My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Guest posts

Guest post: "The traditional school system is effectively a sausage factory"

157 replies

MumsnetGuestPosts · 23/09/2015 10:01

I watched my 15-year-old daughter walk into a classroom for the first time this month. While most other parents dropped off their four-year-olds for day one of school, I waved off the daughter I had, until now, been educating at home.

My daughter had made her own decision, and for her own reasons she put on a uniform and joined our local school in year 11. I, meanwhile, will continue to home educate my 12-year-old and five-year-old. My three-year-old won't be going to preschool.

And so, while many parents are sharing pictures and anecdotes of their child's first month at school at the moment, a growing number aren't. We are choosing, instead, to home-school.

In my view, the traditional school system is effectively a sausage factory. No matter how much is said about individualised or child-led systems, the nature of the beast is that it's mass processing. I wanted my children to have time to be children, and time to be themselves. Individuals.

The rise in this movement is perhaps driven in part by changes to the education system, but also, I suspect, because it is now so easy to network. There are national and local Facebook groups, and depending on where you are, lots of groups meeting up.

Home education is easiest with younger children - there's lots of outside play, lots of art, craft, and stories. There are so many resources now that primary age education is very achievable either following a structured school-at-home model, or completely following your child's interests or, as is most likely, doing something in between. That's my approach with my younger ones - the five-year-old is very interested in art and nature, and I've picked up great nature resources very cheaply in Lidl. We do some semi-formal activity most mornings - I'm also Montessori trained and use these resources regularly too. Afternoons are more free format.


I'm a lot more relaxed and confident with the younger two than I was first time round. There were all sorts of panics about learning to read with my eldest, as we felt it was the central skill. Now though, I know most children get there when they're ready, and that happens at varying ages. So as long as I'm making sure we're offering the chance to develop skills, I don't worry about ticking off any age related boxes.

Questions about academic issues tend to come later in the age range, and I will admit that qualifications can be the issue. There are courses that can be studied from home, and there's a thriving support network helping families find examination centers that will take private candidates. If any government was serious about helping home educators, they could make a single change to say that every area should have at least one state school that will take private candidates, Having details of the exam boards on a central website would also make life easier.

Qualifications are why my daughter has chosen to go to school. She believes it will be easier to follow courses done with her peers, and for her, I think it's the right choice. She is finding the organisational aspects of school more challenging than the academic side and she does have an uneven level of learning, being advanced in English and creatively, but not having covered all the maths she needs. But we are well placed to support her through that.

My 12-year-old, however, is determined that he won't go to school for any reason. He's already started to prepare for the maths and computing qualifications that will suit him, and in a year or so, I'll be hunting for one of those exam centers.

Home education was a philosophical choice for me and something I considered before I had children. I discovered the potential while on a teacher training course back in the 90s. Once we had children I looked into the subject further and found a wonderful network of early years home ed families, brought together by the Muddlepuddle email list as it was then - it is now the Early Years HE group on Yahoo. As well as the email list, there were local and national meetups and camps. There are now a number of national organisations too, such as the Home Education Advisory Service and Education Otherwise. Although home educators don’t have to follow the national curriculum, resources are available if they choose to.

My traditional teacher training (PGCE) is of next to no help as a home educator, as most of what you learn that way is about lesson planning and managing a classroom, although some of the incidental reading was interesting. My Montessori training and experience, however, is very useful, particularly with younger children, as it's all about practical hands on learning and seeing children as independent learners.

As for socialisation - yesterday we went to home education roller skating and soft play. Today my 12 -year-old will go to an after school hours computing club. My 15-year-old is (almost) struggling to fit school in around her other commitments - paper round, swim club, army cadets. On offer locally there are home education art sessions, forest schools, and a communal group where each family brings an activity.

Is home education for everyone? No, there's no one approach that suits every child or every family. But it's great to see a rising awareness of it and for people to know that they have choices. When it comes down to it, that's the important thing.

OP posts:
Report
NewLife4Me · 25/09/2015 13:07

bruffin

The point I didn't make very well Grin was that maybe dc who have been H.ed don't necessarily go into traditional types of work.
Admittedly, I only have my own experience and what I have read to suggest this.
I suppose there are a range of careers that H.edded dc go for, the same as schooled.

Report
SirChenjin · 25/09/2015 13:11

I'm sure you got my meaning Ice....

School kids are underprepared for setting their own goals at uni?! What a ridiculous and over-generalised claim to make. I appreciate that you did say generally, but what research are you basing that on?

Report
NewLife4Me · 25/09/2015 13:28

I think it depends on the child tbh not necessarily the type of education they have had.
We have 2 grown up dc who went all the way through school. They did ok, not as good as they could have in good schools but we don't have any of those here Sad They have average jobs although one does have a degree.
DD on the other hand is completely different and up until leaving school at 8 was raised the same, with the same values.
She is way beyond her years for knowing what she wants, how to get there, what is expected and is motivated, determined and ruthless in her attitude to progressing. She seeks every opportunity she can to further her career, networks, and is already being followed by the professors who will teach her at the higher ed institute of her choosing.
She is like this, her brothers weren't. H.ed has given her the opportunities to do this where school couldn't.
However, H.ed for 3 years has not given her the personality she has, nor the drive and ambition, that was there from being tiny.

Report
IceBeing · 25/09/2015 14:07

sirchen I interviewed a number of students asking them why they thought they had struggled in their first year on our course.

They often said they had come from schools where all there work was scheduled for them and they knew exactly what they had to do in every hour of the day etc. When they started uni, noone was telling them what to do so they basically stopped doing anything. They then started to cotton on but it was too late and they got left behind.

We did the surveying to try and improve the way we introduce students to uni style learning...we were actually a bit surprised by how many people said they interpreted no specific instructions to work on the course material as there being no need to do any work...

Report
IceBeing · 25/09/2015 14:12

sirchen the point about not being walking adverts for home ed, is that while there have been lots of massively ignorant comments about home ed on here...noone assumes parents who send their kids to school are advertising that others should do the same. I am not advertising for home ed. I suppose it would make my life slightly easier if more people did it so it wasn't such an alien concept but the actual impact to me and mine of others sending their kids to school is very low.

It is a mistake to imagine we are here trying to entice others into it.

Now from the other side, it actually is to the advantage of anyone that sends their kids to school that others should home ed. So it is a bit of a mystery why people who school AREN't advocating home ed.....instead of saying stop doing that, it's silly...come over crowd my kids class some more!

Report
SirChenjin · 25/09/2015 14:38

And a PP on here has a very different experience of students. ...as a parent of a student I certificate don't recognise your cliam. All the students I know have been responsible for their own learning in the latter ywars of school, and have had no problems with the transition.

You appear to have misunderstood my use of advert. The narrowest and most offensive views on here have come from the HEs - which is not a good reflection of the learning experience.

Report
SirChenjin · 25/09/2015 14:48

Excuse typos - in a rush on phone

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.