Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Elderly parents

Contribution to DF, 80, housing? Can't think straight, help me with family Comms please

48 replies

Alwaysfixingsh1t · 19/01/2026 17:26

Hello elderly parents board. Thanks for all the informative and supportive of carers threads. I have used it a fair amount to make sure I am not losing my mind over the last few yrs. This is my first post, it's a bit rambly, I am not the best writer I think, I want to get the info across though.

NC'd for this in case family pick it up. I would like some advice on how to approach the following with my family. I am mid-40's, 3 DC, work full-time in a really busy role, DH also works FT and travels away every 3 weeks to London.

My DF, 80, is on the full state pension, no other private pension or other revenue stream. He has limited savings but his main home is mortgage free. We are not UK based so tax rules mean he must keep the home to ensure there is asset to pay for care if needed. He lived in very rural area all his life. My DM, DF wife, passed away in 2023 of bowel cancer, she had been ill for 1.5 yrs prior. It was a tough few years for all of us, lots of support from one side of country to another, lots of driving, supporting at hospital and home while DM went through treatment. DF was wobbly during and after after my DM illness and when she passed away. He seemed and sometimes still does - totally lost. It became clear that he wasn't coping well living on his own, mostly due to social isolation and I think depression. I sat him down (many times tbh) and finally got to place where he made it clear he wanted to be close to his children. Myself and 2 older DBs, we all live in the same city.

My DH and I, separate from my DF situation, saved all we could and using our savings decided to purchase an apartment in Feb 2025 as family investment, it is close to our main home. We indicated to my DF that he could trial living there, being close to us and my DBs, we understood that this could be long term.

DF accepted and transitioned, on and off, over and back to rural home with support from all his children, since April 2025, but then stayed full time since October 2025 to now. Winters in his house are freezing (poor heating system and he's tight with cranking the heat in winter). He doesn't mind the cold but doesn't really engage his social network and will only call DC when in need of assistance, a 3.5 hour drive away. DF has transitioned ok-ish to the city, it was a massive change for him. He drives, has a GP, a physio (my insistence that he has this), a cleaner (again, I insisted). Physically he is okay-ish. Lots of aches and pains from various surgeries over the last 7 yrs, some incontinence. He has no hobbies and it's totally impossible to get him to take up anything - we have tried so often, flat refusal. Mentally he can be very down, I am sure he has at least mild depression - he ruminates a lot. He is very able to wash and feed himself, no personal care needed at this stage. He visits or has visits from myself and geo-closest DB 4-5 times a week. It tends to be me more often than not. It can be a lot, I am trying my best with boundaries and managing my own physical/mental health. Not sure why I share all this - I am offloading while I am in the flow!

My DH and I pay for the mortgage on the apartment, the upkeep, the management fees (2k annually). My father pays no rent,
but does pay the utility bills. My brothers do not contribute, I have never asked them to. My husband has indicated that he would like my brothers and my DF to nominally contribute to the management fees. DB1, he and DSIL work FT in good careers, 3 young children, they have an apartment which "pays its own way", they make a small income from this. DB2, he is the only earner in his family, skilled occupation, v senior, 2 DC one of which is in university, one in A-level equiv yr. I should say I get on really well with my DBs and DSILs; they are important to me and feel I can rely on them for all of the DF stuff. There is no resentment, and between us 3 the Comms can be quite reasonable.

This item though, the contribution, is not something I have discussed with DBs - as this was all a "trial" but it has become normal now. We are not looking for contribution to the mortgage, but would it be acceptable to split the cost of the management fees as a proposal? I sometimes feel stuck in the middle with my family (opaque communications is the culture of the family, since forever, with DF/DM and then like Chinese whispers to my DBs, bad planning on my Dad's and Mum's part - which honestly I am often frustrated by, so bloody frustrated) and my DH who is none of those things and is always thinking 5 steps ahead about our financial future. If anyone has any ideas on how to approach this and if it a reasonable ask I would be all ears.

Thanks for reading - sorry such a long post.

OP posts:
Thelondonone · 19/01/2026 17:30

Why isn’t your father selling his home and paying market rent to you? He needs that money now-not for possible care in the future. I would sell the house, he should covering your costs but possibly not profit.

Thelondonone · 19/01/2026 17:31

It has nothing to do with your brothers and I wouldn’t contribute if I was them.

Octavia64 · 19/01/2026 17:35

If you were in the U.K. the sensible thing to do would be either to sell your fathers house or rent it out.

you say for tax reasons it needs to be kept.

I’ll be honest, if my sibling had moved my parent into a flat they own (was there any family discussion about this at all?) and then started asking for contributions I’d be worried about this being the thin end of the wedge and them asking for more and more money each year.

it’s not normal in the U.K. for children to pay for parents rent/bills/management fees - parents pay for themselves and if care is needed it’s from their own assets or state funded

Dolamroth · 19/01/2026 17:35

If you wanted a contribution that should have been made clear at the beginning, asking now is changing the goalposts.

Like a pp I also don't understand why your father can't sell his house and have an income from the funds or rent his house out. Then pay you rent.

squeaver · 19/01/2026 17:35

Not sure what country you are in but it seems odd that he has to keep the home to pay for care in the future.

Why can't he sell the house and use the proceeds to pay something towards where he is now (i.e. the management fees) and then use what ever is left to pay care home fees in the future?

Is there some kind of tax break involved in only selling the house when a care home becomes necessary? Seems a bit cumbersome - what if you can't sell the house then?

Sorry if this is a diversion but that would seem to be the best soloution

Mirrorx · 19/01/2026 17:36

I think your father should be paying.

I don't understand the tax thing. How can the state prevent him selling in the off chance he needs care? Is it that they'll tax the proceeds to pay for future care? He should still sell imo.

beAsensible1 · 19/01/2026 17:39

Ditto everyone up thread. Sell the house use it pay fees and nominal rent.

siblings don’t really need to contribute. There is money in the house. He isn’t destitute.

Newgirls · 19/01/2026 17:41

Time to sell his house. It could take a few months but he needs the money now. I don’t see why the siblings need to pay when he has assets.

BitsyBop · 19/01/2026 17:45

agree with the “why can’t he sell the home?”
how can they stop you from selling your home and moving?

DwarfPalmetto · 19/01/2026 17:47

Not selling the house doesn't make sense to me. What if he never needs residential care? Most people don't.

WallaceinAnderland · 19/01/2026 17:50

If he is selling the house to free up funds to pay for alternative accommodation for himself that is not deprivation of assets.

Candleabra · 19/01/2026 17:52

But he needs care now, doesn’t he, if he needs to be close to you and have you visiting constantly?
I too don’t understand why this isn’t the trigger of “care needs” that necessitates selling his house.

ProfessorBinturong · 19/01/2026 18:02

It is reasonable for your father to pay the costs of his accommodation. It's not reasonable to ask your siblings to pay.

Alwaysfixingsh1t · 19/01/2026 18:35

Thanks for all the responses, was expecting zero so this is very helpful. Agree that asking siblings for contributions isn't really the right approach, thanks for the very clear steer. I need to talk to DF seriously about finances, and avoid glazing over the topic. This is not the norm here btw, I'm in Ireland, will explain issue with house later as just getting the DC fed.

OP posts:
Cup0flife · 19/01/2026 20:57

Your Father should apply for attendance allowance, it is not means tested. He can pay towards transport to & from both properties or spend on anything he wants to.

Please do this for him asap

Alwaysfixingsh1t · 19/01/2026 21:13

Thanks again for the responses, so clear, reality check too.

Again, this isn't a typical situation, maybe a huge mess, I don't know. I suppose this is is care needs kicking off isn't it @Candleabra, as soon as he left his home his care needs started, but informally with me and DH and DBs support. I always thought of care needs as being in a care home, which is bloody expensive here as it is in UK.

In Ireland there is a “fair deal scheme” which means his house can be used to pay towards care home fees, that is the tax element, I suppose it’s a scheme really, but run by the dept of revenue. The contribution is capped at 7.5% of asset value (ish - there are some savings exemptions) per year for 3 years, max, no more. If he needed more than 3 yrs care, the state would pay all of it and he would stay in place.

If he sells the house then the liquid assets are indefinitely used towards care at 7.5% per year until all gone, then state steps in to pay.

State will pay for care if needed (no assets) however the general view is that the state paying means the choice is zero, you get what you get. That wouldn't be the case here.

@DwarfPalmetto I appreciate that he may never need care, your comment really struck home as I never see that angle, I always presumed he would need it. Honestly after DM passed, I thought he would be a goner shortly after as he was in such poor shape but he has rallied and is doing much better physically.

@WallaceinAnderland I also appreciate that paying rent wouldn’t be considered deprivation of assets, thanks for the fresh view. DH and I would have to pay a chunk of taxes on rent from my DF if he were to pay it but we know that. In Ireland there is a review of assets, deprivation of assets is managed via a 5 year “lookback”, it’s essentially the same rule as UK I think, if any money is gifted to children etc it is assumed he still has that money and is treated as such.

I don’t care about the inheritance tbh, I am not super nostalgic about the house, I see a house that needs attention and upkeep which I don't have capcity for - I care more about the person who is still alive than the house, my DH and I want to make sure that my cash poor DH has access to care if needed which we absolutely cannot afford. Typical fees in are 1.8-2.4k per week. Fair deal scheme is widely used (and tbh a pain in the face, but we have to work the system we are in).

We found a super independent living place not far from us, which was too social for him, so he declined. He is a bit of a hermit but happy to be with family.

I am not sure what to do about DF house - I will think about it again and ask DF, but I am clear about asking him to contribute to fees and running of the apartment now. Thanks all.

OP posts:
Alwaysfixingsh1t · 19/01/2026 21:14

@Cup0flife we are not in UK, but thank you! That doesn't exist here. Not sure I can see him on a 4.5 hr bus journey to rural ireland to visit his house, it's only practical in a car considering remoteness.

OP posts:
Cup0flife · 19/01/2026 21:26

Another option is to rent your DFathers property out to a friend of the family.
Use the rent to pay where he is living now.

He may need to pay tax on the rent income/self assessment

Alwaysfixingsh1t · 19/01/2026 21:53

@Cup0flife Definitely something my DBs are keen on, the house would need a lot of work to get up to scratch though and I think they are full of talk, no action. I don't have the energy to kick that project off or the money to invest to make it tenant ready. Rent in that area is quite low too. I wish it was an easier solution, I'd love to have it lived in.

OP posts:
Candleabra · 20/01/2026 08:31

I hope you can find a solution. I think the problem with caring is it happens gradually so you’re not aware of how much you’re doing until it becomes overwhelming.
I found it helpful to take a step back and write everything down, everything you have to help with or manage. I bet it’s a lot.

TheatreTheatre · 20/01/2026 09:09

I would have a family meeting with your DB’s about long term strategy for your Dad.

Lay out that it could be 10 years or more living in your apartment , at a total cost to you and DH of €XXXXX.

Explain the 7.5% position and how this could be used for care costs… and that maintaining his house can potentially result in a greater eventual inheritance

Explain the impact of selling the house and the greater impact on liquid funds towards care.

Discuss whether the family are prepared to share current costs and explain that if not you will be needing your Df to sell his house.

Overall, fewer people go into care than stay at home, and most care residents are there for less than 2 years.

You need to discuss this properly with your siblings.

And you owe it to your DH to do so.

Part of supporting older parents is having honest but hard conversations with families. Got the T shirt. But clarity, shared understanding and team work really pay off.

Alwaysfixingsh1t · 20/01/2026 14:14

@TheatreTheatre thanks, I appreciate your response. I do owe it to my DH. He is a good and generous soul, I don't want him to be taken advantage of. It's not fair that a house sits empty on the other side of the country indefinitely for nostalgic reasons . Your comment that hard and honest conversations help support older parents rings so true, thanks for the reality slap!

I am often the instigator of the "hard chats" in the family. I won't engage in is the nostalgic chats about going to the family home for a week in summer, or a weekend at Easter etc and "do a bit of DIY". No. I have 3 young children, that is what handymen/women are for!

OP posts:
SilverSurreal · 20/01/2026 14:18

Why cant he sell the house and buy an apartment? I dont understand why its so complicated?