Gaby no i wasnt given the numbers (most likely because i didnt ask for them) and i didnt ask doctors to clarify their protocols from each and every type of diabetes, there was no need. I have given this fairly sweeping statement (do as your doctors say) based on my own fairly extensive by now experience and what i am going through right now plus other womens that i meet through the clinics that i attend. I think that you are right to point out that there is almost certainly a differentiation in risk factor according to the severity of of diabetes but no this was never pointed out to me. As i have stated before, the reason that all of my girls were born at 37 weeks was because i was treated exactly the same at the end of each pregnancy and from what i can tell attending the diabetes clinic each week and the joint obstetric clinic every two weeks currently other women are the same. We do chat and i can honestly say that even the ones who are reluctant to be induced appear to understand the risks of macrosomia, stillbirth and shoulder dystocia to them and their babies regardless of the type of diabetes that they have.
To pick up on a point as well, it was explained to me that the only reason that stillbirth is more of a risk when your blood sugars are poorly controlled at conception is because of malformation of the heart, the hospital i am at now (Swindon Great Western) does a routine cardiac scan on all ladies from 24 weeks found to have early onset GD or as in my case pre existing type 2 diabetes. Once this has been done from what i can gather (and believe me i do still ask lots of questions even though this is my 4th diabetic pregnancy) then the risk becomes nominal. i asked this because my blood sugars must have been really quite high at conception and i was very worried because obviously i didnt know that i had diabetes and i had had a miscarriage last Novemember at 11 weeks. Once this was done though the doctor told me that i had as good a chance as any diabetic lady of not having a stillbirth due to high blood sugars at conception.
I can only relay what i am told at clinic by the people that look after me, clinicians have differing opinions and the way that they look after women i would hazard a guess is much of a muchness in view of the fact that they have to follow medical guidelines and to be honest i do pretty much as im told just because i dont want to put my son at any sort of risk.
All of my caregivers across the last 16 years have said that i need to be induced at 37 weeks ( bar this one who is more comfortable with a 38 week delivery ) because of having diabetes, obviously they know that in some cases its been fairly mild GD and for example in my third its been quite early on and has quickly become insulin dependent, so yes that to me says that the protocols surrounding most of the types of diabetes that you can get apart from the more serious type one elicit the same response, early delivery.
I completely understand your view that not all pregnancys are the same and i think that it is a good thing that you are well informed enough to make the decision with your consultants to go ahead and wait till 41 weeks and 40 weeks respectively but i believe that for me and probably for alot of women the risks of stillbirth/macrosomia are too much to take and would not choose this option even if it is such a small risk as you state. If you are closely monitored and you are happy as are your consultants to go past the 40 week mark then that is fair enough but the OP asked for experiences and opinions and if she puts together yours, mine,squidgys and anyone else who decides to post on here combined with her consultants i believe she will most likely come to the same kind of outcome as MOST women who are diagnosed with GD, which is the early delivery of her baby.
Your earlier post of doctors being clear about the risks posed to your baby with respiritory problems if delivered before 39 weeks should be a matter of course and i cannot for the life of me think why this has never been pointed out to either myself or anyone i know with diabetes. As i have said i was always under the impression that a pregnancyfull term was 37 weeks and that delivery was relatively safe from then onwards. I can only surmise that the reason that doctors perhaps dont point out the risks of delivery at 37 weeks (and this is one ill have ask my doctors about next week) is because they consider it to be more dangerous for a diabetic woman to continue with her pregnancy past 37/38 weeks than to deliver her baby a bit later and negate any breathing problems?
Im not going to split hairs and say that each and everyone of my consultants over the last 16 years has said outright that every type of diabetes should warrant the need for early delivery, its just that i have had two of the three types now and have been told the same thing for each of them. So have all of the women who i know from my clinics so yes obviously we arent as informed as you of the statistical numbers involved for early/late induction of late onset diet controlled diabetes but as you have pointed out the risk factors obviously will vary hugely. If anyone else reading this thread has this condition diagnosed then it is something that they can take up with their doctors because ultimately thats what counts and nothing that you or i will say will make much difference. You are saying do not take for granted the fact that you HAVE to have an early delivery as it depends on the severity of your diabetes and i am saying that from what i can gather experience wise MOST doctors will ask that you deliver relatively early to negate the risks that we have discussed above.