I am kinda in the same boat as you with regards to Mirtazapine. I've been taking 15mg at night for about a year now. It worked great at first, slept well, ate (too) well, and did alleviate most of my anxiety. Recently tho my anxiety has crept back. As always, the GP's first suggestion was to up the dose to 30mg. Like you I was terrified of upping the dosage due to all the reports of it being less sedating at higher doses and possibly making anxiety worse. My biggest fear was not being able to sleep as I have tinnitus.
I couldn't get the GP to give me an intermediate dose of 22.5mg so I ended up just splitting the 30mg tablet into 22.5mg with a tablet splitter (after lots of googling to make sure it's safe).
So, I took 22.5 mg last night(4/11/25) for the first time and here is my experience.
Fell asleep no problem (maybe even faster than 15mg, possibly from the pill being cut??). I did wake up twice in the night to pee which is unusual for me but did fall straight back to sleep no problem.
Woke up, slightly early , did feel a bit odd/jittery with slightly nervy tummy (probably anxiety), had a drink of water and lay back down, then....I had a really nice calming feeling that lasted for 2 hours.
It's now 3pm and my anxiety levels are pretty much the same as yesterday when on 15mg (obviously its too early to tell much) But.. I'm not feeling any worse, maybe slightly sleepier than usual but not bad. I will be definitely taking 22.5 mg again tonight and hope things start to improve over the next weeks.
I'm a very anxious person generally so it can be difficult for sometimes to differentiate between a genuine side effect and the symptoms that anxiety can make you feel at times (especially with the horror stories you see online).
It's entirely possible that you will experience no negative effects at all with the increased dosage and feel only positive ones, everyone is different.
BTW its taken me 6 weeks to try and work up the courage to try the increased dosage. So don't beat yourself up too much about stressing about it.
Good Luck.