If there's no FC, how is it magical?

[skinnysituation]

DC is still a bit young to completely understand and DH hates Christmas, so not much help.

If you don't do 'Father Christmas' how do you still make it special and a bit magical? Are there any traditions I could adopt for future years that would still deliver that excitement?

Feeling a little sad DC won't have that joyous anticipation of Father Christmas delivering/filling a stocking that I experienced.

Christmas is completely non religious in our family. It’s magic because we stay in, just us, all day, no screens allowed for the day, and we play games, jigsaws, crackers, we try to have a visitor every year to join us for the main meal - that has become an incidental tradition as we have a couple of friends who don’t go to their families for Christmas. The whole day is made up of traditions that only happen one day a year.

We also have an advent calendar we made when the kids were tiny. It’s has their painted handprints on (and ours) and we wrap up the same toys every year and tie one to each day - half the days are toys and the other half are sweets.

We do have Santa but tbh he’s not the main part of our day and it would be just as special without it. People go a bit Gaga for F.C. sometimes. I don’t think it’s that big a deal.

we don't 'do' father christmas. never did.
christmas is still special and magical.
decorations, candles, tree, home baking.
festive meal with family, church service, carol singing, presents, christmas cards...

The pair of you need to talk and possibly include his parents in it. "MIL can you believe he doesn't want to do Santa for DS" hopefully a bit of pressure and wanting to repeat the experience for GC will help.

Interesting my mum's view of how she did Christmas differs from mine.
Mum's logic, I'll wait and put the gifts out once kids are in bed, avoids kids poking at them. And saves me having to move them to hoover the floor on Christmas Eve.
Kid logic, we went to bed living room was bare, got up lots of gifts, Santa delivered them!

Your DH sounds like a joyless arse. Honestly, I think F.C. is pretty hard to avoid. What will you say to your son about how not to give away the secret to other children once he starts school? Or will you just not do presents at all? It doesn't have to be all about piles of presents. There's so many fun activities that go along with Christmas - decorating the tree, leaving carrots out for reindeer, watching Christmas movies, carols, a nice dinner on Christmas Day, a walk on Christmas morning.

I wouldn't focus too much on him comparing what he got to other kids. They don't really do that until they're 6,7,8,9 and, by that point, we explained that Santa bought basic presents but, if children wanted more, then parents have to pay. Also, in our house, the elves only make toys. They can't make electronic gadgets like tablets. Mums and Dads have to buy them in the shops and then send them to Santa. That explains any differences.

You could go to a pound shop, spend £20 and have a huge pile of presents from a 2 year olds point of view. Or plan early for next year and spend £10 a month on toys you see in the sales. I hunt for bargains all year round. Charity shops for things that look new, sales, Facebook selling sites. This year, I got my son a remote control car from John Lewis for £10 - another Mum was selling it brand new and original cost was £25. Also, in their sale, electronic science kits for both kids, reduced from £10 to a fiver.
If you really want to do FC, go for it and tell your DH that he needs to pull out the stops and smile for his kid!

Or pack your DH off to his parents for Xmas. He can be as miserable as he likes there.
My other half moans every year about all the stuff my kids get. But it's not his decision because he doesn't get involved in any of it. It's me that books and pays for the pantomime, organises all of the pressies and pays for them, buys and cooks all of the Xmas food. Organises all the secs and arranges all the activities or Xmas Dec making etc.
My kids get alot of gifts but half of it are things I would buy them anyway - new toothbrush, socks, clothes, drinks cups for school etc. Other stuff are bargains. 10 years ago a local toy shop was selling stuff like Knex and Barbie at knock down prices about 10% of what they originally cost as they were closing down. I spent about £100 there buying all sorts of toys and stuck them in my loft. Every year my kids have had some of this stuff for Xmas/birthdays. This year my 8 yo boy will be getting the Knex bucket that cost me peanuts (when I was earning 40k a year - earn less than a quarter of that now) and, in today's money, would cost about £30 so looks like a substantial gift.

I don’t think I ever found birthdays magical. Exciting, fun and special but not magical.

We were skint growing up, and Christmases were sparse but the excitement of tiptoeing downstairs to see if santa had come was the highlight of my childhood.

I’m lucky to be able to afford to buy what my dc need and a fair amount of what they want but I’m not convinced that their Christmases are as good as mine were. There are many things that money can’t buy.

I did wonder as a child why Santa was so generous to the most obnoxious kid in the class. But I thought he was a bit of a confused old man tbh. There wasn’t any other reason to think I was bad or naughty.

I don’t agree with but I can respect some of the reasons people give for not doing santa, but not being able to afford it seems like a thin excuse

Christmas is magical for a 2 year old! Helping to decorate the tree, presents appearing in pretty paper. I still remember Boxing Day when my oldest was 2, she couldn't believe her eyes when she came down and things were still there!
You don't have to spend much to make it happen, he won't know or care how much was spent.
I would be telling DH to suck it up or clear off for the big day. He is incredibly selfish, especially now you say he had amazing Christmases himself! But won't make a minimum effort for his son and doesn't want you too either. Sounds vile.

You can do FC without spending much at all - a few little things in a stocking. Especially when they're little, there are plenty of cheap things they'll like. You really don't have to have the vast pile of presents many people seem to think necessary now.
I don't see why your grumpy dh should put the kybosh on your little one experiencing the magic. Tell him to Scrooge off!

FC doesn't have to cost much at all. A stocking full of small gifts can be inexpensive.

Knowledge of FC cannot be avoided, unless you keep you dc from other dcs and don't send them to school. Not making a big deal of FC is a completely different thing from saying FC isn't real... you'd have to think very carefully about whether you want to be that parent, when you dc is old enough to talk to other dc and young enough that they all believe.

FC is a group conspiracy. There is a degree of compulsion to go along with it, for the sake of the other dcs, whatever you might have preferred to do with your own dc.

My children (8 and 6) have outright told me how much nicer it is to receive presents from their loving family than some imaginary guy.

We do lots of magical stuff around christmas. None of it involves lying to them or telling them they’re being watched

Magic is about spending time with people you love and like, being welcoming and inclusive, eating special food together, music, decorations etc. The sense of occasion.

I really don't think there's a part in it for someone being deliberately curmudgeonly though. I really would send him elsewhere, team up with other family members, or do a joint thing with friends and enjoy yourselves.

Why not do a stocking anyway and you can all be amazed on Christmas morning. “where did that come from?” “Who brought you that?” You don’t ever have to mention Father Christmas but it would still be magical for your DS. I wouldn’t tell your DH - if he’s really awful, he’ll reveal your secret but it won’t really spoil it for your son who will still have the presents. But you can stick to the letter of your agreement and not pretend it’s from FC, while your son still gets a “magical” surprise.

If you do want to do the whole FC thing with your child and he doesn't why does his decision trump yours???

I think you need to get to the bottom of dh’s Scroogeness. Could you do an activity a day to celebrate the season rather than piling on the pressure for one big day - so as others have suggested baking, craft, walks etc but staying away from visiting Santa or over commercialised stuff. sometimes seeing how a child reacts to the lights in the neighbourhood or the excitement over gingerbread houses can soften hearts
Fwiw we did low key FC - never embellished or even told a story - just did a little stocking with bits and pieces and let the dc believe what they wanted to believe (although I did get into a pickle with the tooth fairy).

I love Christmas and the stocking was probably my favourite part so I want my children to enjoy it too but cost does add up. I buy loads second hand from Facebook marketplace/local selling pages, I add necessities like new underwear and socks, visit pound land and flying tiger, found the site toysforapound on the bargain thread in 'Christmas' on here and buy bargains as I see them.

I never believed in FC because my older sibling told me it wasn't real when I was 3, and no parent attempted to convince me otherwise. Christmas was still magical and the stocking placed on my bed when I was sleeping by my mum was still the most exciting bit. I never felt Christmas was ruined. This influenced my decision to be honest when my 3 year old asked me if FC was really real. I told them it wasn't, as I'd always said I'd be honest if ever asked directly. At the time they were fine about it but when they were older they were really cross with me for it and wished they believed. I also had a lot of contempt from other parents. Not because my child told theirs, they were good with not doing so, but I was told several times I was cruel so I do think I did the wrong thing now.

When I was a child the magic of want a was the best bit, didn't reallyatyer what he brought it was the magic I loved and to be honest Christmas has never been the same side I stopped believing 😂. Still love Christmas though. Oh my youngest believes in want a now, hopefully it last a a few more years!
Your dh should really just get a grip and stop being a scrodge.

I know it's not quite the point of the thread but gifts from Santa (or any gifts) don't have to be expensive to be magical. Martin Lewis's perennial favourite of a large box filled with balloons is always a winner. My Ds always brought sticks home from walks and I would never let him keep them, one year all he wanted from Santa was a stick. He got a stick and was delighted.

Charity shops are a treasure trove of toys and games for a fraction of their retail price. Whack a mole cost £2 last year and the play value has been immense.

Now that my DCs are older their favourite thing is our £5 secret santa that has to be bought in our local market town on Christmas Eve morning. Pick a name out of a hat, go shopping, buy your gift, meet for coffee and mince pies/mulled wine after an hour. We exchange those gifts at lunchtime on Christmas day and it is always hilarious.

Tell your DH to find some festive spirit.

It's not the price tag on the gifts that makes Christmas magical!!!

OMG OP you should totally do Santa.. it doesn’t have to be about volume or stuff! You can make it that Santa brings sweets, a token, or just pops by to check your presents! But it’s a huge part of the magic and my DD’s have given us so much joy in their reactions... it doesn’t have to be materialistic. My DD1’s favourite present last year was a ball in a cup I put in her stocking 😂

On a practical note, if you do santa is there any danger that he would reveal the truth?

I can't imagine how angry I'd be if my DP didn't want to do the FC deal this was 100% the best part of my childhood and I couldn't wait to create that magic for my babies!

I'd go ahead and do it. He doesn't have to actively be involved if he wants to be miserable about it, so long as he isn't bitter enough to ruin it! I think you'd regret not doing it in a few years when you had the chance if you are wanting to!

Santa is a big part of christmas imo- what abiut haning the stocking, leaving out biscuits and a carrot for Rudolph, following Santa ofn the Norad tracker, I would bake biscuits on christmas eve with my kids, decorate them and one especially for Santa.
Rushing down in the morning to see if he had been, see the biscuit crumbs on the fireplace.

Santa makes christmas special.

Do the people who say Father Christmas was the best bit of their childhood really mean that? I mean, I have memories of being very excited and waking up to feel the bumpy stocking on the bed, but I have memories too of me and my cousins feeling all the presents under the tree and going up to Oxford Street to look at the Christmas shop windows. But it seems a bit sad to reduce the best bits of your childhood to half a dozen nights/mornings. Christmas is fun and exciting and so are birthdays, holidays, parties, sleepovers....

We did FC with ours but I simply don't understand the compulsion people seem to have to 'make Christmas magical'. There are lots of fun and special moments at Christmas without the FC myth - decorations, lights, carol concerts, parties, presents, school fairs, food, family....