Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Infant feeding

Get advice and support with infant feeding from other users here.

Accurate studies of Breast/ Bottle pros and cons

110 replies

dyzzidi · 26/05/2005 08:32

HI. I really don't want a huge debate as I feel that has been done already. I am hoping some of you can post links to clinical studies of the pro's and cons. I have not made my mind up what I am going to do but would like to read some clinical research before I decide and would like to read a few different studies.

I believe it is such a personal choice that most peoples views will be slightly biased.

Sorry i do not intend to offend any of you.

OP posts:
mogwai · 12/06/2005 22:45

that makes sense

It's hard not to poke in if you feels there's misinformation

Hadn't thought of that

hunkermunker · 12/06/2005 22:50

Also, as I said in my first post on this thread (I'm very wise and can see the future and how threads will end up, y'see ) - what are pros for one mum may very well be cons for another, both with breast and bottlefeeding.

For instance, I knew that I could not be arsed with making up bottles, washing them, sterilising them, etc - so, in order to have the labour-saving when DS was a bit older, I went through five weeks of pain to establish breastfeeding. I know now that it hurt because I'd not got the right info re breastfeeding, but it did strike me as ironic that I was prepared to put up with it hurting so I didn't have to wash bottles!

moondog · 12/06/2005 22:58

Hunker,are you still around (stupid question?!)
I've finished breastfeeding now . It's been three days since ds partook (11 months) and dd accidentally thawed all my EBM.

End of an era eh???? sigh

pupuce · 12/06/2005 23:00

Sympathy Moondog

hunkermunker · 12/06/2005 23:00

Yes, I'm still here - aw, hun - how are you? End of an era, as you say! xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

moondog · 12/06/2005 23:03

Ah,thanks girls. He hasn't been interested for about 3 months tbh,but I persisted with a morning one (which took about 3 mins lol!)until it became obvious that he wasn't fussed. Sooo different to his sister,who went for it for 2 1/2 years. Still,bought myself lots of nice new clothes to mark the moment.

That's it for me,no more babies!

hunkermunker · 12/06/2005 23:05

Ooh - a new wardrobe! That should soften things a bit

Seriously though, hun, sympathy - not sure how I'll feel about DS stopping - he still usually loves his morning feed, but the night-time one's getting shorter (and Saturdays and Wednesdays he doesn't have it as I'm at work!).

JulieF · 12/06/2005 23:40

Mee too moondog, I stopped breastfeeding ds when I had to go away on a training course 2 weeks ago. i ame back and he had one feed but has not been interested at all since then.

No more babies for me either.

It really does feel like the end of an era.

Maisiemog · 13/06/2005 20:01

Long Post - Dyzzidi congratulations on your forthcoming adventure. I totally sympathise with your worries. It's hard to imagine how you will cope with the impact of the birth, but there's every chance you will cope fantastically. I found it was amazing what I managed to cope with.
I'm wondering if you would be able to put off having the myemectomy until later on, rather than get into a big operation immediately, at least that way you will have less to worry about at a stressful time. And you would get to focus on bonding with your baby without having to stress about your partner coping.
Just curious, but is the arranged section a consequence of the fibroid?
I have a large c 20cm fibroid and basically, it was monitored throughout my pregnancy with the possibility of a section hovering. There was talk of removing the fibroid at the same time, which worried me, as I didn't want to loose a lot of blood. I ended up going into spontaneous labour in the 37th week and didn't need a section. Having a fibroid removed was the last thing on my mind at the time. I'm going back in for a myemectomy in July, and I feel happier that I am doing things in this order. Now I've got breastfeeding sorted, after a bumpy start and feel happy that I can express milk whilst in hospital and maybe top up with formula, plus my ds is weaning now anyway (7months).
I had to express immediately for my baby because he was jaundiced and didn't latch on immediately. So it can be done and my dp fed him when I was expressing, but I HAD to do that and it made the whole thing much more time-consuming than it needed to be.
My baby was mixed fed for the first ten weeks until I finally managed to breast feed exclusively.
For me, the main pros of bottle feeding, were knowing how much the baby is getting, that you can get someone else to do it, and that you don't feel nervous about feeding in public, and of course as my baby's good health was maintained by formula at the start - so invaluable if there are feeding problems which compromise the baby's health.
The cons, for me, were worrying that my baby wasn't receiving immediate immunity and protection from illnesses in the long-term (see piles of research), also loosing track of how long formula has been out of the fridge and worrying whether it was still sterile and ok for use (and running out), having to wait for the steriliser whilst the baby wails and so on and having to wait for the kettle for water and then having to wait for it to cool.
Don't worry about the amount of help you will receive in hospital, If you are stuck in a ward with your baby, as I was for 8 days you will find that you will always be able to get help with all of the physical aspects of feeding, pain relief etc...so don't worry about that, there is a buzzer system and you will get a super fast, willing response.
You will however need support at home, regardless of how you choose to feed.
One benefit of breastfeeding is that your periods often take months to return, so if you had problems in that area because of the fibroid then it might help.
My consultant at the hospital said he thought breast feeding might help to reduce the fibroid, as the oestrogen levels are so low. In addition to this I have been taking Zoladex for the past two months in preparation for the op in July. This will hopefully reduce the fibroid and reduce the bleeding. Do you think this would be an option for you?
You sound as if you are trying to control a scarily, uncontrollable situation. Don't worry too much, I managed to distract myself by buying everything I could conceivably need on Ebay. It paid off and I've sold the stuff that was never used (on Ebay). Including my Dr Brown's anti-colic bottles (just in case)
Finally, make sure your doctors and midwives keep an eye on your bowels. I had BIG problem with my bladder because of the fibroid. Make a fuss if necessary - if I had known of the risks I would have.
If you want to ask me anything about my experiences please feel free to CAT me.

zebraZ · 14/06/2005 07:39

End of an Era: am still feeding DS but stopped expressing for him a month ago. Feels really funny. Am even selling our chest freezer (only bought it so I could be a milk donor, and kept it to store EBM after that).

About periods not coming back, I filled in the survey for the Breakthru Generations study last week and was really surprised they didn't ask about lactational amenorrhea. They did ask about weeks spent breastfeeding (was pleased to see they at least went to 3 digits in the little boxes...) but not "did you not have periods for a while due to breastfeeding?" Just seemed like an obvious oversight. I've had a year off of periods each time... quite nice.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page