Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Pregnancy

Talk about every stage of pregnancy, from early symptoms to preparing for birth.

Are 5 names too many for DD2? Feminist dilemma!!!

57 replies

franch · 23/05/2005 14:06

OK, here's the dilemma:

We have a first name that we love for DD2 (due Sept). Haven't been able to find a middle name that we can get excited about, till yesterday when I started to think about her 2 grandmothers' names. DH and I have both always liked both our mums' names, but didn't use either of them for DD1.

DD1 is named after DH's aunt and my grandmother, as follows:

DHAunt MyGrandmother MySurname DHSurname

My surname is one of her middle names, not part of her surname. (I have both surnames combined as my legal surname but only ever use one or the other - mine for work, his for home.) So she is mostly known as "DHAunt DHSurname".

So back to DD2: we both like the idea of using our mothers' names as her middle names, but if I also include my surname, that gives her 5 names! Which seems a bit much. So do we do:

  1. DD2Name MyMum DHMum MySurname DHSurname? OR
  2. DD2Name MyMum DHMum DHSurname - i.e. omit my surname?

#2 goes against all my feminist principles (which I've compromised already by taking DH's name on getting married). I always intended my children to bear my surname but I'm so excited about the prospect of using my mum's name (which I love, plus the idea of it as a tribute to her) that I'm trying to convince myself that using Mum's name instead of my surname is actually more significant because my surname has nothing to do with the female line in my family anyway .....

BTW the three first names that we're considering (DD2Name, MyMum and DHMum) have 2 syllables each. The two surnames have 3 each.

Discuss!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
teuch · 30/05/2005 13:17

Hi folks,

came across this babyname website (satire) when I was looking - reminds us all that names are tres subjective!

It is extracts of postings from an american website (where else?) with very funny commentary...

enjoy!

Baby's named a bad thing!

MRSflamesparrow · 30/05/2005 13:25

Bobbybob!!!

Thump her! How dare ANYONE regardless of who they are (except the child's parents) choose that the name isn't to their liking????

I wanna thump her for you now!

ambrosia · 30/05/2005 14:24

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

expatinscotland · 30/05/2005 14:35

Run that by me again? I'm confused just reading that.

ambrosia · 30/05/2005 14:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

expatinscotland · 30/05/2005 14:38

I didn't mind taking my husband's name b/c my maiden name was just another man's name.

But hey, if Sharon Stone can name a child 'Laird' and David Duchovny can name his son 'Kydd', I guess anything goes these days.

jessicasmummy · 30/05/2005 14:44

jessica's name was chosen as we have many aunties on both sides called Jessie. We do shorten her to jessi (no E) on occasions. Her middles name is Helen as my now SIL is called Helen and my mum's only sister is called Helen.

For new baby we are thinking James Iain for a boy - most boys in the family are James, including my dad and grandad. Iain is my brothers name.

For a girl though, we are stuck.... i want the middle name to be after my late mum, Alison, but cant find a first name we like!!!

We all have just dh's surname!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread