[quote Sherrystrull]@Fripp
I honestly thought all ofsted inspectors had to be ex teachers![/quote]
I was observed by a lay inspector 20 years ago - I was an NQT on supply who gamely threw myself at a school knowing they were about to be inspected (back when there was a 2 week ish notice period from Ofsted)
I was 22 and super confident - probably had more confidence then than now!
He tried to mansplain my lesson to me, told me I shouldn't have allowed a (Y3 who was clearly desperate) child to go to the toilet mid lesson and I lost my shit. I got the lead inspector to sit in on the feedback and he agreed that the lay person should not have been commenting on lesson content.
To be honest I think inspections should be lead by current teaching staff on secondment. The classroom is a different place to what it was 2 / 3 years ago so anyone who hasn't taught in that time has little idea of the reality.