Please or to access all these features

Mental health

Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you have medical concerns, please seek medical attention.

Worried about my friend - is her husband abusive?

3 replies

claremcfuddle · 17/09/2012 20:26

I have a friend who I know reasonably well through work (Kate). She has a history of depression and eating disorder. She is occasionally off work with what she calls 'inability to cope' and will lose tons of weight at these times. She is currently taking antidepressants but functioning ok at work.

Kate is 33 and has a husband and two kids.

Kate's husband is superficially charming but there's something about him I find insincere. He certainly doesn't like her going out without him and she has often admitted that 'it's not worth the hassle' of planning an evening out (dinner as a group of friends) because he sulks for ages afterwards. He doesn't mention his own friends and neither does she so I don't know that he has any. He complains afterwards if she comes in tipsy from half a bottle of wine. When they are in company, he doesn't take his eyes off her - which makes it hard to have a conversation.

Her husband gets them into a lot of debt (I mean, a LOT) and because of this they've had their home repossessed despite both having good jobs. His spendin is still out of control (they were renting but could no longer afford the rent) and they are now lodging with his cousin indefinitely. They are not paying any keep, so spend their money on expensive things that they 'want' but couldn't afford if they had their own home (like recent trip to New York).

Just recently she has been really 'down' and told him she wanted to end the marriage. I've never seen her so low and though I was pleased she's stood up and said what she thought, I did worry where she and the kids would go.

Since then he's been 'making an effort' which has involved buying her very expensive clothes/bags and taking her away on expensive weekends leaving the kids with his cousin. She now says he's 'making an effort' and 'he does really love me, after all.' I think he's realised she's on the brink and he's throwing money at her. He has also suggested they move abroad.

As a bystander, there's little I can do but I wonder if my assessment of the situation is way off the mark? I think he's very controlling. I worry for her and the kids and I find the friendship very frustrating as she is very inconsistent and much seems to depend on whether he 'approves' of our plans.

Does this sound like a familiar pattern? Anyone had a friend in this situation?

OP posts:
squishee · 17/09/2012 20:43

Looks like you've answered your own question, claremcfuddle.

Your friend's DH sounds a lot like my manipulative, shapeshifting ex - which is why he's now my ex.

But, as I found, your friend will need to be ready to reach the decision herself and for her own reasons, no matter what people around her are saying. She'll get there. As my best friend told me I would.
Keep being there for Kate, she will need your support when this happens.

claremcfuddle · 17/09/2012 20:52

Shapeshifting - yes that really describes him.

He is always making HUGE changes to their life.

For example, they resigned from their jobs, sold all their possessions and went to live in New Zealand but only lasted a few weeks because he had the wrong visa and couldn't work.

They got a dog and changed their mind a year later so it had to go to a dogs home.

He makes decisions that have not been reasoned out. Last year he applied for a job in Thailand and flew over three times for interview and then changed his mind at the last minute. They have repeatedly moved house/changed their children's schools.

It is very hard to believe anything he says. She is a perfectly intelligent girl and I have no idea why she stays I suppose. Do you think people DO ever leave? She must be under such strain at times but at the moment she's 'up' because he took her to NYC.

What's his game? I think he knows I don't like him and this doesn't help matters for her.

OP posts:
squishee · 18/09/2012 22:24

Haha, that sounds familiar! My ex hated my best friend. Who had him and his manipulative manoeuvres sussed way before I did, because she was not under his spell like I was. He kept talking about us moving abroad together and that kind of thing. And then I discovered what a financial mess he was in.

These manipulative people get a kick out of imposing things that are wildly inconsiderate. Making you feel good when they feel like it and wretched when they feel like it. The power makes their damaged egos feel better. Sad really. Twisted, for sure.

This "gentleman" sounds like a tosser. Easy to say, but far less easy to deal with.

Sometimes it is very difficult to break free of someone like this, even though there's nothing rational about it. It can feel like you're looking to hack your own arm off.

Can I suggest that you check out my story, which might be similar to your friend's? Just to get some insight:

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/relationships/1546506-Trying-to-bounce-back-after-addiction-to-manipulative-ex-anyone-been-there

New posts on this thread. Refresh page