Majorca or Menorca

[Mamaemmeline]

We are trying to plan a holiday and we are going around in circles and going bleary eyed! Any opinions on any of the destinations below? Thank you!

Majorca:
Porto colom
Paguera
Sa Coma
Puerto pollensa
Cala Ratjada

Menorca:
Santo Tomas
Arenal d'en Castell
Cala n'Bosch

The Playa palmeras in Sa Coma is fantastic and very close to the beach. The beach as another poster pointed out is lovely. There's also 3 bars there but all spaced out. I only realised that part when after swimming used the bar as landmark to go back to where the sunbed was and couldn't work out why my sunbed wasn't where I'd left it. Plenty of places to walk to in either direction and around a 2 mile walk to Cala Millor. There's also a nice walk to a castle which is maybe around a 30 min walk

We’ve done both and both are lovely! You really can’t go wrong. We tend to do villa holidays and hire a car so we can go exploring.

We had a great time, very cheap AI for 4 in Cala Ratjada last April. Found it pleasant, quite quiet but perfectly fine.

Just looking at booking menorca... is 2 weeks too long ? We are taking a 1 year old and 5 year old. Is there enough to do? Thank you !