Twins in separate classes?

[icf90]

We recently found out DT's have both been accepted into our #1 primary choice which is great. School have been in contact and asked whether we want them in the same class or not. Once they are put into classes in YR they stay the same through to Y6. Both boys are very outgoing and confident so would thrive in separate classes or the same one. DH wants them in separate classes so they make their own friends and don't just stay together. At their current preschool they are in the same class and are very close so I think they should be together. We have to reply to school by next Friday because they need to sort out classes for taster/induction meetings in June. What would you do?

I’m a twin and I also have twins and I would say separate, my twins were together in nursery class and separate from reception. My sister and I were together throughout, that’s what they did then. Tbh I don’t remember identity issues but the lack of privacy really bothered me, there was always someone who knew everything that had happened at school that day and vice versa, it was all a bit much

I split mine up.
Both have done well but back then one struggled with his dyslexia. I did it so he could get the support he needed away from his brother and so the teaching staff would stop comparing them.