We're pretty much split up, and living on my own with DD has been excellent.
Ok, so I don't live my life by pros & cons lists, but to get an overview, here it is:
Cons
Erratic moods are difficult to deal with, I can't be sure how to talk to him in the best way to keep things peaceful
He doesn't do a lot without instructions
Our attitudes to finance are incompatible
I will never be able to trust him; I always worry that he is still doing the online sex thing or seeing escorts in his lunch break
Sex issues - is he thinking about the other women, am I trying to please him too much or not paying enough attention to issues he might have from the abuse; he rarely initiates which makes me feel even more pathetic after what he's done
I have to make a safe space for DD so that his attitudes to women and sex can't influence her too much
I don't want to recreate my parents' marriage of always struggling and always fighting
I could only keep things peaceful by agreeing with him all the time and never having my own opinion
DD needs to learn what healthy relationships are, and ours isn't it
Neither of us wants to give in first when we argue
He is messy and does not clean a lot
He takes no initiative when it comes to DD - I inform myself on developmental stages, when to apply for schools, which nursery etc, and then pass my knowledge on to him
He will always have mental health/addiction issues
I will always be completely on my own emotionally
I feel more in charge when I don't see him
I feel more 'authentic' when I don't see him
He sometimes gives me guilt trips when he's done something for me like babysitting DD; he keeps track of exactly how much he's done for me
He always has to be superior - e.g. as he studied politics, his opinion on political events counts more than mine, I am always wrong
He never apologises for having made me feel rubbish followed by giving me a hug to make things better
There are always things he doesn't tell me
When there's a conflict, he tends to side with other people rather than me
He knows exactly he'll always have another chance and behaves accordingly
Pros
He is dependable - he will always help out in a practical way, give me lifts, pick up shopping
He's very generous
He'll go along with most things I suggest, but also put thought into it and make suggestions
We more or less have the same attitudes to parenting/weaning/healthy food for DD
We now know all about each other's families' dark secrets and have the same opinions on family involvement (i.e. as little as possible); someone else might make me feel bad about how I deal with my complicated family
DD is beautiful and extremely bright (if I do say so myself)
We have similar attitudes to food (I have some slight issues around food because of my upbringing)
He's DD's dad
I would imagine it's administratively and emotionally easier to have all children with the same dad
I don't want a complicated family life, having to deal with potential new partners for each of us, their families and their potential children
He doesn't think less of me when I wear comfy clothes and no make up and still tells me I look nice
He has a good job/career prospects
He is intelligent
Sex works ok as we know each other's buttons
Pregnancy is likely to be complicated in my case, and he knows the issues already
Erm... that's it. Still not convinced by either side. The cons are all big issues for me, but I can't stop thinking aww, but we have such a long history, or ...yes, that's all bad, but I just want a baby and it'll all be fine somehow.
I know pregnancy and having a new baby is hard, but I've got through so much on my own the last couple of years that I really think I can do it. Just occasionally I think I don't want to do it with him again because he would not appreciate what I'm doing for him, because the effort that goes into growing a baby and looking after it should be appreciated by the dad, IMO.
I know, it's all really stupid. 