I think I've had an ephiniy.
Was up last night with a feverish child (who is off school-yipee!) and realised the Status quo in the school looks just like the tax system.
The gov raised taxes to the point of being burden as their first solution to every issue. So the people looked for ways to cut down on paying tax by going under the table for the small stuff. In response the gov created new taxes and higher taxes. So the people got more creative at avioding tax, and paid less than they has originally. So the gov created a flotilla of new taxes, higher taxes, backdoor taxes, sneaky taxes. And the people became the world leaders in tax aviodance.
There are two economies here, one offical, one black, I suspect the latter is thw greater of the two.
Ten to one that is what is happening at school. The new NC curriculum raised the bar, as did the new state exams. The first choice to combat objective, standardised prog. and tests was to increae the volme of work made the learners sole responibility. So kids found ways round it. And so on and so on until you get me, who is adverse to aversion techniques trying to get it all done, while everybody else just carries on as per normal.
I've found references to 30% of kids failing the year at scuola media, not sure if that is every year, or they must pass them through each year, and then fail them at the end of the three year cycle.
Also found a letter to the min of ed from an infuriated mother of one of 11 kids failed in first year middle school in one school. If that is as big as my sons school that would be about 10% of the cohort (and does ot include the statmented kids who have specialized exams).
I know in my son's class there is a 14 year old who has never got past first year and in the class he goes to sit in for when his class has the religion hour there is a 13 yo, two 14 yos and a 15 yo.
My son best friend does not do homework, I've had to lay down the law in their "study group" becuase I discovered that the homework claimed to have been done was more a case of guess the answer or read one paragraph and assume that isthe same as reading all 5 pages required.DS does some homework post great big threatening session, while his (honestly, lovely, bright, great family) friend pretends to write something, but is actually laying out his next Pokemon stratagies.
I can't work out if his other friends are some sort of wunderkind, who can dash off a myth in five minutes, ten pages of set theory in 7, memorise 11 pages of history in 3, do a huge technical drawing thing in 4, copy reams of musical score in 6 and write a ruddy huge list ofmcountires in differnt time zone in 5. OR they aren't dping the homeowrk and patents are xhosing to assume they only got about half an hours wotht that could be fitted in just before bed.
Cos they are all out and about in youth club, going to their sports clubs, shopping sat morning, mass sunday morning, youth club again sat and sun afternoons, passesgiata in the piazza both weekend evenings.....
I have wo dered if my son is basically thick, and In my mummy love I just didn't want to see it, or I did amlousy job for two years HE.
But his ex school tested him, his ex teachers wrote the test, examined him, marked it and I have two certificates declaring him to be "equivilant", and less formal letters fro the teachers using words like excellent, lode and very good.
Oh well, if you can't beat 'em, jion 'em. But only fpr this year, I don't want his edication to be centered around aversion and aviodence techniques.
He is an average student, he is not cream, he will not fulfill his potential If I rely on him just rising naturally above the roadblocks his education has turned into.
DH was cream, he is really bright, and rose above the school system no problem, but I'm just average and unfortunaly the intelligence gene DS got from me.
Those are the children Italy fails, the average and below average students who leave school well below their potential becuase they were allowed to spiral into a decade long state of falling behind, cos the pitch and volume was far too high and far too much, far too soon.
IMO.