Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

If you do the four gift rule…

57 replies

YouFilthyAnimal · 14/12/2022 12:31

How do you differentiate between the ‘want’ and the ‘need’?
Surely all children need a certain amount of toys for development and just for something to do so how do you decide which is a want and which is a need?

My 7 year old would tell you that he needs a new monster truck so he can race it against his other one, of course he doesn’t need It in a ‘would die without it’ sense but to him it’s a pretty big need - so need or want?
Is it whether the child seems it a need or the adult deems it a need?

If your child’s bike has broken, they play on it almost daily, so you’re getting a new one; want or need?
If they have used up all the felt tips and paper so you’re buying more; want or need?
All of one child’s friends are playing a certain game together on the Pc and he’s feeling left out and it’s affecting friendships, so you buy him the game - want or need?
The school moves all homework online to an app so you buy them an iPad, they can also play games on the iPad so want or need??

Also what if you have 2 DC and one needs a new bike but one only needs new socks, surely you don’t buy one child a ‘want’ plus a bike and one child a ‘want’ plus a pair of socks??

Also the ‘need’ one if you say you take it down to the very basics - shouldn’t you be providing your child with those anyway and not calling them gifts?
If my child happens to go up a shoe size in December I’m not going to buy them school shoes for Xmas, it’s my job to provide them with clothes that fit anyway, also what if then another child goes up a size in January - they get shoes just because but the other child had to count is as an Xmas present?

I just don’t know how you differentiate??

OP posts:
jetadore · 14/12/2022 17:40

Fucking hell.

Robishar · 14/12/2022 18:42

I think you're over thinking this lol
My 5 Yr old rides her scooter to the school bus stop everyday but the back wheel has dropped and become difficult, so she NEEDS a new scooter. We bought her a tablet for her birthday which she uses headphones for, but wireless ones would be more convenient so she WANTS (would like) wireless headphones.

Ultimately they're both wants really, but one is something that replaces something broken or upgrades something whereas the other isn't needed atall and she could still use her wired headphones no issue.

I've done the same for my 8 month old. His want is teletubbie teddies i know he likes playing with in baby class. His need is a toy that encourages him to chase and crawl. Obviously he doesn't actually NEED it, but its more for a developmental benefit so I've loosely classed it as a need.

Squiginawig · 14/12/2022 18:48

We did a different version when our kids were younger - we did:
Something you want
Something to wear
Something to read
Something to share

Did this largely because if they needed something we would just get it for them! The share present was often a board game which we would play after dinner.

daisychain01 · 14/12/2022 18:49

The Christmas roolz for Christmas presents

everything is a want - anything that's a need is normally boring and sensible
everything is fun
everything is indulgent, chocolate selection boxes, yard of Jaffa Cakes, 2 kilo chocolate bars Grin

there you go OP I've taken all the thinking out of it for you, just follow the roolz and your kids will have a fab Christmas

BiscuitLover3678 · 14/12/2022 18:54

I always thought news was something really useful like a new water bottle, cute plates or something more educational if they’re older.
Want is something you might not approve of like that pooping flamingo thing.

Daffodilsinbloom37 · 14/12/2022 20:00

BertieBotts · 14/12/2022 12:44

You're overthinking, but also, that's why it's a silly rule IMO.

Just set a budget for presents and pick within that.

Yep, this!

Thisisthelifewevebeengiven · 16/12/2022 19:39

I do this for my nephew!! This is his 3rd Christmas and I chose to use this poem so that I don't over do it for him because it's so easy to do!

This year he has:-
Want:- leapfrog gamer toy
Need:- tall colour changing bubble lamp for his bedroom
Wear:- dinosaur jumper and jeans
Read:- tales of acorn wood board book collection

It's easier as an aunt to differentiate between what would be a want and a need too I think.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page