Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Pregnancy

Talk about every stage of pregnancy, from early symptoms to preparing for birth.

Grandmother drama - what would you do?

54 replies

Evianontoast · 22/09/2021 17:24

I wasn't sure what section to put this in, so I thought I'd post here as I'm currently pregnant - sorry if this is in the wrong place.

I'm due to have my first child at the end of the year and we live about an hour away from both my parents and my husband's parents. My mum is over the moon and can't wait for her first grandbaby. She's retired and my parents have already decided they'd like to move closer to us so they can help out/ spend regular time with their grandchild.

My husband's mother hadn't talked much about the future so my husband asked her about what her plan was for spending time with her grandchild once the baby is born.

A little context on both mothers: MIL doesn't like driving long distances because she's scared she'll get lost (she's not very tech savvy and doesn't like the idea of GPS or using google maps). She has never worked but, in her defence, she has raised 3 kids as a single mum for a lot of the time with is obviously the equivalent (or more!) of a full-time job (all kids are grown up and moved out now). She lives in a council house and survives month-to-month off her new husband's paycheck. She has always been very emotionally generous with us and is a very sweet lady but does feel a little hard done by in life, which I think is fair to an extent. My parents have worked all their lives and are by no means rich but they have saved up enough to be reasonably comfortable in retirement and have their own property etc. They are also very emotionally generous but are able to also be generous financially, where they can (they paid for our wedding, for example, which we were so grateful for).

MIL replied to husband's question with "well, you'll have to drive the baby to me at weekends". Husband was a little upset by this and said that would be difficult with a newborn to make the journey every weekend (2 hour round trip). Her response was "Well we're not rich like [my] parents, we can't just afford to move house!". Unfortunately, this resulted in an argument between the two, which wasn't very pretty and they've not been on good terms since. It basically ended with husband (who can be a little hot-headed and say things he doesn't mean) telling his mother that she'd never get to see her granddaughter if she was going to be like that. (Husband is close with my parents and I think was also a little offended by his misunderstanding of their situation).

I can kind of see things both ways. I will admit, my parents do have it very easy compared to MIL and I can see that she'd be frustrated. I can see that MIL wants to spend time with her grandchild, which is wonderful, and ordinarily, we always drive to her to see her but I do think it may become exhausting making the journey every weekend with a tiny baby. We don't want her to move, we just want her to come to us sometimes but she's refusing. Her comments about my family's "wealth" (hardly!) have made us realise that she does compare herself to my parents (which is natural) and so I'm worried she'll be upset if my parents get to see the baby all the time and she only gets to see her once a month or so, because of the driving distance. Husband and MIL don't have a fantastic relationship and I think this will really drive a wedge between them. I've tried to make suggestions that she will be included in her Grandchild's life, like when she was talking about her car, I joked about her having a car seat in there soon and she got a bit huffy with me and said "I've raised my children already, I don't need to raise yours too". I was a bit baffled by this, as I really did mean it nicely and that we would trust her with our child and would love for her to spend time with her, not like I wanted her to raise my child. I don't really know what to do!

In this strangely tense situation, what would you do? Do you have any advice for managing difficult relationships with parents in law and between grandparents?

Thanks for taking the time to read, I appreciate this is a long post!

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
SylvanasWindrunner · 22/09/2021 17:27

I think you just wait until the baby is actually here and see what happens. I don't think you need to plan anything about visits or who is going where before the baby even arrives, and it sounds like
It's just causing a lot of stress. If she doesn't want to come to you then that's the choice she makes - she doesn't have to see the baby every weekend. A lot of grandparents don't.

QueenoftheKarens · 22/09/2021 17:29

Just leave it until the baby is born. You don't need to be making arrangements right now before their even born.

Lazypuppy · 22/09/2021 17:32

It was a weird question from your dh if i'm honest, it wouldn't even cross my mind to ask that question. Just wait till baby is born and you do what you want. If she wants to see baby she will have to drive,

VippingQ · 22/09/2021 17:34

Are there no trains between your houses that she can get once a fortnight or so?

Can her husband drive?

It's not reasonable of her to expect you to go there every single weekend.

PurBal · 22/09/2021 17:34

My parents and MIL are also an hour away. I’d lose my shit if either moved closer. MIL also doesn’t like driving so I empathise. Tbh we always travelled to family but since having DS we’ve had to put our foot down. We can and have done it but there are 3 of us to get ready and packed into the car and only one of MIL. And she’s an adult, I don’t have to make sure she’s dressed and clean before leaving the house. As for “fair”, my mum is particularly precious about this but the reality is it won’t be fair, it can’t be. I'd leave it alone, if MIL wants to see DD she’ll have to put her big girl panties on. Hope this makes sense, Can you tell I’m a sleep deprived mum with a ten week old refusing to travel to family 😂

PurBal · 22/09/2021 17:35

And once a month is plenty often enough for us.

DelphiniumBlue · 22/09/2021 17:36

Can she get a train?

Maighread · 22/09/2021 17:37

I could have written this. My MIL is not a fan of driving and while we have not talked to her bout things I'm very firmly putting my foot down - she lives around 2 hours away and I'm not comfortable driving with a new born (My partner doesn't drive.. yet) - She would be very lax on cleaning and that so I'm very wary of visiting her so early into baby's life.
I hope your MIL sees sense when the baby arrives but best to let the dust settle x

Aquamarine1029 · 22/09/2021 17:37

It was so ridiculous of your husband to ask his mother how she was planning to spend time with a baby who's not even born yet. It's like he was looking for a fight, honestly.

Of course you're not going to drive to hers every weekend. That's not even remotely reasonable, so she will either make the effort to come to you or she won't. What she chooses to do is out of your control.

saraclara · 22/09/2021 17:42

It was so ridiculous of your husband to ask his mother how she was planning to spend time with a baby who's not even born yet. It's like he was looking for a fight, honestly.

Yes, what a weird thing to ask. It was almost as if he thought she had an obligation to come and adore his child.

Did she even mean EVERY weekend? That's not what I get from "well, you'll have to drive the baby to me at weekends".

FatAnkles · 22/09/2021 17:44

We never had these discussions Confused

My parents live 85 miles away but my in-laws are about four miles away. Both are close enough. The in-laws come over once or twice a month even though they are fairly close. My parents see DD about twice or three times a year. Luckily we can all use public transport to see each other.

I think once a month is enough tbh.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 22/09/2021 17:45

My mil lived 5 minutes drive from us when ds was born and still saw very little of him/us. (for context my own parents lived 3 hours away, each way, and saw more of ds than mil did). If your mil wants to see GC she'll have to find a way. It's that simple.

BluebellsGreenbells · 22/09/2021 17:45

The last thing you can do with a baby is make firm plans! Why are you even attempting to do this?
MIL sees more of DN than she’ll ever see of my kids - and nobody actually compares

saraclara · 22/09/2021 17:46

MIL isn't the only one comparing though, is she? Your DH seems to have decided he likes your family better, and is expecting her to be like them. She's not. And it's really unfair to deliberately add to her feelings that she's lesser. She's had a tough life and he should respect what she gave up to bring up her own family on her own.

User5827372728 · 22/09/2021 17:46

Yea another one who thinks asking that question was weird; she doesn’t like driving, what was he expecting as an answer?

Evesgarden · 22/09/2021 17:49

Honestly OP keep your beak out of it. Its a storm in a teacup - let them, deal with it

Ughmaybenot · 22/09/2021 17:53

@Aquamarine1029

It was so ridiculous of your husband to ask his mother how she was planning to spend time with a baby who's not even born yet. It's like he was looking for a fight, honestly.

Of course you're not going to drive to hers every weekend. That's not even remotely reasonable, so she will either make the effort to come to you or she won't. What she chooses to do is out of your control.

I agree with all of this. I appreciate that your husband and his mum have a difficult relationship but it seems odd that he looks for things to take issue with like this. She sounds a bit defensive and probably feels a bit hurt by the fact that your husband seems to get on so well with his in laws but has ongoing issues with her, his own mother. I expect you’ll end up driving to see her here and there, maybe once every couple of weeks/once a month, and that’ll just be how it is. Given the difficulties in the relationship, I’d argue that seeing her less often than weekly wouldn’t really be a bad thing!
user1471543683 · 22/09/2021 18:05

My parents were an hour away from me and I'd travel over weekly to see them. Wasn't a problem, timed it with nap time and it got kids used to being in the car for longer distances.

Zilla1 · 22/09/2021 18:09

Why fight a battle before the war has even started? Why would your hot-headed DP choose to start a fight with his own DM who raised him as a single mother? I know the idea of a first baby can become all-consuming and give rise to the idea it should be the whole wider family's priority. Concentrate on having the baby and see how things go. If it takes an hour's drive every week, fortnight, month then that's what it will take. If you are on mat leave and drive and have a baby who goes to sleep when driven then you might welcome the opportunity to go for a drive, especially if you are not juggling several DC.

Good luck.

Zilla1 · 22/09/2021 18:10

@user1471543683 agreed.

Notaroadrunner · 22/09/2021 18:11

Why are you already trying to decide how involved the grandparents will be? It will happen as it happens and doesn't need to be pre organised or discussed months in advance. Nobody needs to travel anywhere every weekend. Nobody needs to move house. Your parents are only an hour away - hardly a difficult journey for either side to make every so often.

ineedsun · 22/09/2021 18:12

Yes, an odd and very loaded question. Of course she felt defensive.

Summersnake · 22/09/2021 18:15

Dear god
Are you the first person to ever have a baby
Get over yourself ,it’s not really a big deal .
What a stupid question your husband asked his mum …how involved are u going to be ….ffs
You and your husband are causing problems before the baby is even here ..how crap you must of made his poor mum feel

VippingQ · 22/09/2021 18:19

@Summersnake

Dear god Are you the first person to ever have a baby Get over yourself ,it’s not really a big deal . What a stupid question your husband asked his mum …how involved are u going to be ….ffs You and your husband are causing problems before the baby is even here ..how crap you must of made his poor mum feel

Oh hi grandma.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 22/09/2021 18:20

What a strange question to ask your mother. Or anyone really. Very loaded an ld actually given the context that your parents are moving closer comes over very "Oh look the other grandparents want to spend so much time with baby they are moving, how are you going to compare to that?" Honestly most people just get on with life, take the baby down at some point in the first few weeks and then just get on with life arranging get togethers around special events etc.