Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Other subjects

How do you talk to people who are into alternative medicine??!

163 replies

Pruni · 18/08/2005 22:19

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
edam · 19/08/2005 14:44

? fishy?

Pruni · 19/08/2005 14:45

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
cod · 19/08/2005 14:47

Message withdrawn

edam · 19/08/2005 14:48

Practically the only German word I know is 'schalplatterspeilen'. Which is record-player. Never particularly useful and considerably less so since the invention of CDs!

katierocket · 19/08/2005 14:52

"The point is surely that my gp or my hospital dr is not making money directly from prescribing me a particular medication. Whereas the cranial osteopath I saw wanted me to commit to six sessions at £35 a pop"
I'm not sure this is the point Pruni. When I had chronic back ache my GP prescribed me the equivalent of 6 nurofen (sp!) a day without blinking. That horrified me. Osteopath sorted it out in 3 sessions. Now if you ask me what was better for my body it's not rocket science is it. GPs are exactly that general practitioners whereas a lot of therapists (depending on what they do) specialise in one particular area.

Out of interest (geninue question) have you ever tried anything other than western medicine?

Pruni · 19/08/2005 15:01

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
edam · 19/08/2005 15:08

Am I, Cod?

katierocket · 19/08/2005 15:10

Ah, ok, that surprises me actually because from your first couple of posts you do come across as not really wanting to go near any 'therapies'. I still think it was harsh to say that "it's about making money".

Reki is interesting, does any mumsnetter know how it works?

Jimjams · 19/08/2005 15:16

hmb - because it hasn't been shaken

homeppathic treatment on the NHS- you have to be in the right area basically- there are NHS homeppathic hospitals but waiting lists are long- easier if you have a practiioner attached to your gp's practice- or if your GP is trained in homeopathy.

Pruni · 19/08/2005 15:16

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
morningpaper · 19/08/2005 15:18

me i agree!

Caribbeanqueen · 19/08/2005 15:23

There was a thread about reiki a while ago, I'll have a look.

Caribbeanqueen · 19/08/2005 15:25

\link{http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk?topicid=1600&threadid=66603\reiki thread

Jimjams · 19/08/2005 15:25

medical students can now take (optional) modules in complementaty mediciine. My tutor teaches a module on homeoopathy and finds it really interesting. His first session he had a real mixed bag of students. At the end one wanted to give up medicine to become a homeopath (!- he talked her out of it), and one started the course intending to disprove homeopathy and ended up being less sure about not believing iyswim- he certainly respected it anyway and thanked the tutor foor a very interesting course.

There is an aim to bring more complementary medicines into the NHS- will probably happpen over the next few years. It's a good thing- partly because of this proper registration is having to happen soo you will be able to ensure that your practioner meets required standard.

RE the placebo affect- sorry- but just no way can ds1 have been affected by the placebo effect. he's severely autistic and non verbal, no idea of medicines. Just not possible.

Also seen aconite stop ds2's croup attack- within 5 mins was back to sleep.

That I found less "impressive" that the situation I described with ds1 way down the thread.

Someone has already mentioned The Field- it's a good book for explaining how it probably works. Other books that don't deal with complementary medicine but do go into quantum physics are things like hyperspace- they're worth a read as well. You've just got to stop thinking like chemists and start thinking like physicists.

Caribbeanqueen · 19/08/2005 15:26

Why can't I do links? I'll try again

reiki

Jimjams · 19/08/2005 15:26

But bach flower remedies cost £3 a bottle and last for years and years and years..... Hardly going to break the bank!

iris66 · 19/08/2005 15:38

Been away & just noticed Pruni's q re: reiki. I practise reiki regularly and still find it difficult to explain but here goes... my understanding is that it is an intentional direction of energy through practitioner to client(energy follows thought.
Energy is everywhere since it is constantly being created and destroyed between atoms causing a multi directional web effect string theory and quantum mechanics explain it better but are rather too complex to be succinct!)All organic matter emits energy and the quality/quantity of that energy is dependent on the "health status" of the organism (experiments in the 70s by the Russians, using, amongst other things Kirlian photography (photographing auras, to you and me) concluded that the more complex the organism, the more energy it emits,and needs (and, as an aside, demonstrated that microwaving any organism removes the energy from it completely - kicking off the debate that as complex organisms we need whole complex foods to function properly and that the more you process something, the less "energy" it contains - fast food anyone?!) Reiki is not dissimilar to faith healing (in that the energy is the same) but is merely a more focussed means of transferring it. hope this helps

lunachic · 19/08/2005 15:41

what type of reiki do you practise iris66

iris66 · 19/08/2005 15:57

Usui - got into it as "something different to do 'cos I'm bored" about 7 years ago and have been using it almost daily ever since.

lunachic · 19/08/2005 16:19

my teacher
did usui and then seichem/tera mai(shes a master in both -she rates seichem best)
i have done level one in this and will do level two sometime i guess im just taking it slowly i dont use the energy enough really it is good though

sunchowder · 19/08/2005 16:28

So...I read this. Don't you think this is like sharing a good recipe? If something has worked for you, you just want to share it with others! If you have the best lemon drizzle recipe and someone is wanting to make a cake, wouldn't you offer the recipe? I guess you either say, yes, no and thank you.

happymerryberries · 19/08/2005 17:33

Sorry to reurect a thread, but you might be interested that there is a debate on this subject on Radio 4 tonight. Two to speak for complementary meds integration into the NHS and two to speak against it.

cod · 19/08/2005 17:50

Message withdrawn

happymerryberries · 19/08/2005 17:52

lost me there cod

cod · 19/08/2005 17:54

Message withdrawn