"This tends to be the pattern in AA; newish members get carried away with the threatrical, 'faux serenity' of meetings, where, as noteven said herself, one is persuaded to keep the shit in one's life for one's 'sponsor', and only talk about how great the 'program' is 'in the rooms'."
bollocks. I was in a meeting the other night where the chair spoke purely about her problems and how she was addressing them - and, in general, this is the advice I have received myself over several years in AA. I also regularly hear people discuss quite openly how they choose not to practise certain elements of the program (I am one of them). They are never criticised.
"By which time the unfortunate newcomer has mortgaged their life to AA, in terms of the promises they have given to family members, who may have been persuaded into al-anon, whose main purpose seems to be persuading the afflicted to go to AA meetings." Bollocks - I have never made any promises to family members, in fact the whole ethos of "one day at a time" goes against "promising" anything. No one in my family is, as far as I know, in Al Anon and no one has ever tried to persuade them to join it. I think that this is most people's experience, in the UK at least.
"Do you notice how often noteven referred to her 'illness'? And how fantastic AA is? She has been thoroughly brainwashed into thinking that she is powerless." Perhaps she proved to herself that she was powerless. Perhaps that's why she was desperate enough to think that a church hall full of other alcoholics could help her. Very few people join AA for the biscuits - most of them are despearate and have tried everything but AA already. Again, this was my case. They stay - as have I - because it works for them, at least better than anything else they have tried.
"Someone noted that they went to a lovely meeting with a couple of very oldtimers, a couple 'with' 8 years, etc. What does this say about all of the newcomers who have wandered in, over the years? They have either run for their lives or gone back to drinking." Or perhaps, one day at a time, they have gained 8 years' sobriety. Just a thought.
"These people are not mentioned. AA causes binge drinking and suicides." Bollocks - alcoholism causes those things. It causes them among members and non-members, more often among the latter than the former.
"I would recommend CBT. And education." Neither of which tend to work if someone is still drinking because the person is rarely honest.
Can I say "bollocks" again?