Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Pregnancy

Talk about every stage of pregnancy, from early symptoms to preparing for birth.

36 weeks pregnant after a traumatic first birth – am I being unreasonable to be upset about my elective C-section date? (UK/NHS) 39 weeks plus 6 days

99 replies

Kershaw22 · 04/07/2026 15:10

Hi everyone,
I’m currently 36 weeks pregnant with baby number two, and I’m looking for some advice or to hear from anyone who’s been in a similar situation.
My first birth was extremely traumatic and, following an investigation, there were failings in my NHS care.
I went into labour at 40+2 and was in the latent phase for four days. I kept going into hospital because the pain was getting worse, but I was repeatedly sent home. Eventually I was kept in overnight after having a significant bleed because they wanted to make sure my placenta hadn’t abrupted. My husband was sent home, and despite repeatedly telling staff I was in severe pain and couldn’t pass urine, I wasn’t properly assessed. It later turned out I had an infection, which wasn’t diagnosed until I finally reached the labour ward at 7 cm dilated.
Up until that point, I’d only been given paracetamol for pain relief. I wasn’t screaming or making a scene—I coped as best I could—but I genuinely felt like nobody realised how far into labour I was.
Once I got to the labour ward, I asked for an epidural because I was exhausted after four days of labour and desperately wanted to rest. Instead of waiting for the anaesthetist, they broke my waters, and my 9 lb 4 oz daughter was born just 30 minutes later with only gas and air.
I then sustained a 3B tear and had to go to theatre for repair under a spinal anaesthetic, leaving my husband and newborn daughter waiting outside.
Unfortunately, things got even worse. During surgery they discovered retained membranes, and I suddenly lost over a litre of blood. I remember the room filling with people, everyone calling out my observations and trying to stop the haemorrhage. Afterwards I went into shock for over an hour. I couldn’t speak and was shaking uncontrollably. My husband has since told me he was terrified and kept asking the staff what had happened to me.
The whole experience was incredibly traumatic, and for a long time I genuinely thought I’d never have another baby.
Fast forward four years, and I’m now 36 weeks pregnant with another little girl. Thankfully, this pregnancy has been straightforward, and I’ve tried really hard not to let my previous experience take away the excitement of meeting her.
Because of what happened last time, and after discussing it with my consultant, I decided an elective C-section would be the best option for my mental wellbeing. I wanted a calm, planned, controlled birth experience. I was also told that if I suffered another severe tear, I might not heal as well.
I’ve now been given my elective C-section date… and it’s booked for 39+6.
I honestly feel devastated. I’ve explained to my consultant how terrified I am of going into spontaneous labour and how important having a planned birth is for me psychologically. I’ve been told that if I go into labour before my date, they’ll do an emergency C-section—but that completely misses the point. I chose an elective section because I wanted to avoid the panic, uncertainty and trauma of another emergency situation.
To make matters worse, my date is on a Friday. My hospital doesn’t perform elective C-sections at weekends, so if there were any scheduling issues or cancellations, I worry I’d end up waiting until Monday at 40+2.
What has upset me even more is that I know someone due on exactly the same day as me who has been booked in two days earlier simply because she’s anxious about a vaginal birth with her first baby. I know everyone’s circumstances are different, and I’m genuinely happy she’s getting the care she needs, but it’s hard not to feel hurt when I have a documented traumatic birth history and still feel like my concerns aren’t being taken seriously.
I’ve never actually agreed to this date, and so far it doesn’t seem like anyone is willing to move it.
Am I being unreasonable for feeling so anxious and upset about this? Has anyone in the UK managed to have their elective C-section brought forward after speaking to their consultant or the maternity team? I’d really appreciate any advice or experiences.
Thank you for reading.

OP posts:
Blushingm · 05/07/2026 15:12

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 07:04

So then why are people with the same due date as me with no medical reasons having theirs 2 days prior to me you think that is fair?

You cannot know other people’s full medical history

Plus if all of you wanted the same date there would be a queue and on this occasion they are in front of you. Your need doesn’t trump theirs - from what you’re saying here is that theirs should be moved to accommodate you? How would you feel if it was the other way around?

You also need to appreciate that there is not a theatre booked out just for elective sections - they will be fitted in around those emergencies and those who have a greater medical need

I understand you are anxious but you need to try and understand this is the NHS. If you want a particular day then you could pay privately

Greybeardy · 05/07/2026 15:16

Blushingm · 05/07/2026 15:12

You cannot know other people’s full medical history

Plus if all of you wanted the same date there would be a queue and on this occasion they are in front of you. Your need doesn’t trump theirs - from what you’re saying here is that theirs should be moved to accommodate you? How would you feel if it was the other way around?

You also need to appreciate that there is not a theatre booked out just for elective sections - they will be fitted in around those emergencies and those who have a greater medical need

I understand you are anxious but you need to try and understand this is the NHS. If you want a particular day then you could pay privately

That actually isn’t the standard any more - elective sections are routinely staffed separately to emergencies.

Musicaltheatremum · 05/07/2026 15:16

Sometimes it is due to the fact that a Friday is the day that is allocated to that consultant to do his elective caesarians. My consultants theatre day was a Tuesday so both of mine were booked in for a Tuesday.

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 15:19

Greybeardy · 05/07/2026 15:16

That actually isn’t the standard any more - elective sections are routinely staffed separately to emergencies.

That is actually very reassuring to know , thank you very much.

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 15:22

Musicaltheatremum · 05/07/2026 15:16

Sometimes it is due to the fact that a Friday is the day that is allocated to that consultant to do his elective caesarians. My consultants theatre day was a Tuesday so both of mine were booked in for a Tuesday.

This would be also an explanation which if he was hands on doing the c sections and why the date has been selected, that hasn't been explained to me yet on the form i completed did say it could be anyone carrying it out at the moment which is understandable. Obviously if there is an explanation for this i am more than understanding but it has not been explained yet.

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 15:23

Blushingm · 05/07/2026 15:12

You cannot know other people’s full medical history

Plus if all of you wanted the same date there would be a queue and on this occasion they are in front of you. Your need doesn’t trump theirs - from what you’re saying here is that theirs should be moved to accommodate you? How would you feel if it was the other way around?

You also need to appreciate that there is not a theatre booked out just for elective sections - they will be fitted in around those emergencies and those who have a greater medical need

I understand you are anxious but you need to try and understand this is the NHS. If you want a particular day then you could pay privately

Please read the previous comments before commenting.

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 15:33

Etherealcelestialbeing · 05/07/2026 15:06

Can you answer my question @Kershaw22?

Are you worried you will end up having a vaginal birth?

I was booked in for an elective section (at 39 weeks) after having an emergency with my first baby as she was unidentified breech.

My waters went at 38 weeks at around 3am (as they had with my first) so I went straight into hospital and they put me first on the list for elective sections that day.

It was a calm and ordered experience - completely different from my first emergency section. Recovery was way easier and quicker and I was home the next day.

Oh this is good and positive to hear. Glad you had a good experience and a good recovery :)

yes i am worried for a vaginal birth and also an emergency situation like last time ( which i know sometimes cannot be avoided ). Don't get me wrong i am extremely terrified of even a planned c section as the theatre bit with the haemorrhaging was what i found more traumatic than even the 3b tear. But it was more the mindset of a planned c section where things would be under control, i would be scared but i know what i was going into unlike a natural birth again.

also with what happened with my first they didn't listen to me about being in labour that time so obviously i have less trust in the fact of going back in actual labour and them advocating me a c section. I was trying for this birth to heal my last but i feel like at the moment I've only got a 50/50 shot of getting the elective planned c section i would have hoped for.

OP posts:
JulietteHasAGun · 05/07/2026 15:51

Do remember it’s very unlikely that even if things did start off before your section that you’d go from nothing to full blown labour. Generally women niggle, back ache, period type cramps, etc. if that happens then that’s the point you ring labour ward. You don’t have to wait for contractions to be strong and 3 every 10 mins.

Yes you probably do need to have been niggling for a little bit, ie not ten mins of back ache. But the staff aren’t going to want you to go into full blown labour at all. I hope that’s reassuring. Remember you don’t have to agree to a vaginal examination if that happens when you go in. Just politely decline, say there’s no need as you’re having a section, that you know your body and that things are hotting up and you feel the section needs doing asap before full blown labour. They’ll want to monitor baby, palpate any tightening, etc but if something is starting they’ll get things moving.

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 16:06

JulietteHasAGun · 05/07/2026 15:51

Do remember it’s very unlikely that even if things did start off before your section that you’d go from nothing to full blown labour. Generally women niggle, back ache, period type cramps, etc. if that happens then that’s the point you ring labour ward. You don’t have to wait for contractions to be strong and 3 every 10 mins.

Yes you probably do need to have been niggling for a little bit, ie not ten mins of back ache. But the staff aren’t going to want you to go into full blown labour at all. I hope that’s reassuring. Remember you don’t have to agree to a vaginal examination if that happens when you go in. Just politely decline, say there’s no need as you’re having a section, that you know your body and that things are hotting up and you feel the section needs doing asap before full blown labour. They’ll want to monitor baby, palpate any tightening, etc but if something is starting they’ll get things moving.

Thank you that is also good to know i just hope they take me seriously if it does happen, i am aware it is a lot of what ifs and hopefully i make it to 39 plus 6 and it isnt cancelled but statistically it isn't looking that great.

also the secretary told me if i did go into labour prior to make a fuss in the waiting room and they would definitely listen to me ... but that just isnt like me and my husband hence why last time i was left to 7 cm dilated . But not a comment that helps instil my trust in them.

OP posts:
Greybeardy · 05/07/2026 16:09

JulietteHasAGun · 05/07/2026 15:51

Do remember it’s very unlikely that even if things did start off before your section that you’d go from nothing to full blown labour. Generally women niggle, back ache, period type cramps, etc. if that happens then that’s the point you ring labour ward. You don’t have to wait for contractions to be strong and 3 every 10 mins.

Yes you probably do need to have been niggling for a little bit, ie not ten mins of back ache. But the staff aren’t going to want you to go into full blown labour at all. I hope that’s reassuring. Remember you don’t have to agree to a vaginal examination if that happens when you go in. Just politely decline, say there’s no need as you’re having a section, that you know your body and that things are hotting up and you feel the section needs doing asap before full blown labour. They’ll want to monitor baby, palpate any tightening, etc but if something is starting they’ll get things moving.

While you’re right, you can decline VE’s in that scenario, it’s worth knowing that just occasionally it does give useful info and you may be disadvantaging yourself (for example if someone were almost/actually fully then there’s sometimes a bit more to plan for/discuss in theatre…. Or if things aren’t as you’d normally predict (eg a surprise unusual presentation) then it may change things from a relaxed cat 3 to a quick cat 2). There’s sometimes a bit more to the medicine than you’d imagine so it’s worth keeping an open mind if they suggest examinations.

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 16:25

Greybeardy · 05/07/2026 16:09

While you’re right, you can decline VE’s in that scenario, it’s worth knowing that just occasionally it does give useful info and you may be disadvantaging yourself (for example if someone were almost/actually fully then there’s sometimes a bit more to plan for/discuss in theatre…. Or if things aren’t as you’d normally predict (eg a surprise unusual presentation) then it may change things from a relaxed cat 3 to a quick cat 2). There’s sometimes a bit more to the medicine than you’d imagine so it’s worth keeping an open mind if they suggest examinations.

Yes i agree thank you :) i would want them to have the full picture, especially as last time my contractions were completely irregular even though i was heavily dilated .

OP posts:
ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 05/07/2026 16:38

OP I too had a traumatic first birth and was booked for an elective c section. The date they gave me was 39+6, despite the fact that I’d previously gone into labour at 39 weeks exactly. It was also my eldest’s birthday, so not ideal (although I don’t expect them to plan around that!). I went into labour again at 39 weeks bang on. It progressed very fast and by the time I arrived at the hospital they gave me the option of a c section or continuing and I chose a c section. They then pretty much threw a gown at me and rushed me into theatre because it was progressing fast, but honestly, it was NOTHING like my first. As someone up thread said, just because it isn’t a planned c section does not make it remotely like a crash c section, and honestly, it was all very calm. I went home the next day and healed so much quicker than from my first birth. Even if you can’t change the date, I really would try not to worry about it.

MabelAnderson · 05/07/2026 16:43

sarahbanshee · 04/07/2026 18:51

An emergency C section is different from a crash C section. An emergency C section is unplanned but you would usually have a bit of time before you go up for surgery to get ready and have the spinal block, and things should be able to feel quite calm. A crash C section is the “hurry hurry we have to get the baby out in under 30 minutes” and would be more like the frightening experience you had before. But an emergency C section from going into labour ahead of your scheduled date doesn’t need to be a crash section.

I think nonetheless you should push harder for an earlier date and explain your (very good) reasons for being concerned. Just trying to reassure you that an emergency C section wouldn’t necessarily be that much like the traumatic experience you had before and might still give you the calmer birth you hope for.

This.
I had a second c-section, trying for a vbac in my case that then didn’t progress well. It was actually really calm and not anything like my first, traumatic delivery when I lost a lot of blood and needed the crash team.
Hopefully you can bring the date forward but if not , if you do go into labour they will have time to calmly take you down for another c section . It won’t be the same.

Ibi · 05/07/2026 16:49

Why do you think you won’t get a section if you go into labour before the date? I went into labour 2 weeks before mine and had a section. It was calm, peaceful, honestly one of the best experiences of my life.

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 16:50

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 05/07/2026 16:38

OP I too had a traumatic first birth and was booked for an elective c section. The date they gave me was 39+6, despite the fact that I’d previously gone into labour at 39 weeks exactly. It was also my eldest’s birthday, so not ideal (although I don’t expect them to plan around that!). I went into labour again at 39 weeks bang on. It progressed very fast and by the time I arrived at the hospital they gave me the option of a c section or continuing and I chose a c section. They then pretty much threw a gown at me and rushed me into theatre because it was progressing fast, but honestly, it was NOTHING like my first. As someone up thread said, just because it isn’t a planned c section does not make it remotely like a crash c section, and honestly, it was all very calm. I went home the next day and healed so much quicker than from my first birth. Even if you can’t change the date, I really would try not to worry about it.

ohhh this is reassuring! Thank you for telling me your story , im glad with your second you had a much positive experience :)

honestly one of the mums from school had her c section the other week and avoided her childs birthday at my hospital which is completely fair enough.

im glad it was calm for you, i think thats mentally the main thing i just really want a calm experience and environment as last time in theatre it was the complete opposite.

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 16:52

Ibi · 05/07/2026 16:49

Why do you think you won’t get a section if you go into labour before the date? I went into labour 2 weeks before mine and had a section. It was calm, peaceful, honestly one of the best experiences of my life.

i love hearing the positive experiences even if it was an emergency there does seem to be a difference in peoples experiences .

i worry they won't listen to me like they didn't with my first daughter.

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 16:55

MabelAnderson · 05/07/2026 16:43

This.
I had a second c-section, trying for a vbac in my case that then didn’t progress well. It was actually really calm and not anything like my first, traumatic delivery when I lost a lot of blood and needed the crash team.
Hopefully you can bring the date forward but if not , if you do go into labour they will have time to calmly take you down for another c section . It won’t be the same.

Lets hope not, its good hearing these positive experiences even if their c section was technically classed as an emergency.

its really hard mentally and healing from a traumatic birth , i just am more cautious this time with having my 4 year old as i want her to remember this as a positive experience too which why i have tried not letting my anxiety get to me regarding my first birth.

OP posts:
ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 05/07/2026 16:56

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 16:50

ohhh this is reassuring! Thank you for telling me your story , im glad with your second you had a much positive experience :)

honestly one of the mums from school had her c section the other week and avoided her childs birthday at my hospital which is completely fair enough.

im glad it was calm for you, i think thats mentally the main thing i just really want a calm experience and environment as last time in theatre it was the complete opposite.

I nearly fell asleep in theatre the second time round while they were stitching me up 🤣 First time round the only thing I remember is people running around, and me yelling at them to just get the fucking baby out 🙈 Not the same experience at all, safe to say.

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 17:00

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 05/07/2026 16:56

I nearly fell asleep in theatre the second time round while they were stitching me up 🤣 First time round the only thing I remember is people running around, and me yelling at them to just get the fucking baby out 🙈 Not the same experience at all, safe to say.

Haha brilliant 🤣 oh gosh i remember the running around and complete fear . Its been a different pregnancy and thats really helped , i just am really praying for a positive birth and experience to heal from last time 🙂

OP posts:
PocketSand · 05/07/2026 17:06

God things have changed. 20 years ago I was booked for an elective CS at 38 weeks. They did not want to risk me going into labour before that date. I also remained in hospital for a week to monitor the baby and to recover and establish breastfeeding. So sorry to hear your stress.

knickershockerfurore · 05/07/2026 17:08

Hi OP, raise these concerns directly with your consultant (or via their secretary) if at all possible, and see what they say. Two of my three elective c-sections were brought forward by a few days at my consultant’s request (still 39+), so it can be done but would depend on whether they felt there was valid medical need. You won’t lose anything by trying, and I definitely would in your situation. Whatever the outcome I would also ask that your request be recorded in your notes. I’m sorry that your first birth was so traumatic and hope you have a far better experience this time round!

romdowa · 05/07/2026 17:22

I had a planned section booked for 39 weeks. My waters broke at 36 weeks and I went into labour and I had an emergency section that night. Even though it was an "emergency" it was all very cool calm and collected. No panic , no massive rush . So if you go into labour before then it wont be what you imagine unless there is an imminent need to get baby out. Then it will be all systems go

Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 17:33

knickershockerfurore · 05/07/2026 17:08

Hi OP, raise these concerns directly with your consultant (or via their secretary) if at all possible, and see what they say. Two of my three elective c-sections were brought forward by a few days at my consultant’s request (still 39+), so it can be done but would depend on whether they felt there was valid medical need. You won’t lose anything by trying, and I definitely would in your situation. Whatever the outcome I would also ask that your request be recorded in your notes. I’m sorry that your first birth was so traumatic and hope you have a far better experience this time round!

Hello, thank you for this :) honestly they are making me feel a little bit better especially when its over the weekend and i am not hearing anything. I am glad yours got moved for you :) yes i have thought about requesting all my notes after this too, my consultant has been fantastic so far and i really have not complained about anything the whole pregnancy, it just has come as a shock how late it is booked in for especially when he told me we would be aiming for the monday/ tuesday. Just hoping everything goes ok :)

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 17:35

romdowa · 05/07/2026 17:22

I had a planned section booked for 39 weeks. My waters broke at 36 weeks and I went into labour and I had an emergency section that night. Even though it was an "emergency" it was all very cool calm and collected. No panic , no massive rush . So if you go into labour before then it wont be what you imagine unless there is an imminent need to get baby out. Then it will be all systems go

This is good to hear it was still a relaxed experience for you even when dealing with your waters breaking so early. I love hearing positive experiences from even an emergency c section.

OP posts:
Kershaw22 · 05/07/2026 17:37

PocketSand · 05/07/2026 17:06

God things have changed. 20 years ago I was booked for an elective CS at 38 weeks. They did not want to risk me going into labour before that date. I also remained in hospital for a week to monitor the baby and to recover and establish breastfeeding. So sorry to hear your stress.

Thank you for the support, im glad your elective went very well. Hopefully all will be sorted and i will make it to then🙏 just hoping for a very positive experience .

OP posts: