SPRINGCHICK- here are some concerns i have with your position,
#1. I find it as disturbing as much as i do ironic that you recognize marriage only on the same low level as consensual sex, your dim (and frankly) depressing view of marriage is both unattractive and.........non-functional in the real world,
#2. I see that you fancy overly simplistic statements like "NO ADULT CAN TELL ANOTHER ADULT WHAT TO DO"..... while "cute" (in a test tube) it suddenly falls apart under the harsh application of reality, clearly your narrow understanding of the depth and tenderness that people partake of when they covenant the rest of their lives to love, HONOR, and CHERISH, one person as long as they both shall live, is .....to say the least.....lost upon you,...truly sad.
#3. you misunderstand me if you think that i am speaking of controlling ones mind and forcing them to think of you and you only!, but what i am speaking to is the duty of husband and wife to keep themselves pure to each other and to HONOR each other, clearly this sort of behavior is not HONORING the poster!, she feels rightly DISHONORED!, is the meaning of this word "HONOR" lost upon you completely?, or do you just not even understand the vows that people take altogether? while we cannot force ones mind to think on us and us only, we should do everything that we can do to protect our marriages and to keep the tenderness and affection alive, only God can change peoples hearts and work with them on their thought level, but we must hold our spouses accountable for what we can see and touch and for what we know is going on in their hearts by what we see them do.
Coupled with holding them accountable, we should let them know that it is out of love and a desire to save and keep their marriage safe from parasites that will certainly drain the sexual tenderness right out of their bed, that we are holding this standard, not to force or judge, but to preserve the dignity of both parties so that trust and honor can be cultivated,
#4. while I do agree with you about sitting and discussing what both parties expect out of this mutually rewarding covenant that they have both entered into willingly, I will have to part ways with you upon the mention of a compromise IN THIS AREA, obviously there are many things that we must learn to compromise upon but the area of sexual exclusivity is NOT ONE OF THEM!, if the poster loves her husband and wants to keep their marriage as safe as she can she will LOVINGLY "hold the line", shame on you and the rest of the posters for not standing in the gap and encouraging her to stay the course that will ultimately bring emotional security to her and honorable integrity to her husband.
Sorry to be so blunt, if you perceive me as being antagonistic it is only in an attempt to be perfectly clear.
Respectfully.