Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Films

Gutting disappointment disclosure day - SPOILERS

53 replies

Puddingypops · 11/06/2026 13:38

I sooooo wanted to love this film, I was excited all day to see it, John Williams?! Spielberg??? Alien epic?!?! YES YES

But as I filed out of the packed cinema with everyone else walking in stony unsure silence my first words were “well that wasn’t what I expected” and by that I expected it to be good

i actually found it bad

Emily blunt was exceptional I will say that, I enjoyed it when she started speaking other languages and had hope it would be deliciously mysterious happenings like that to come….

I also like the way the aliens, when we got to see them for the 2 minutes they were in the film, walked…and I liked their fingers

thats it for things I liked unless you count how much I enjoyed Josh O’Connors stealth mode in hiding behind a 2 foot slatted fence with gaping gaps in it 2 yards away from 50 military guys not trained to look around.

can we seriously not get a real fox to sit and walk? No? Let’s make one that looks ridiculous, same with the deer, and the bird, I was completely removed from the whole film every time cgi made an appearance.

car chase, car chase, car being dragged FAR TOO LONG by a high speed train, like that guy would miss shooting them from there too

no chemistry between the characters, I know what the film wanted me to feel, what messages it was going for, but if I don’t feel them then what’s the point

anyone else feel the same?

OP posts:
CraftandGlamour · 04/07/2026 09:13

PurpleFlowersShed · 29/06/2026 12:43

I like the theory that the aliens are softening us up with this, and will have a listen to the podcast recommended up-thread. Hope it is way better than Disappointment Day...

Come back and tell me what you think. Also highly recommend the documentary Age of Disclosure which is on Amazon (a rental) and is totally jaw-dropping

PurpleFlowersShed · 04/07/2026 09:27

CraftandGlamour · 04/07/2026 09:13

Come back and tell me what you think. Also highly recommend the documentary Age of Disclosure which is on Amazon (a rental) and is totally jaw-dropping

Thanks! Will have a watch

HoldingOntoMySanity · Yesterday 18:58

EmotionalSupportWren · 11/06/2026 17:52

I thought it was terrible. A real let down. The story, sense of place, plot, and pacing were all off.

I don't understand why the CGI animals were so cack. Or why the nun was wearing so much make-up. Or even why the construction in the warehouse was necessary. Tagging on a verbal reason as an after thought didn't make it believable.

Honestly, I've lost count of the number of times I've watched Close Encounters of the Third Kind, so this truly was gutting. I can't quite believe the same director was involved.

As for Colin Firth... I don't have words.

TBH it all smacked of the emperor's new clothes. Someone who cares about Spielberg should have stepped in and said, "Mate, this ain't it."

Saw it today. I agree with all of this. Incoherent, incomprehensible. Boring with a slight overlay of earnestness.

Disappointing.

Never thought of Josh O'Conner as eye candy before though, so there was that.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page