YES, I have a shoe recommendation! Toughees which are a brand from South Africa now available in the UK, from their own website www.tougheesshoes.co.uk and through amazon.
We have these ones Toughees Christine and I am absolutely blown away by them - dd has worn them since September, played football and climbed walls in them, and they honestly look as if they were bought a week ago. It's quite spooky, tbh. And they don't need polishing, you just wipe them wiht a damp cloth. They are the only school shoes I've ever encountered that would not need to be replaced until they were outgrown (and I have lots of experience, dd is the youngest of three).
I am really evangelical about them, I wish I'd discovered htem years ago. Clarks and Startrite are overpriced delicate little snowflake shoes in comparison.