Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

When did your child potty train?

132 replies

Usingthings · 30/12/2023 14:36

I have tried a few times now but he doesn’t seem ready. What I’m wondering is how I know when he’s ready - will he just ask to use the toilet or potty?

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
lorisparkle · 31/12/2023 19:09

Honestly ds1 was a nightmare to train. It was very traumatic, he would just wee anywhere (once on the self service but in tescos). He just did not get it. I would go through multiple pairs of pants and trousers before lunch. However a friend could see how stressed and upset I was getting and told me to stop, give everyone a break and try again in a couple of months. Once they are ready it can take days but if they are not ready then it just won't work. Some children are ready young but not all.

FunkyFangtooth · 31/12/2023 19:55

@Usingthings I honestly would ignore any comments from anyone who "just did whatever at age 2" and it was all fine. Some children do just find it harder than others, and I think it is very hard for someone who had a fairly standard potty training experience to imagine what it's like to have a different experience. People said to me "you just need to sit him on the potty" which is easier said than done when you have a very distressed child going rigid! I think the majority of children are physically ready at age 3, but emotionally some aren't. I don't really think there are any cues you can necessarily look for to see if he's emotionally ready, just trial and error.

We first tried my DS at around 3 and it was awful. He refused to wee on the toilet or potty, but was so distressed about accidents. We stuck at it for a long weekend but he was so miserable and I felt so stressed out we gave up. We tried again mid November (at 3 years 5 months) and he seemed much less stressed by the whole thing, so although we still didn't get a single wee in the potty for 4 days I stuck at it. Day 4 we got our first wee, so we stuck at it a bit longer. One week in we were getting very few accidents, but I would still have to keep taking him when he looked uncomfy rather than him initiating it. I think it's really only been over this Christmas break (about 5 weeks in) he has been confidently telling me he needs a wee. Also only just starting to poo in the potty, although usually does it in his nappy first thing before we get his pants on. And he's a few months older than your son!

It's hard not to take it personally and feel a bit crap, but my daughter successfully potty trained a whole year earlier at 2 1/2 so I don't think it was anything major I did. And I'm sure the same applies to you - we are all only doing our best!

I think one thing that can take practice for them is going from learning to hold the wee in most of the time to then fully emptying the bladder on the potty. Which is why sometimes they'll have a wee then an accident a few minutes later, but this will come with practice.

Personally I think if he isn't getting distressed if you stick at it he will get there over the next few weeks but it might just take a bit longer than some children. However, if you are feeling really stressed then I think it's worth taking a break - my son's nursery said they have a few every year that take to 3 1/2 so there's no harm in trying again in a few months if you need to for your own mental wellbeing! Especially as you have ages until school (my son is starting next September which massively added to my stress!).

Good luck - it is so stressful, but one day it will click and this will all be a distant memory.

Usingthings · 31/12/2023 20:38

I would like to thank you from the bottom of my heart for these compassionate and sensible posts. I was getting myself stupidly upset about it all and there is no need. As you’ve said, it just takes some kids a bit longer. I know some think it’s laziness on my part and it really isn’t. He is mostly okay with wees although admittedly this is with me telling him to have a wee rather than instigating it himself and he still has a lot of accidents. Poos are another story. However we will get there. I’ve found this Christmas a bit tiring and stressful so new year and a renewed start and faith that all will come right.

OP posts:

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 31/12/2023 20:54

DS2 was 2y 10m. We'd tried a l month earlier unsuccessfully, but he decided to have another go.

DD declared "pants today" at 2y 3m, and refused any more nappies.

Both dc were dry night, day, wees and poos within a fortnight.

lorisparkle · 31/12/2023 21:05

@Usingthings I do think that toilet training (like sleeping, weaning, walking, learning to talk, read etc) can feel like some kind of competition and the earlier they do it the 'better' parent you are. This is thankfully rubbish. DS1 was a terrible sleeper, nightmare to toilet train, late at talking and reading and is now predicted As and A*s in his 4 A levels. Nobody asked on his UCAS application when he was toilet trained! You are doing a fantastic job and it will all slot into place.

toomanyleggings · 31/12/2023 21:43

We started at 2 and a half and have had brilliant runs with it and then periods were we totally regress with poos. Wees have always been pretty fine. She’s just turned 3 now and we hardly have accidents

pinksheepbeep · 31/12/2023 23:03

lorisparkle · 31/12/2023 21:05

@Usingthings I do think that toilet training (like sleeping, weaning, walking, learning to talk, read etc) can feel like some kind of competition and the earlier they do it the 'better' parent you are. This is thankfully rubbish. DS1 was a terrible sleeper, nightmare to toilet train, late at talking and reading and is now predicted As and A*s in his 4 A levels. Nobody asked on his UCAS application when he was toilet trained! You are doing a fantastic job and it will all slot into place.

I love this post and 100% agree.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread