Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Pedants' corner

What do you think of this sentence about afternoon tea?

55 replies

MsAmerica · 22/01/2026 01:20

I thought you might like this:

What do you think of this second sentence, purely as a sentence, but also in terms of punctuation?

There was a silver tea-pot, and a silver kettle with a little spirit-lamp underneath, and a silver cream jug and a covered silver dish full of muffins. There was also hot buttered toast and honey and gentleman’s relish and a chocolate cake, a cherry cake, a seed cake and a fruit cake and some tomato sandwiches and pepper and salt and currant bread and butter.

OP posts:
belleager · 25/01/2026 13:37

Walker1178 · 25/01/2026 12:54

I can look past most of it but will never accept ‘pepper and salt’ as being correct!

For me, pepper and sait is another trick that stops it from reading like a shopping list and the reader from going into autopilot.

One effect of good writing is to make us see things fresh, and reversing the order we expect (as well as mentioning salt and pepper at all) does this.

It's also, quite simply, like the sentence structure, not incorrect. There's no rule against saying "pepper and salt". It's just not what we usually say, and Waugh is using that to give us a bit of a jolt.

upinaballoon · 25/01/2026 16:08

CaptainMyCaptain · 25/01/2026 12:36

Gentleman's Relish - Wikipedia https://share.google/NrlG3vGjSq48oFXQt

'Patum', not my incorrect thought of 'pater'. Thank you. Ah, paste.
I suppose Pater Peperium would be nearer to Daddy's Sauce.

PrizedPickledPopcorn · 25/01/2026 16:57

It conjures his eyes skipping across the table, noticing one thing after another- in the order they are seen rather than expected.
I thought it was Wind in the Willows, too.
I like it.

MsAmerica · 29/01/2026 03:17

CaptainMyCaptain · 25/01/2026 12:36

Gentleman's Relish - Wikipedia https://share.google/NrlG3vGjSq48oFXQt

Wonder what it tastes like.

OP posts:
MsAmerica · 29/01/2026 03:18

Walker1178 · 25/01/2026 12:54

I can look past most of it but will never accept ‘pepper and salt’ as being correct!

I agree. If this was by a teen in an English class, he would have had his knuckles rapped.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page