Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Philosophy/religion

Join our Philosophy forum to discuss religion and spirituality.

Went to a talk by the Bishop of Durham lats night about Dawkin's the God Delusion and I was not impressed.

51 replies

Monkeytrousers · 16/01/2008 22:25

Me and DP being the only two athiests in there and possibly the only two who had read it, his misrepresntaions and at one point, outright lie, did not endear me to his argument.

OP posts:
UnquietDad · 16/01/2008 23:35

It's true MT, there is an element of "fighting back" these days, as more and more religious types try to get their views into the scientific agenda.

RD is criticised for writing about "theology" when he doesn't have a qualification in it - which is of course to miss the point, as he isn't writing about "theology" at all.

I'd still be happy if no scientist ever had to write or say anything on the subject of religion ever again. Sadly, the religious will never return the favour.

Pruners · 16/01/2008 23:38

Message withdrawn

candypandy · 16/01/2008 23:38

You can actually use logic to disprove the existence of the Christian God. I think it's a unique religion in that respect! All the others are empirically highly improbable, but not illogical.

I struggled with it and gave up. Choose to believe anyway. I do think it's the point in a way. If you could prove it.. then what's to believe?

UnquietDad · 16/01/2008 23:40

And they're scary people with lots of money, Pruners...

candypandy · 16/01/2008 23:41

Maybe I should read it. I must admit I assumed Dawkins had used maybe a couple of the proofs.

candypandy · 16/01/2008 23:42

Where do you see the pushing creationism? In schools..here?
Surely not

Pruners · 16/01/2008 23:43

Message withdrawn

Pruners · 16/01/2008 23:44

Message withdrawn

UnquietDad · 16/01/2008 23:45

Not here as much but it's endemic in the US - museums of creation, evolution being spun as "just a theory", creationists arguing for "equal" time for their "theory" in science lessons. About as sensible as giving over half the biology lesson on conception to talking about storks and gooseberry bushes.

UnquietDad · 16/01/2008 23:45

Maybe it is happening here more.
I'd forgotten that from MB.

candypandy · 16/01/2008 23:46

Had no idea..but promoters must realise it can't ever catch on here surely with NC.. state schools.. very strict rules about diversity of religious teaching etc.. even in Church schools

Pruners · 16/01/2008 23:49

Message withdrawn

choosyfloosy · 16/01/2008 23:49

candypandy when i found there were MNers who didn't 'believe in evolution' (i dislike the phrase but that's a quote) i realised that nearly anything is possible.

I understand that the Emmanuel College Foundation schools such as Emmanuel College Gateshead have been said to include descriptions of creationism in their science lessons but I emphasise that I have only heard this through the Meejah.

UnquietDad · 16/01/2008 23:50

I hope things will change when they finally get rid of Cowboy Bush next year.

candypandy · 16/01/2008 23:53

I am surprised and disappointed. I was eddimacated at a church school and it was "Onward Christian Soldiers" of a morning and basically be good and be nice. That's as far as it should go at school I reckon. Still leaves people the choice and I think it should be a choice.

Pruners · 16/01/2008 23:54

Message withdrawn

candypandy · 16/01/2008 23:56

religion + american politics = bedtime for me

UnquietDad · 16/01/2008 23:56

I know - ridiculously optimistic. They all bang on about Gawd after all - impossible to get elected if you don't. But Romney and Huckleberry seem the scariest from that point of view.

choosyfloosy · 17/01/2008 00:01

LOL candypandy

Pruners · 17/01/2008 00:01

Message withdrawn

Pruners · 17/01/2008 00:02

Message withdrawn

UnquietDad · 17/01/2008 00:03

interesting to see how right-wing they all are really

choosyfloosy · 17/01/2008 00:03

(hidehi pruni! how's the new place? probably about six months in?

i like 4-year-old boys, do you? so much nicer than 3-year-olds, or is that just me? 5 is supposed to be quite tough so hope for the best i guess)

SueBaroo · 17/01/2008 11:08

seriously, UQD, if you want religiously scary, Ron Paul is yer man. Romney is a cuddly Mormon, and Huckabee is just really Bush mk2, which might be scary, but it's hardly surprising.

UnquietDad · 17/01/2008 11:14

Oh yes, Ron Paul as well. They all deny evolution, though, whch makes them non-starters for me!