Just marking this thread with interest as I'm in Lewisham and due at the beginning of September. I had DD1 in 2005 and she was a homebirth (though ended up transferring to Lewisham at the very end because of meconium in my waters) so they have had a homebirth team for a while.
I had DD2 at home and it was brilliant. All my midwives have been brilliant from Lewisham. There were 4 teams iirc, so it was pot luck who was on call on the day, but they did arrange a meeting so we could meet as many as possible.
I guess I've been lucky in that both births were straighforward, drug-free labours. Even when I ended up in Lewisham with DD1 it was the same midwives who were with me, and the birth was fine. And I was never remotely discouraged from homebirths either time - in fact most of the midwives I've met have really enjoyed doing them!
However, the ward I ended up on was horrendous at Lewisham which is why I would definitely choose a homebirth again! There was blood all over the bathroom (shared between 6 women) and the people working on the ward were brusque, unsmiling, unsympathetic and in some cases downright rude. I couldn't wait to get out of there. the other new mums didn't help either with their mobile phones, arguing with partners etc.
So if you used the birthing centre would you then have to go to a ward or would you actually be discharged from the centre?
Sorry for rambling on. I can only praise the midwives on the homebirth teams in Lewisham, but I wasn't keen on the postnatal experience. However, better the devil you know and all that. But packing some Flash wipes and flip flops this time just in case!