you.

LouDecember1 · 16/12/2012 00:24

Thank you so much everyone for both support and taking the time to respond.

I'm really really shocked as I really thought that half the posters would say it's him, the other half me. And I've tried so hard to give a balanced picture, I hope that comes across.

One thing I do know is that he 'loves to hate me' if that makes sense?

He's put me down in areas that I know that I've worked hard on (e.g. he's said if we split then the kids will probably want to stay with him (I dont know why he thinks this would be the case) / he's put me down in front of the kids (or said his insults very 'quietly' so they cant hear and all they hear is me yelling - and therefore they think that I'm the bad guy) / he's taken credit for jobs that I've got on my own merit (ooh, I'd forgotten about that one) / and admitted to feeling jealous of the career successes I've had (we used to work in the same industry).

Ultimately, I pride myself on being a really kind and generous person - and most other people see that but him. It's like he refuses to accept the real me? Anything good I do is often undermined - even down to refusing to accept romantic breaks away - and yes, he's taken the opportunity to put me down in front of our friends ("jokingly"). Somehow it never feels funny though.

Going to bed soon(ish) - but I will be checking this thread for most of tomorrow (he walked out this morning after I complained yesterday that he was being selfish in bed again - after he promised me he'd treat my body differently) and I will post again, tmrw if not again tonight (not sure how tired I am now - even though I'm exhausted if that makes sense Sad

Again, thank you. xx

OP posts:
LouDecember1 · 16/12/2012 00:27

mcmooncup - but he didnt know that I didnt want to have sex with him (he just didnt bother with foreplay and my self-esteem has always been too low to say no)... not making excuses - but I didnt actually say "no".

Suburbophobe - I'm shattered, frankly...

OP posts:
mcmooncup · 16/12/2012 00:27

Order that book.
It will change your life.
And yes, abusers don't love their partners. You are right again Smile

mcmooncup · 16/12/2012 00:27

He knows damn well Lou Sad

LouDecember1 · 16/12/2012 00:29

Thank you... I'll head to Amazon. x

OP posts:
suburbophobe · 16/12/2012 00:31

Didn't even get to the part about the therapist!!

Sad thing is, a lot of therapists are not qualified or have the experience to deal with domestic abuse. First thing they will ask is what is your part in it rather than looking at the facts. (Got threw out that particular t-shirt).

Not really helpful. . Waste of precious time and money.

Better to ask for a recommendation for your area via Women's Aid probably.

MaggieMaggieMaggieMcGill · 16/12/2012 00:39

You should both be seeing separate therapists for individual counselling regardless of anything else. There is a massive conflict if interests going on if she is seeing you both separately and as a couple.

Feckthehalls · 16/12/2012 00:48

Sorry if this sounds harsh. You both sound a nightmare.
But he sounds worse than you.
Sorry I can't begin to offer anything more constructive regards the train wreck that is your relationship.

LouDecember1 · 16/12/2012 00:52

Crikey - and I havent even touched on the fact that our ex neighbour (admittedly a proper nasty piece of work) told me that my husband had 'spied' on her boyfriend in the shower (I have actually asked my husband if he's sure he's not gay - since he once told me - out of nowhere - that it'd make no difference to him if a bloke or a woman gave him oral sex. I mean, that's as maybe, but why say that to your partner???)

My wedding ring is long gone (thrown out of a car window, mid-row) - I've had that promised back to me on numerous occasions..

The web pages that he used to hurriedly close down if I headed downstairs and he was online...

The fact that he laughed in my face when I asked him (in tears) if he did actually sleep with that woman...(incidentally a good friend begs to differ that they didnt sleep together).

Ah, now I'm just venting a 'shopping list' of petty grievances. Sorry Sad

The ridiculous thing is, if you met him at a party you would think he was such a nice bloke.

OP posts:
Mollydoggerson · 16/12/2012 01:21

You are both abusers by the sounds of things.

Bogeyface · 16/12/2012 01:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.

Bogeyface · 16/12/2012 01:51

if you met him at a party you would think he was such a nice bloke.

I have sung that song. No body believed me until they saw me with a black eye and a fat lip. They are charismatic, funny, charming and sexy.......until they get home :(