I think vulnerable people (myself included) need to look at the facts and make their own decisions about 'shielding'. It's a useful term if you need it to 'be allowed' to stay home from work etc & for getting help with shopping/medication or anything else
But as far as relying on the Govts 'Guidelines' 🤷🏻♀️
At 'best' they're 'balancing deaths & the economy' they don't have our individual lives In the forefront of their minds.
Shielding is optional for many reasons, but the main one is that they'd have to Do much more for people if they made it compulsory.
I'm not (yet) on the shielded list, but as a 51 yo, obese, diabetic with high blood pressure I'm doing everything I can to avoid getting it right now. In time I'm hoping at the very least they take people into hospital sooner and put them on oxygen/have better treatment plans - I had my appendix out a couple of years ago and whilst the op went well my HbA1c & blood pressure were both badly affected (not at all helped by the hospital food) by the treatment afterwards. I'm hopeful, but not holding my breath!, that they learn how to treat diabetics better for Covid so fewer die. I'm very sure it's a difficult balance with meds etc but hopefully they'll find a way
I'm currently furloughed, but I'm trying to think of a WFH businesss that will enable me not to go back to my job (contact with lots of people)
I can't see them adding diabetes to the shielding group even though it is very risky, simply because there are just too many diabetics in the UK. Mine is pretty well managed with diet & exercise (no meds) and if I hadn't had the awful experience with my appendix I wouldn't have been so worried about this, but I went downhill very badly and 'recovery' has been long & slow. And that was just the anti infection treatment for a small op.
DP is locked down separately, he has a different mindset to me though (though to be fair probably how I would have been had I not had the other experience) and I can see things getting a bit 'difficult' when I still won't let him come to mine (he has contact with a lot of other people due to his children & job) but as much as I miss him & love him, I'm not putting myself at risk to see him.
Sorry, lots of waffle to say I'll be making my own mind up when it's safe to do anything, not trusting the govt. (no risk of me 'breaking lockdown guidance' as I'm
more risk adverse than them!!)
& also I know there a psychological difference once put in the 'shielding' list & im not minimising that 🌷