Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Politics

Any American Mumsnetters around?

134 replies

Wildflowers99 · 28/02/2025 19:02

To have a respectful discussion about Trump. Did you expect him to act in the way he has? Are you happy with it? What’s the mood towards him over there?

I’m completely speechless at his ambush of Zelenskyy tonight and just trying to understand how this has come about, and whether he has support to continue acting in this way. He was obviously chosen to be President by the public but I assume they would never have guessed how the last few weeks would have gone.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 12/03/2025 18:51

1911AD · 12/03/2025 15:39

By defining practically everything in the US in a regulatory context.

Some examples: The Feds (that's a handy moniker) say what constitutes raisin bread to what safety features cars must have. Grazing is controlled on public land by the Bureau of Land Management. The US Forest Service has a slew of regulations governing how I can and cannot work my little 18 acre mining claim (not to mention how many nights a year I can camp on it). How airlines are run. What level of fire retardancy kids pajamas must have. Every single thing about highway construction. If I decided to start a tire making company, I would have to comply with all sorts of Federal Regulations from OSHA to the DOT to the EPA and probably lots of other agencies would want to have their say as well.

There are almost 100,000 pages in the Federal Register. Not all of those are regulations but, according to LegalKnowledgeBase.com there are over 88,000 Federal rules and regulations since 1995. There are 19 Federal Agencies. They are busy beavers.

Federal Regs touch every aspect of our lives whether we know it or not.

I'm certainly not saying the BLM shouldn't control grazing on public land or that highways should not be built to certain standards. I'm not complaining that there are Federal Agencies, I'm simply saying that they are woven into the very fabric of our existence and he who controls the Federal Agencies has got a hell of a lot of power.

So in other words, you don't really understand how the agencies work, if you believe one single person can control them.

I'm in the US btw, and I know what "the Feds" means, and also the general political leanings of people who use that term in association with the word "control".

The reasons trump has let chainsaw boy loose on the federal agencies are:
To promote a climate where the rule of law is undermined and individual feelings of security are demolished.
To make a mockery of the judiciary, whom he cannot control directly - he seeks to present them to his cult followers as enemies of the will of the people because they will inevitably issue rulings against the work of his pet goon, with consequences that might be horrendous on a national and personal level for individuals engaged in this public service.
To test the loyalty of the so far completely spineless GOP Congress and Senate - how far will they follow him into the fascist revolution? This is a test arising from his own dysfunctional personality, but he also wants them to do his bidding in the House and Senate, and since they are spineless they will play nicely out of the realization thst they are riding the back of the tiger.

The judiciary are his real targets here, with the end of the rule of law as his goal.

1911AD · 12/03/2025 20:29

Welp... the Federal Regulatory and Law Enforcement Agencies are in the President's portfolio. Is it just me or did the border look like one thing under Biden and something totally different under Trump? All with no new laws being passed by Congress. Seems to me the President has an awful lot of power over what the various agencies enforce, what they don't, and how they do or don't do it.

Parker231 · 12/03/2025 20:46

1911AD · 12/03/2025 14:13

Ok. The question was about whether or not Biden's Presidency was widely perceived as a failure. I think that can be summed up by his polling at the end of his presidency, the pounding the Dems took in the election, and the shell shocked and ruderless state of the party today.

Americans are only now beginning to realise how good they had it under Biden compared with a felon in charge who has zero understanding of foreign policy, economics (he needs to learn about tariffs and explain them to his press secretary who is looking more stupid by the day), he can’t have what he wants - Panama, Greenland and Canada (and needs to shut up about them and stop disrespecting the Prime Minister by referring to him as Governor), he is not a peace maker (Ukraine and Israel) and it’s disgusting to talk about ethics ckeansing in Gaza.
Americas only allies are Russia (possibly) and Israel - they can stop thinking they are the greatest nation.

Parker231 · 12/03/2025 20:50

nonmerci99 · 12/03/2025 17:32

Nonsense. You wrote some sweeping generalisations in your post that are easily countered under the guise of providing your “aw shucks!” American small-c conservative opinion. Honestly, your whole post looks very much like it was written for you. 🙄

Unfortunately many Americans are very insular - they haven’t travelled and aren’t interested in world affairs until their 401k drops and they want to know who to blame

nonmerci99 · 12/03/2025 20:51

Parker231 · 12/03/2025 20:50

Unfortunately many Americans are very insular - they haven’t travelled and aren’t interested in world affairs until their 401k drops and they want to know who to blame

Some Americans being parochial doesn’t make the post I replied to any less false.

knitnerd90 · 13/03/2025 00:04

I've lived in the US for 15 years, near DC in fact, and I assure you I do know how the government works. I watch the sausage get made. I don't even have the energy to reply to all your points, but I will point out that your metric of success by opinion poll is laughable garbage.

Federal agencies do have a lot of power. They're also controlled by laws and regulations -- which are passed by Congress, not merely the whim of the president. I would also point out that executive action has expanded radically in the past few presidencies, partly because Congress is ineffective and the use of the virtual filibuster requires 60 votes to pass anything in the Senate, but that the courts have ruled that quite a few of those actions were illegal. In fact, in the influential decision that overturned Chevron doctrine this spring, SCOTUS even limited their ability to promulgate regulations based on laws. Congress has to do that now.

MsAmerica · 13/03/2025 00:24

SpuytenDuyvil · 10/03/2025 03:43

Knit, do you think those voters ever bother to visit National Parks? I think they are sitting in their basements watching Fox News.

I'm not sure what you mean there. I don't go to National Parks. I'm a city chick. Does that make me a bad person?

MsAmerica · 13/03/2025 00:27

SerendipityJane · 11/03/2025 10:19

the GOP has unified control of the government

If that were true, then Trumps one bigly beautiful bill would be law by now.

The real truth is the GOP is totally splintered and you will have little cabals of representatives who will leverage their wafer-thin majority in order to pursue their own grifts. Which may - or may not - alight with Trumps.

The house is in a similar state to the last Tory government. Where there were enough headbangers to threaten the parliamentary majority so Sunak was forced into a permanent compromise.

Which is why Trump wants to make Congress an irrelevance. (And they are doing a good job of helping him).

And WTF is it with politically appointed judges ? Whoever thought that was a good idea ? Clearly fucking idiots, that's who.

Being non American I can take a pop at the founding fathers .... remember their mission was to ensure that landowners kept their land. All else was fine words and parades.

It's true that the GOP may be splintered. The Democrats usually are, too. But the Republicans have always been pressured to follow the party line, and right now they are really cowed by Trump.

SpuytenDuyvil · 13/03/2025 00:33

@MsAmerica Haha, no definitely not. I have been dragged around to National Parks by DH, so I have been to many of them, but it's not my favorite thing. I am indoorsy

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread