hmm. I really liked Donnie Darko, American Beauty, Oh brother where art though and big fish. Maybe I'm odd.
I hated:
Matrix
eyes wide shut
mulholland drive (normally i like a bit of oddness. this film took it too far).
killing zoe - you are so right, wilbur
starship troopers - v boring and lots of deeply dodgy nazi symbolism, but no exploration of same.
the idiots - supposedly an "arthouse" film. extremely offensive and quite dull.
and why isn't pearl harbour on the list? Or has no-one seen it? (I haven't).
Haven't seen all of the other films mentioned