Please or to access all these features

Fasting / 5:2 diet

Talk about intermittent fasting and 5:2, including what’s worked for others. Mumsnet hasn't checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. You may wish to speak to a medical professional before starting any diet.

One 24 hour fast a week has helped where 5:2 did not

132 replies

Lemonthyme · 08/04/2026 11:16

I have a good diet, being sober and exercising a lot, perimenopause was starting to cause weight gain. With some levels of change to my diet to cut out the crap, this changed to stability (which would and did cause loss when I was younger). There was one thing though that pushed me into trying something different and that was my HbA1c result which was 5.8%. So despite doing EVERYTHING the NHS tells you to do to be a healthy weight, I was still overweight and very close to prediabetic (other countries would already class this as prediabetic).

I've not had another HbA1c result back since I started once a week 24 hour fasting on top of everything else I've done but what is changing is I'm losing weight. Total weight loss is c. 1-1.5 lbs a week so not huge but consistent and enough that it's really starting to be noticeable.

I have been so fed up since perimenopause hit with things not working. I'm really pleased something is and it kind of makes sense that if there's good evidence that intermittent fasting works to improve insulin resistance, if IR was my problem, that would have been making it harder to lose weight so it is a complete lightbulb moment for me that it's probably been that.

As for "how" as that's what I would have been wanting to know. I "read" an audiobook on the science behind the hormones of weight loss and it advocated one 24 hour fast a week (or possibly two) for insulin resistance and metabolic flexibility as your body has to switch to burning fat. Two sounded terrifying but one sounded possible. They then went onto explain that all you do is finish eating dinner on, say Monday at 6pm then miss breakfast and lunch the next day, eating dinner on Tuesday at c. 6pm or later. Well that sounded less frightening even though that is 24 hours, it's actually only missing 2 meals. I'd originally thought about doing it just once a fortnight but when I tried it, realised that it was easy enough (it only gets a little harder from 4pm onwards) and if anything I now almost look forward to my fasting days. What's more is if I'm busy with work, it's actually easier.

I'd previously tried 5/2 though and didn't lose an ounce. So I wanted to share this with people in case you've tried one form of "IF" type approaches and assumed they all didn't work for you (although I'm not really sure if 5/2 is really IF).

Top tips I have is to have herbal or spice (not fruit) teas so they're calorie free, black coffee and plenty of sparkling water. I don't personally have any sweeteners anyway but I think most people avoid them when fasting. Also if you find you're struggling and exercise a lot like I do, sodium can be depleted by fasting so another tip is to have some electrolytes or even a pinch of salt (e.g. in coffee) if you're struggling.

I genuinely cannot imagine stopping doing this now unless I'm advised to medically. It's far easier than any other method I've used to try and lose weight. I'm a total convert.

OP posts:
AFPotts · 10/08/2026 11:59

I totally agree @BIWI that's 100% true. But I get lured in due to emotional eating and because I'm trying to feed up 2 skinny teenage boys.

Will there be another bootcamp soon? :)

MagicThanks · 10/08/2026 12:20

I’m going to give this a go, thanks OP

BIWI · 10/08/2026 16:41

AFPotts · 10/08/2026 11:59

I totally agree @BIWI that's 100% true. But I get lured in due to emotional eating and because I'm trying to feed up 2 skinny teenage boys.

Will there be another bootcamp soon? :)

I'm thinking of doing another one, starting on 5 October, if that would suit you? Will last for 8 weeks, until 30 November.

AFPotts · 10/08/2026 19:28

@BIWI Yes that would be perfect. Thanks for all the effort you've put in over the years.

alteredimage · 08/10/2026 07:59

This might be interesting.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/jan/29/fasting-for-36-hours-the-experts-view-on-rishi-sunak-weekly-habit

From memory his wife encouraged him, initially for religious reasons.

I have found an initial 24 hour fast is a good way of resetting before a diet, along with a general cleaning up of what I eat. I did well over the summer, simply by cutting out snacks and sugar. However the colder weather has brought food cravings back. I have lots in my diary so a determined sleight programme might be too complicated. Once a week would work better and help prevent me from getting back into a sugar and pudding habit.

Fasting for 36 hours: the experts’ view on Rishi Sunak’s weekly habit

PM consumes only water, tea or black coffee from 5pm on a Sunday to 5am on a Tuesday, which can have benefits for ageing and DNA repair

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/jan/29/fasting-for-36-hours-the-experts-view-on-rishi-sunak-weekly-habit

SuperMoonIsKeepingMeUpToo · 08/10/2026 08:28

Lemonthyme · 09/04/2026 07:48

People really seem hung up on this on MN that it's "just another way to restrict calories". Of course you do reduce your calorie intake but it's only missing two meals a week. You do tend to eat a little more in the evening on a fasting day and while I don't binge, I don't get overly restrictive with that.

The reason I took this up as an idea was that there is pretty good evidence it supports reversing insulin resistance which makes losing weight harder and it forces your body into ketosis once a week which can support metabolic flexibility. Then there's the increase in HGH and autophagy that happens towards the end of the fast. So research would suggest it's not just about calorie reduction.

There is a recent paper which compares intermittent fasting with more traditional caloric restriction but it's pretty flawed. It lumps all kinds of IF (including 5/2 which I'd argue isn't fasting) into the test state and treats all other calorie restriction as the control. The different forms of IF have quite different impacts on your hormones, at least from what I've read in the research.

Why do you think 5:2 isn't fasting? And do you consider what you do fasting?

alteredimage · 09/10/2026 11:02

For me the advantage of "fasting" or 5:2 is not calorie restriction but the having a break between eating. It seems to help reduce craving and, bizarrely, increases my energy levels and improves my sleep.

Much of my snacking habit was down to boredom or sugar crashes/craving so a bit of discipline helps.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page