Everyone has the right to bring up their child how they want. V has talked about how she does it - I havent read any post from her where she has said "and if you dont do it the same way you are a bad parent" or any form of judgement at all! (although its a bloody long thread, so I accept I may have missed great chunks of it - and I think I possibly dozed off at one point!!)
We are all entitled to raise our children as we see fit, and this is a great place to debate the pros and cons of our individual approach, even to say things like I think that X is a better aproach than Y because .... But what I think is wrong, is personal abuse.
"I don't agree with that point of view because...", is fine, good, great, healthy debate. "You are a moron for having that point of view", or other assorted insults and sarcastic comments is, in my humble view, totally unnecessary.