Yes, and bearing in mind some accommodation is closer to £10k if catered, students whose parents pay all the accom and then have all the min loan for spending have close to £15k per year which is substantially above a full maintenance loan.
I think lots of MN families say they will pay the accom and then let student have the min maintenance loan for spending, as it seems administratively easier and doesn’t require calculating what needed. I suspect some don’t realise quite how much above the full maintenance loan that gives them.
Personally, we started from a figure we thought they needed and worked back. Using this approach could mean students live on something closer to the full maintenance loan (we used £12.25k as the proper inflationary adjusted maintenance loan figure - covered fully catered halls plus £80 per week term time - has been plenty) and the extra £3k some of them were receiving and didn’t really need, could either save parents money or mean they took a smaller maintenance loan.
I think parents and students need to engage with the numbers - costs of accom, food, socialising and come up with a figure. Then ensure the kids have what is needed - could be all parental contribution or mix of that and student loan and/or money from student work in term time and/or holidays - according to family circumstances.
I’d also plan to review yearly rather than stick with ‘parent pays accom and live off min maintenance loan’ - 2nd and 3rd costs can differ a lot to first year. So what they need/receive can differ too.
Rather than automatically taking whatever loan was available, we look to take as little as possible. It will be paid off sooner. We work on the basis it will be paid back and less loan means paying it off sooner and less accrued interest - good for DC.
Even 3 years if min maintenance loan is an sig debt to be funding across many years when they might have childcare costs etc. What’s the point of having that so they could have £15k per year combined parent and loan contribution, if they could have lived really well on £12-13k?