Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Guest posts

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Guest post: Nicky Morgan - "Why academisation is best for our schools"

999 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 18/03/2016 17:09

As parents, we all want the best for our children. We want to make sure they have access to the best opportunities and to help them grow up into well-rounded adults. Making sure that our children have a high quality education is a key part of that.

I want to outline exactly what academisation means and why I truly believe this is the best way forward for our schools. Our children only have one shot at receiving the best education and I am committed to ensuring this happens as swiftly as possible.

We need to put our trust into the hands of the people that know best how to run our schools - the teachers - and the academy system does just that. tells you more about what an academy is. It gives schools greater autonomy to make the decisions that are right for their community and pupils. After all, we have the finest generation of teachers ever and being part of an academy helps put the power back in their hands.

The most recent results show that the percentage of pupils achieving the expected level in reading, writing and maths at the end of Key Stage 2 in primary academies has risen by 4%, from 67% in 2014 to 71% in 2015. Additionally, when it comes to secondary, it's a similar story with converter academies which are performing 7.2% above the national average, with 64.3% of pupils achieving five good GCSEs.

However, a dynamic school system where all schools are academies is just one part of a much wider plan to improve our education system which I set out yesterday in our white paper.

It is every parent's right to know their child is in an excellent school no matter where in the country they live. I am confident that this move will guarantee a higher school standard with each academy held to account for the performance of their pupils.

Ultimately, I am committed to making it easier for you as a parent to play an even more active role in your child's education. In essence, I want to put young people and parents first – something that might sound obvious, but the truth is that for too long parents have been an afterthought in our education system. We want you as parents to have a much stronger voice in what happens to your child during their school years, because we know that you want the very best for your child.

So how are we doing that? Firstly, I am well aware that the education system can appear complex to many parents. I am dedicated to changing this once and for all, and putting the control firmly back in your hands. As a result of this, I plan to introduce a new, online Parents Portal from as early as next year. This portal will enable parents' access to key information and allow you to support your child's learning.

Alongside this, we have changed the curriculum and the way that students will be assessed. This will help to raise standards and make sure that your child leaves school with the knowledge and skills they need to succeed. It is imperative that every child fulfils their potential, and this includes stretching the most able pupils.

More young people will also study the EBacc - a combination of maths, English, two sciences, a humanity and a language - up to the age of 16. And the exams and qualifications young people are awarded will set a new international gold standard that is respected by employers, helping them to succeed in our increasingly global world.

I am a firm believer that an exceptional education transforms children's futures and everything outlined in this White Paper is committed to ensuring that parents and pupils come first. Our goal must always be to ensure every single child leaves school with the best education and the opportunity to excel in adult life. I believe that together, we can achieve that goal.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PrettyBrightFireflies · 20/03/2016 22:18

We never did find out what your job is Prettybright, did we?

Yes, I posted it pages ago!

PrettyBrightFireflies · 20/03/2016 22:24

The Michael Rosen article is excellent - accurate, scathing and witty!

CobblerBob · 20/03/2016 22:33

I had my comment removed. It was nothing compared to what I'd say to Nicky Morgan face to face. It really wasn't as bad a PrettyNickyMorgan would like you to believe.

Comparing our education stats with other countries makes me so mad. As if league tables meant anything. I was in a position to hire people from abroad when I worked abroad. The company employed many people with masters degrees from India, China... The least qualified were the few Brits. BUT rote learning facts to inflate results only gets you so far. The majority of my staff were spectacularly uncreative, couldn't think for themselves and were useless at research. What they were very, very good at was following orders and expanding work to fit the hours. Few could manage their own hours and work effectively without constant direction. This was an industry which absolutely required creative thinking. It was the most frustrating time of my life. I'll take a "badly" educated creative dude over a robot any day.

I am so against turning our schools into automaton hothouses. The creative industries earn billions for this country, not everyone is fantastic at maths or science and why should they be?

I've just resigned as a parent governor as the my school head gave the year 6 teaching job to an unqualified yes-person who cannot control the class. My daughter is in that class and is suffering. The discipline is confused, contradictory and often knee jerk. The class is struggling with the new SATs. No-one knows what is going on. It is a mess. This is the future if we accept wholesale academisation (not a fucking word.)

PrettyBrightFireflies · 20/03/2016 22:39

It really wasn't as bad a PrettyNickyMorgan would like you to believe.

Are you suggesting that I'm sock-puppeting?

CobblerBob · 20/03/2016 22:47

have you got a sock puppet?

Anyhoo, read this, tis very good.

www.theguardian.com/education/2016/mar/20/michael-rosen-on-academy-schools-local-democracy-bites-the-dust?CMP=share_btn_fb

PrettyBrightFireflies · 20/03/2016 22:52

Is there an echo in here ?

Yes, I've read the Guardian piece. And? It's an opinion. It is, unlike many others that have been published, well written, and accurate in its content - but could be considered, as others have said about my posts on this thread, disingenuous.

It's politics. People aren't all going to agree.

Valentine2 · 20/03/2016 23:00

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/education/a1540850--1billion-of-title-deeds-for-schools-transferred-to-private-companies

I have been looking for this. To me (and I have had no finance education so I could be wrong though I don't think I am) it makes more and more sense now that Cameron appointed a woman as education minister whose background is in corporate law. Laugh or cry, whatever suits you.

MNHQ

I have just come back to remind you that you have promised to demand the statistics behind this guest post from Nicky Morgan office tomorrow morning.
My challenge was this: she provides the solid data, facts and figures that led to this decision. Or you remove this post altogether:

curluponthesofa · 20/03/2016 23:01

Disingenuous is not a word I'd use to describe Michael Rosen.

It shouldn't be about politics, that's the point, it should be about what is best for our children. This isn't just some interesting after-dinner debate - it's about our children's whole experience of education. But they seem to be the last ones to be considered in this sorry mess.

Valentine2 · 20/03/2016 23:02

Pretty
Politics?
Are you for the real?

madgibbo · 20/03/2016 23:03

look like youve done a sterling job there NM..........

PrettyBrightFireflies · 20/03/2016 23:08

To ensure that education remains outside the scope of politics, it would have to be completely removed from political control.

All the while politicians, local and national, can ignore the advice of the professionals they appoint to advise them - it's political.

webdeborah · 20/03/2016 23:12

I would say that any country's best chance of success in educating its children lies in employing qualified teachers. Just a hunch.

Valentine2 · 20/03/2016 23:14

Pretty

I have not gone through all uour previous posts on this thread but are you trying to derail this thread?

We are trying to have a serious discussion here and what you have just posted is trolling in comparison.

Valentine2 · 20/03/2016 23:15

Sorry for the wrong word. post not thread.

biddy53 · 20/03/2016 23:19

valentine whilst we want the statistics from NM, the thread shouldn't be removed - there are too many valid arguments against "academisation".

it shouldn't be about politics, that's the point, it should be about what is best for our children. This isn't just some interesting after-dinner debate - it's about our children's whole experience of education. But they seem to be the last ones to be considered in this sorry mess

Good post

Valentine2 · 20/03/2016 23:35

Biddy53
I am sorry for not making my point in a better way: I wanted to write that Nicky Morgan's guest post should be removed if she fails to respond with statistically strong facts and figures.
I am almost sure there will be a way of doing this without removing the hundreds of comments under it that contain discussions which i really learnt a lot from.
Infact I think this whole set of comments belongs in the Mumsnet Classic already considering the potentially irreversibly damaging nature of the proposed school status changes.

MsDinosaur · 20/03/2016 23:42

Pretty - you clearly know a lot about the education sector but please can you remind us what your job is (I don't want to have to scroll back on my phone and I have obviously missed your response to the original question about your job - thank you). I am interested because you come across as well-informed and you write intelligent-sounding answers. However, you are yet to put forward any compelling argument in favour of academies. I am curious to know your involvement (if any) with academies and/or LAs.

To say that some LAs do or do not do X, Y and Z but academy chains/trusts might isn't really a reason to do away with LAs. Let's face it - a bad chain/trust will be just as bad (or potentially worse) than a bad LA. Surely it would be better to compel LAs to improve and learn from their more successful 'peers' in other LAs?!

biddy53 · 20/03/2016 23:45

Fair enough Valentine - let's push for NM giving some verifiable facts and figures, preferably as part of a web chat.

curluponthesofa · 20/03/2016 23:47

Just posting this petition again for anyone new to the thread:
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/124702

curluponthesofa · 20/03/2016 23:49

And this one (now over 100k)
petition.parliament.uk/petitions/124747

nattiew · 21/03/2016 06:10

"We need to put our trust into the hands of the people that know best how to run our schools - the teachers - and the academy system does just that. This video tells you more about what an academy is. It gives schools greater autonomy to make the decisions that are right for their community and pupils. After all, we have the finest generation of teachers ever and being part of an academy helps put the power back in their hands."

Really Nicky Morgan? Then leave us alone to do our jobs! I am a KS2 teacher and a parent of two boys and I have absolutely no faith in anything your Government has introduced to 'improve' the education system.

All I see are tired, stressed children who are being assessed and tested repeatedly to jump through your "target" hoops. My own child is in Year 6 and burst into floods of tears when attempting the new mock Sats papers for maths. He is a very able mathematician by the way but was being tested on things he has not yet been taught due to the fact he's had a year to learn content for a whole key stage. Not to mention content from KS3 that has been forced into the Primary Curriculum and the straight jacket approach to teaching and learning! (Yes, like many very famous and popular Authors over the decades I have used the ! incorrectly according to your new grammar policy too - whoops! However, I prefer to follow the grammar of the aforementioned coveted Authors rather than some jumped up politician!)

Trust teachers you say? Okay let's scrap QTS which is an internationally recognised professional qualification. Let's employ unqualified teachers. Let's decentralise the profession so that teachers really have no way of voicing their concerns. Let's force unrealistic targets, Sats assessments and National Curriculum onto those teachers to train our 'poor little monkeys to perform to the tune of the ringmaster'. Let's remove Teacher's passion and flair for creativity and replace it with the love of data administration and a passion for assessment. Let's not believe a teacher who has been working closely with children to have any say in what their actual ability is but rather rely on a test designed to catch them out with trick questions and incredibly difficult questions previously asked at secondary school level.

Let's demoralise teachers with endless changes to the education system which results in a choice of continuing to struggle on with it all or leave a job you once loved to keep you from burning out.

Let's enforce an undemocratic decision to academise every school so you can 'sell out' future generations of children to your business cronies who are surely going to listen to Teacher's concerns about ill thought out 'profit' making decisions.

Mmmmmm well done on your ability to give teachers control Nicky! That's almost as reassuring as your plans to give parents control by removing them from governing roles at schools but offering them a 'portal'!

To all those people who voted these muppets into power, you must be so proud of yourselves. Privatisation of the NHS and our Education system was always coming. Cuts to disability support for our most vulnerable people was always coming. Now we have all got to live with the consequences and our children will pay the ultimate price!

Devilishpyjamas · 21/03/2016 06:40

Valentine - Nicky Morgan's office would love this car crash of a thread (from her point of view) to go. Don't give her that option. I have sent the link to my very slim majority tory MP. He may as well know how angry people are with this utterly incompetent government.

Peregrina · 21/03/2016 06:41

To all those people who voted these muppets into power, you must be so proud of yourselves. Privatisation of the NHS and our Education system was always coming. Cuts to disability support for our most vulnerable people was always coming. Now we have all got to live with the consequences and our children will pay the ultimate price!

Well said.
Just what can we do, apart from sign the petitions, which I have already done? Somehow we must harness this energy.

Abuelita · 21/03/2016 07:08

The Department for Education has misrepresented stats since Gove became Education Secretary. Morgan's foreword to the Education Bill is full of dodgy data. www.localschoolsnetwork.org.uk/2016/03/morgan-waffles-in-white-paper-foreword-describes-acting-first-thinking-later-as-bold-reforms

Clarella · 21/03/2016 07:09

Tried to post last night.

Your post should be the guest post to reply to Nicky morgan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread