Suzy, I have just spoken to my mum and it seems she had a different version of Hashimoto's.
Anyway, just for the record: apparently she initially was diagnosed as being overactive (she had a goitre, weight loss, anxiety etc) and was considered untreatable and ended up having surgery which removed 95% of her thyroid gland.
Following a biopsy she was diagnosed as having Hashimoto's and therefore now underactive and was put on 50mcg of thyroxine. This was increased by 50 mcg every couple of months until she finally ended up on 150mcg, adn she has been on this dose for quite a few years now and feels fine.
My mum says she remembers that each time the dose was increased, she went back to feeling how she did before the operation; she described it as a mild version of St Vitus' Dance, and would only last for a few days each time.
I know this doesn't relate to your situation but she fully understands your anxiety of not wanting to go back to suffering those awful symptoms. My mum now gets very anxious when she has to have a blood test.
Is there any chance you may be having panic attacks ? (which can cause similarish symptoms and can be linked to your anxiety remembering how ill you were)
Anyway, go back to your GP and discuss how you are feeling - ASAP!
Best wishes, let us know how you get on.
(PS, bear in mind that my mum was first diagnosed 20 years ago, and had the op 15 years ago)