Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Divorce/separation

Here you'll find divorce help and support from other Mners. For legal advice, you may find Advice Now guides useful.

Positive experiences of staying in same house when separated

43 replies

Annilk · 07/05/2019 15:59

Hoping to hear from those who have chosen to stay in the same house after ending their relationship and separating as a couple.

Main reasons are so we can both continue to parent our DC with minimum disruption for them, and for financial reasons. Importantly, things are also amicable between us, and we both like the idea of being able to create a new kind of family set-up, no longer as a couple but both committed to the idea of co-parenting.

I've looked at other posts and found mostly tales of it not being a good idea ultimately, and people advising against it. Can anyone tell me that it worked for them?

OP posts:
CatyaPurella · 07/05/2019 20:46

Nope, not working for me sorry! How do you move on living in the same house? Unless both of you have zero intention of meeting someone else then I don’t see how it can work. We are technically amicable but it’s killing me slowly each day that goes by we are in the same house together.

I think it’s confusing for the DC’s, living like a family but doing things separately with Mum & Dad, especially if they know you are separated. That’s the point we are at but house is sold and counting down the days!!

PotteringAlong · 07/05/2019 20:48

What happens when one of you meets someone else?

Annilk · 07/05/2019 21:33

That's my question and concern, I guess, Catya, how can you move on? Superhuman effort am guessing...Am worried I am also starting to identify with it slowing killing me, too....

But surely it must work for some people?

Pottering, at the moment meeting anyone else couldn't be further from my mind...I'm at the craving my own space and never having to share it with another adult stage, I guess! But still desperately trying to think we could amicably make this work....

OP posts:
coco123456789 · 08/05/2019 10:00

We are doing this but it doesn’t work as I still love him. We sleep in the same bed and so I just live in a perpetual state of (false) hope that things will change which is very painful. He has been offered a job abroad and wants us to go - don’t know how he thinks we could move away living in this weird set up, away from family etc!

I think if you don’t love each other any more and get on very well then it could work as long as you have agreed boundaries. My parents had a very strange relationship, as did my grandparents who spent much of the year apart in their different houses. But somehow I was always grateful they were all still together.

Kazzz65 · 08/05/2019 10:04

I stayed in the house separated and filing for divorce but moved out once divorced. I guess if you can both draw up an agreement you can co-parent and still have your own lives. The trouble is if you both find other partners will they accept this arrangement?

stucknoue · 08/05/2019 16:28

Living in same house, works ok (admittedly a larger house which means he has separate bedroom and also and office/living room) however not sure if it's good for me longer term as I want him back really

coco123456789 · 08/05/2019 17:57

Stucknoue - do your kids know about the situation? What I find really hard is having to pretend things are normal in front of them

PotteringAlong · 08/05/2019 18:01

We sleep in the same bed

He has been offered a job abroad and wants us to go

Coca, it sounds to me very much like you’ve not split up at all...!

Finfintytint · 08/05/2019 18:06

My friend’s parents did this. They had a large manor house though and divided the house in two. I know they did this for many years but I don’t know what the end result was.

coco123456789 · 08/05/2019 18:07

We’re together for the kids he says. I have a very depressive tendency and he said he just cannot take the fact that I am impossible to make happy. Won’t let me hug him or anything, totally withdrawn. Only wants us to move abroad so that the kids are there too I think. He really wants to be with the kids, he would never leave them. He would never move out for that reason, they are his world.

Tawdrylocalbrouhaha · 08/05/2019 18:12

I know people who have done it successfully for a short while, and then less successfully as time went on. I don't think it is a viable long term plan, but for a year or so it could work, especially if your children are still very young.

Singlenotsingle · 08/05/2019 18:15

You won't be able to go out with other people though, and certainly not bring anyone home.

MumiF244 · 08/05/2019 18:43

I’m in this situation, but only because my soon to be ex husband refuses to move out. We are currently experiencing serious behavioural issues with our son who is feeling confused and insecure doing things with each of us separately and us sleeping in separate beds. I’m also feeling smothered and restricted as I can’t move on. If you can make it work huge respect to you, but my experience is a nightmare! X

MumiF244 · 08/05/2019 18:45

I would also add that for children you, as their parents, are their benchmark for a healthy relationship.

Fairylea · 08/05/2019 18:46

You’re deluding yourself, sorry. And I would bet one of you brings someone home or meets someone much sooner than you think you might.

coco123456789 · 08/05/2019 19:10

Our situation is very confusing as we share a bed, eat together, watch telly together, spend the weekends doing family stuff. Even go to theatre together and stuff. It would be much easier to draw a line and list of rules. I think it can work if you are both on the same page.

Singlenotsingle · 08/05/2019 19:23

You aren't separated then, are you coco? You should be leading separate lives, certainly if you're thinking of divorcing on a 2 year separation. That means sleeping separately, shopping and cooking separately, you don't do his washing, you don't go anywhere together.

BadJanet · 08/05/2019 19:25

We do this. We split after 18 years together (unmarried) and two DC (planned), but we couldn’t afford two homes in the area and were reluctant to move the dc away from their school and friends. But we were super amicable, so we bought a place locally with an extra bedroom and now we all live together happily. This was after quite a bit of post-breakup talking over what to do with a family therapist.

I now have a DP who lives 15 mins’ drive away, and is divorced with full custody of his two older dc. He and XDP get on well. XDP is single, currently not wanting to be in a relationship.

It’s working well for us and I’ve never regretted it, but I know it really wouldn’t work for most couples. XDP is honestly my best friend though, and current DP is literally the kindest, most perceptive and understanding human on the planet; so that helps.

I am strongly motivated to make this work because my own childhood was shaped by a horrible divorce and international custody battle over me which has made my relationships with both of my parents so, so hard. I was always 3,000 miles away from one or the other of them; it was so traumatic. I guess I’m doing the opposite.

Anyway. We’ve been like this for several years now. DC are perfectly cheerful about it.

We are in all other ways quite boringly conventional. That probably helps too, in that we’re broadly so “normal” that people seem to have pretty much accepted it.

(I’ve nc for this post btw! It’s a bit outing ...)

coco123456789 · 08/05/2019 19:53

I think we are separated, as we don’t have a loving relationship anymore. We don’t do things as a couple, no affection, no kisses on texts anymore. It’s just about the kids.

Annilk · 08/05/2019 21:26

Thanks for all your replies.
Sorry for those who are stuck in really difficult situations - I am feeling the strain of trying and am getting a feel for how hard it can be...
Makes me realise just how unique every single situation is - there's just no rule is there, for how it might work out because it depends on so many circumstances....
BadJanet, your situation sounds like what I was envisaging, it's great it works for you and sounds like you all manage it incredibly well and can all work together to make it work. My worry is that in my situation that wouldn't happen, cause of the people involved....But it's good to read and hope!
As regards the kids, surely as long as things are explained to them, kids will accept any sort of 'normal'? Ie two people can be separated but show the kids they still enjoy doing things as a family and that it's all very friendly? Surely as long as it works well with no tension the kids ultimately would prefer the togetherness no matter what the relationship looks like (will they be that bothered about the detail?!)?

OP posts:
DelphiniumBlue · 08/05/2019 21:39

I think it can work IF you are up front and honest about what us happening, and if you can carve yourself out some personal space.
I think Coco' s situation is untenable, for her but also for the children. Coco, why are you pretending that the separation isn't happening? That can only lead to confusion for the children at best; they'll know that things are not right between you, yet be told that everything's fine. They will learn not to trust their own instincts and feelings. If you are honest with them, they'll be able to cope, if you constantly lie to them, you are risking their mental health.
It doesn't seem as if it's doing you any favours either.

BadJanet · 08/05/2019 22:05

Yes, I think as long as you’re honest and authentic with your children in an age-appropriate way, they can adjust perfectly well to the idea that you are good friends now instead of a couple. It all hangs on whether what they see happening matches up to what they’re being told (I mean, it’s no good assuring them you’re friends if there is palpable tension between you). If it does match up, and everyone is kind and respectful and stuff, it can totally work.

Our kids know we used to be a couple, in love, boyfriend/girlfriend etc., for a long time - but that over time, our relationship changed. They had already been aware of other families (of school friends or classmates etc.) where the parents split up, so they had an understanding that this sometimes happens, and that often in those situations, one of the parents moves out.

We explained that, just like in those families, we have stopped being a couple, because sometimes that kind of relationship does not last forever - but that we are lucky enough to still like each other a lot and to feel happy about both sharing a home with them, so nobody was going to move out.

We have committed to sharing a home until they are grown up enough to want to move out into their own places, and at that stage we’ll see how things look and decide what to do next.

Sorry, this is all really obvious-sounding and probably not that useful. I don’t normally post about it on here under my usual name. Trying to think what else to say that might help...

I do really recommend talking to a therapist with experience in this area if you can afford to. It helped me so much. Even though our breakup was amicable, it still took a LOT of soul-searching to get to the point where we felt we were sure we could do this. Obviously you don’t want to tell the kids that you’re doing it, and then have it all break down and crumble after six months. And buying a bigger home together was a big deal.

That period of deciding what would happen - the period between us acknowledging to each other that our relationship had ended, and breaking the news to the children - that was really hard. We didn’t want to tell them we had split until we knew what was happening next, because we wanted to be able to answer their questions about who was living where and how their lives would be affected.

When we finally were ready to “come out” to them it was a huge, huge relief to be able to be honest.

We did then have about 18 more months of XDP sleeping on the sofabed though, before we could find a local house we could afford with 4 bedrooms. That really wasn’t great! But we felt like it would have been too confusing, muddling the message, if we’d shared a bedroom.

And after I met my current DP it also took lots of time to get to the stage of introducing him into the picture. It’s all been slow, slow, slow and careful.

BadJanet · 08/05/2019 22:12

God that was an epic post - sorry!

Annilk · 08/05/2019 22:17

BadJanet, thank you - it is all massively helpful (and don't worry, none of it is at all obvious when the situation feels so muddled!) :)
You're giving me hope, and seeing the different stages you've been through also helps in that, while it feels so hard and almost impossible now, that can pass if focused enough on the ultimate goals....

OP posts:
Annilk · 08/05/2019 22:17

Epic is just what I was hoping for!

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.