First time posting on this thread but a long term lurker, so please be kind and objective with me and sorry if I over share ! It's a terrible personality trait.
Firstly, thank you to everyone who contributes in any capacity to this thread as all the information has been extremely helpful in our long journey.
My own child didn't make the cut for shortlisting at Oxford for Medicine despite being amazing ( in my opinion
)
I think the algorithm used at Oxford ( I'm not sure about Cambridge) reflects their background school performance.
Child had great GCSEs, Predicted 3 A stars and an A at A level plus a significantly above average entrance test score.
However, 9 grade 9s, a7 and a 6 (out of the possible 11 sat) just wasn't good enough for her course and you can't argue with that. I believe ( and could be totally wrong) that Oxford looks at the percentage of the top grades ( 8 & 9s) to GCSE taken and my child's fell below the 90% of top grades and Ucat wasn't top 9th decile to counter that out .
I think this is fair enough as it levels the playing field between schools as extra consideration is given to students who attend less academic schools.
My only gripe is her contextual circumstances ( FSM, young carer due to my disability) may have had less impact because of her school type ( state grammar) which I feel a little salty about - can't lie!
Oxford admission statement says that 'FSM is a flag that tutors should consider when shortlisting due to under representation 'as only 6% on FSM nationally meet Oxford A level entry requirements ( my child is likely to exceed the standard offer for Oxford come results day) Not bragging as I'm sure they all will who apply.
We are a poor household and fall in this bracket , but also a happy family ( money can't buy that ).She gained a place at said grammar by her own Merrit as we live in an opt out county rather than opt in so primary school orchestrated the entrance test and all the children sat it ( possibly some opted out).
My child is pretty stoic and thinks her application would have been treated fairly by the admissions Tutors, so she bares no grudges but I do 😂