Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Food/recipes

For related content, visit our food content hub.

A strategy for fussy eaters that has really worked for us

55 replies

macherie · 09/05/2009 12:40

DS2 is 9, and an very fussy eater, the kind who will have a tantrum if the chicken is touching the potatoes, or the toast is too brown, so fairly hardcore fussy.

Until recently is was living on a diet of (lightly) toasted bagels, pasta, chorizo (!) and apple juice.

I'm pretty well informed about nutrition, the rest of the family eats very well, very little processed food, meals cooked from scratch, etc.

I have read all the books and tried all the tricks. Nothing worked and it was making life a misery - he wasn't eating enough, it was affecting his behaviour and impacting on his brother and sister.

So I took him to a psychologist, she gave me a strategy, and it has worked. He is trying new foods, and eating better than he has for years, his behaviour has improved imesurably, and our lives have been changed for the better.

I know we are not the only one's experiencing this so I'm going to post it here in the hope this might help someone else

Firstly you, the parent needs to be in the right frame of mind, as the first few days might be tough (although it was MUCH easier than I anticipated) so don't try this the week before your period

Choose a time when the child is hungriest, probably before dinner.

Choose the food you want the child to try, say, carrot.

Before dinner put a bowl of carrots on the table.

Everyone (we choose to do it as a family, for democratic purposes and not to single out the fussy eater) has to have ONE BITE.
That's all just one bite, of course if they like a bit of encouragement might lead them to try more, but go easy, no pushing.

After the bite, you have dinner, but if you don't take the bite, then no dinner.

The parent must stay CALM, if the child doesn't want to try the carrot "ok, if you don't want to try it, that's your choice, but you can't have dinner if you don't take one bite of carrott"

You must be resolute - no carrot, no dinner. BUT it has only come to this once with us. We had a bit of a stand off over banana, but it was pasta for dinner so he gave in eventually (3 hours later)!

So no taste of carrot, no dinner AND no other food until you have had the bite of carrot, so no supper, no bedtime snack, NOTHING until you have had the bite of carrot. YOU MUST NOT GIVE IN. This is hard but IT WORKS!

Say you are trying carrot for Sunday lunch and he won't eat the carrot, so no lunch, well bring the carrot with you if you're going out later, and no ice cream or treats unless he has ONE BITE of carrot.

The psychologist recommended using one food only for a 10 day period, based on the idea that children may need to try a new food 10 times before they accept it. We found that if he liked something, we would then include it as part of his normal diet, and then moved on to try something else.

3 weeks on he is now eating lots of veggies, a little fruit, dishes like risotto and casserole which he would never have tried before.

Because he is 9, I felt it was better to sit down and explain what we were going to do and why, and perhaps that is why it has worked so well.

I know this is long, but I hope it helps someone

OP posts:
Mins · 21/10/2012 23:21

Thanks again for the tips - it really is very hard. Dinner wasn't too bad - he did eat some of it although not as much as I would have liked - he also had pitta bread and hummus & fruit which was good so had his treat afterwards. I like your idea about making it seem like you almost don't care whether he eats it or not - will def try that out. Anyway thanks again - will see how this week goes! Grin

TodaysAGoodDay · 21/10/2012 23:39

What a bloody good idea, I will try it with the world's fussiest eater, no really, he really is my 5 yr old starting tomorrow. Brilliant! Thanks.

Becca220679 · 08/01/2013 20:14

Oh my god! someone please help me, We have the worlds fussiest 8 yr old boy. He loves carrot so that wouldnt work, (he wont eat it if its cooked) He would live on rubbish given half a chance, pizza, chips etc etc, but we like to cook wholesome healthy meals without having to cook a seperate meal for him. Every meal time is dreaded. he sits and looks at his plate, not too much so its not daunting and says "I dont like it" this is without even trying it. we have tried encouragement, ignoring, offering the promise of pudding if some of it gets eaten, or even tried. we have even tried putting the same meal infrount of him the next day, (shepards pie went on for 4 days untill he beat us)!!! we are at our wits end and we honestly dont know where he continues to get his energy from. He doesnt snack, has no behavioural problems and seems just plain stubborn. 9times out of 10, he goes to bed with no dinner because i refuse to make him something else. We, as a busy family, just want the one time the family get to sit together to be a friendly, happy time. Any ideas?

LondonMother · 10/01/2013 21:03

Sympathies to everyone who has a picky eater. My son was like that from about a year old. He was very healthy on the whole but it was a lot quicker to list the foods he would eat than the ones he wouldn't. I decided early on that it was important to us that mealtimes should be happy times, not stressful. I thought about what he ate and reassured myself that he was getting the full range of nutrients. OK, it wasn't that varied but it was varied enough - as somebody upthread said, in many parts of the world the people eat the same thing at every meal without much chance to try different things. I made whatever I thought the rest of us would enjoy. On some occasions I knew he would eat that. On other occasions I knew he wouldn't so I did something quick and easy for him alongside. It really wasn't much extra work to put some chicken nuggets in the oven on the shelf below the roast veg the rest of us were having, and he would eat those with rice and salad while we had roast veg, chickpeas and rice.

It would have been much harder if he had tried to eat only crisps, biscuits etc but fortunately there were several fruits and vegetables he would eat. My husband is a bit picky too and I think there was a genetic element. I will eat almost anything and our daughter will eat most things, but I had a cousin who was super-picky. Seeing the stress that caused in his family was one of the things that made me determined not to make a big fuss over my son's pickiness.

I am happy to report that he is 19 now and will eat most things. Compulsory (and good) school dinners in the first two years of secondary school made a big difference. So there is light at the end of the tunnel!

iamaduck · 18/07/2013 18:26

Great idea might try this with my 11 yo ds but for some it would work, like my 13 yo dd would just not eat at all if she didn't want to have one bite of the thing.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page