Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

Could remote schooling become a choice?

54 replies

Raindropsonrosesand · 17/05/2020 09:15

Coronavirus has forced us to try new things which were previously dismissed as impossible. I'm certainly hoping to wfh more, even when this is all over.

I wonder whether the government should be looking at making remote schooling - properly planned, supported, and resourced - a long-term option.

Effective remote schooling is possible: my DD's (private) school has been amazing at providing a really good remote learning experience. They have a full timetable using Teams on their school ipads, with taught real-time lessons and teachers available for support. They also have form time for discussion at the start and end of the day, which keeps the kids connected to the school and each other, and includes daily activities to help them process what's going on.

Don't get me wrong, it's a hard thing to do well. The teachers are very obviously working incredibly hard, and it's more difficult for them to gauge how kids are doing and help them than in person. A lot of important parts of the school experience are missing. It does still need significant support from parents for the kids to benefit fully (although I think this would lessen with time, as everyone figures it out). And it certainly isn't for all kids: they need to be reasonably self-motivated, able to focus and keen to work.

In most cases, physical school will be a far better choice for children. I can't wait for DD to be able to go back safely!

But for a minority of kids - eg living in remote locations, army parents moving around lots, schools within reach haven't worked for the child, health issues that put them at risk in a school environment - it could be the best option. I'd probably choose it over boarding school for DD, if I had to make that choice. I expect that many of the parents who choose home-schooling would find this a good alternative. And many kids who just don't thrive at school might find this a better option.

The neat thing about it is that the children who would benefit from it can be geographically dispersed, which makes it much more achievable than other specialist educational provision. Even a tiny proportion of children adds up to a significant number across the whole country.

And without the cost of running an expensive physical school, there would be more money available for the technology, other physical support (books and resources sent to each child) and smaller class sizes necessary for it to work.

It would work well for teachers too. You could recruit them anywhere, so hugely opening the pool of possible applicants. In the short term, this would be great for teachers who have health conditions which make coronavirus exposure dangerous.

And finally, it would be really easy to assess the provision (which would be important). Unlike normal ofsted assessments which are done in one not-very-representative day, all lessons and interactions can be recorded and assessed.

Like I said, it's not easy. It would require some pretty serious thought and work to set it up in a way that works well. And it would only be the right choice for a small proportion of children, perhaps only for a limited amount of time. But I think creating that option could really enrich our state educational provision, solving significant problems for some children.

What do you think?

OP posts:
lovingtea · 12/06/2020 19:29

I dont think it can be a choice thats state funded , although a few LAs will fund it for with SEN. But what they get funded is only a bargain basement version (its a sideline of interhigh) of online school only doing maths, english and science. I would say as its parent funded the online schools are more under pressure to deliver as a business or we as parents would walk away! That helps keep teaching/ education quality up. ds does yr 8 6 subjects= £232 a month. We re very lucky that we can afford it, though. DS has actual lesson time 9 hrs. So for those saying about kids sat in front of a screen for hours, thats not how it is. Take away registration, assembly etc etc actual lesson time isnt that much. PE is our own devices as is food tech. We dont have RE or anything as online isnt under government control, although interhigh etc do follow the curriculum and if they had to be OFSTED they wouldn`t be fussed!

its an alternative and an extra choice. I have seen classes get bigger since easter as some students have come to online school while mainstream is off the table.

CraftyGin · 13/06/2020 15:49

In our school, we are in the process of installing the kit (webcam and microphone). There will be a learning curve in how to work it optimally, and we won't be able to start that until September.

As far as data protection goes - we are all within our school G-suite. No one outside of the Google Classroom can access the Google Meet lesson. We won't be recording lessons (we only record 1-2-1s). Students who cannot be photographed etc, can sit behind the camera, and they will be aware of live camera positions should they move around the class.

Paranoia the destroyer.

NeverTwerkNaked · 13/06/2020 16:03

excellent @craftygin Smile

LokisLover · 15/06/2020 12:16

@lovingtea I’m really interested in your homeschooling experience and it sounds really positive. My ds has not been in school since Dec 2019 due to severe anxiety but has engaged really well with homeschooling since lockdown and has caught up.
If he finds it hard to reintegrate in to school again I think I will seriously consider what you are doing until he feels he is able to cope again. My perception of homeschooling has really changed.

Is online learning quite straightforward to engage with? I have coped with homeschooling so much better than I thought I would but of course I am not a teacher so there are massive gaps in my knowledge. Feeling more positive about the future than I was before having read your posts.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread