I saw some American woman on daily politics earlier this week point out that nations who are weak refer to 'special relationships', whilst those who are strong don't because they don't need them.
On that note this thread from yesterday is doing the rounds.
Ben Kelly @thescepticisle
Baffled by the childish fantasies of atlanticist Brexiteers who believe in the "special relationship" and that the US will treat us favourably and with some kind of sentimentality. It's based on Hannan fantasies and misreadings of history. US trade negotiators will turn us over.
There is an element of a "special relationship" in cultural crossover (though this is very one sided), intelligence sharing & miltiary cooperation though this is diminishing along with our capabilities) but from a political perspective there is no "special relationship"...
...From a trade and economic perspective, the US will seek to get everything they want from us and give away as little as possible. They will be ruthless. Why on Earth anyone would possibly think they'd be exra nice to us and ensure it was totally mutually beneficial is beyond me
None of this is a criticism of the USA. Not at all. Nor am I saying they are not a hugely important ally. I just think we need to drop this desperate "special relationship" idea and be realistic.
It goes hand in hand with the sentimentlaity over fighting "shoulder to shoulder" during WWII. Okay, but lets not forget that the US extracted a heavy price from a desperate UK, extortionate loans, demands that we cede territory to them, massive transfers of our gold bullion...
... The US used our foreign policy blunders and WWII to push the dismantlement of the British empire and confirm the tranfer of power to them, something they aggressively pursued since WWI. Early in 20th century war between UK & USA wasn't out of the question.
We are allies now, important allies, though again we need them far more than they need us. But we are not like old pals and family. Stop this doughey eyed silliness.
Bizzarely, Atlanticist Brexiteers have their perception warped so much by their weird sentimentality that they buy into Donald Trump, a man trampling over much of what they love about the US & damaging the very basis of their "global Britain" vision
Just to reiterate, I do, on balance, think America is awesome and am soaked in its culture. There is nothing anti-America in this. They've got it right in being unsentimental.